TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 9 · «We Have No Business with Hidden Things»

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous part we looked at the Alter Rebbe's hagahah (gloss) in this chapter, and at the three tzimtzumim through which the ten sefiros came into being and in which the divine light is revealed. Now we come to a further foundation: the Holy One Himself does not change in the slightest, we are the ones who change. When we speak of «before the tzimtzum» and «after the tzimtzum», we are describing our own perception and our emunah; because if we want to speak of the Creator as He is in and of Himself, the tzimtzum accomplished nothing in Him, it did not «color» Him in any color at all, and He remains entirely abstracted from every description.

Think of a clear glass vessel that has been painted red, into which clear water is poured. Whoever looks at the water through that vessel sees red water: it looks red, it acts upon its surroundings as something red, it casts a red reflection, and every property that the color is capable of producing it will produce as red. And at the very same time, in itself the water has remained clear and transparent, not tinted with any color whatsoever; the only reason it appears red is that it was poured into a red vessel.

Now picture two people arguing, one insisting «the water is red» and the other insisting «it is completely clear». Both of them are right. The one speaking about the water as it is in itself, apart from the way it is revealed through the vessel, is right that it has remained clear, transparent water; and the one speaking about how the water acts once it has entered the vessel and operates through it, is right that it is red. And with this the dispute between the Rambam and the Maharal is resolved as well.

Once the light has clothed itself in the keilim:

In the words of the Tanya itself: «והנה אחר שנתלבש האור אין סוף בבחינות כלים דחכמה בינה ודעת», «And behold, after the Or Ein Sof has clothed itself in the keilim of Chochmah, Binah and Daas». The infinite divine light in itself remains abstract; but once it has been revealed in the ten sefiros of the world of Atzilus, «אז שייך מה שכתב הרמב"ם: הוא היודע והוא המדע והוא הידוע ובידיעת עצמו וכו'», «then what the Rambam wrote applies: He is the Knower, He is the Knowledge, and He is the Known, and by knowing Himself, etc.» Precisely after the tzimtzum, after the descent and the revelation within the ten sefiros, one can say of Him that He is the Knower and He is the Known, and, in the Rambam's words, that by knowing Himself He knows all that exists.

«לפי שבחינת כלים דאצילות», «for the aspect of the keilim of Atzilus», keilim being a metaphorical name for the ten sefiros, «נעשים נשמה וחיות לבריאה יצירה עשייה ולכל אשר בהם», «become the soul and the life-force of Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah and of everything in them». In other words, what enlivens each and every detail of creation is He Himself. It is not as even some of the sages of Israel supposed, that the Holy One remains, as it were, in His palace and supervises from a distance, as if by remote control, what is happening elsewhere. Even in the lowest of places, in that very «garbage heap», the King Himself is there and He Himself is the one acting. And the tzimtzum is the explanation of how this is done: He Himself is revealed in the ten sefiros, and by this means He gives life to all the worlds and to everything in them.

«But without the tzimtzum and the clothing in the keilim»:

«אבל בלי צמצום והלבשה הנזכר לעיל לא שייך כלל לומר הוא היודע והוא המדע והוא הידוע», «But without the aforementioned tzimtzum and clothing, it is not at all applicable to say that He is the Knower, He is the Knowledge and He is the Known». This is like the water that has not been placed in the glass, which cannot be described by any description at all. The Creator was not «tinted» with a color and did not become chochmah; in Himself He is abstracted from every attribute, and just as one cannot say of Him that He is a table, so one cannot say of Him that He is wise.

And here is the difference between the two modes of revelation. Within physical reality the Holy One reveals Himself in such a way that the reality feels itself cut off from Him, and therefore we never call Him by the names of physical objects. His revelation within the ten sefiros, by contrast, is a revelation of genuine ha'atzalah, an emanation from Him, and therefore He can indeed be called by those names. But in Himself: «כי אינו בבחינת וגדר דעת ומדע כלל חס ושלום, אלא למעלה מעלה עילוי רב עד אין קץ אפילו מבחינת וגדר חכמה, עד שבחינת חכמה נחשבת אצלו יתברך כבחינת עשייה גשמית», «for He is not in the category or definition of knowledge and knowing at all, heaven forfend, but is infinitely higher and more exalted even than the category and definition of chochmah, to the point that the level of chochmah is considered before Him like the level of physical action».

So it turns out that the teaching of Chassidus is what mediates between the approach of the Rambam and the approach of the Maharal, and it is set out plainly right here in the hagahah: how things stand without the tzimtzum, and how they stand as a result of the tzimtzum.

«Ihu vegarmohi chad»:

Let us return to the closing passage of the chapter. The upshot of everything said so far is that the Holy One reveals Himself within the ten sefiros, and therefore He can be called by their names, because the ten sefiros come about by way of hamshachah and ha'atzalah, drawing down and emanation, exactly as we learned in the hagahah: through the three tzimtzumim the ten sefiros came into being, and He is revealed in them.

But here is the difficulty. The ten sefiros, which came into being only after tremendous tzimtzumim, are limited and defined, while the One revealed in them is the Unlimited. How can the limitation of Chochmah, Binah and Daas, of Chessed, Gevurah and Tiferes, contain the Creator's very Essence in full? Of this union the well known phrase is said, «איהו וגרמוהי חד», «He and His 'limbs' are one», He and the sefiros are one: two opposites together. The Creator remains abstracted from everything, and at the same time He is present in all His unlimited power inside the tzimtzum of the ten limited, defined sefiros.

And this is not comparable to the analogy of a body and a soul. In that analogy the body does not become soul-like; it remains physical, and the Holy One joined the two so that the soul enlivens the body. That analogy fits the divine life-force found in physical things, in stones, in earth, in inanimate matter and in every physical creation, where the Holy One gives life to something physical just as a soul gives life to a body. But here something far deeper is being said: the ten sefiros are something defined and limited, and nevertheless they are literally Elokus, to the point that He is called by their names.

«We have no business with hidden things»:

How are these two opposites reconciled? The Alter Rebbe does not come here to offer an intellectual explanation; he states outright that the mind cannot absorb this paradox: «והנה אין לנו עסק בנסתרות», «Behold, we have no business with hidden things». Note this well: regarding the earlier question, about hamshachah and ha'atzalah, he did not say «we have no business with hidden things», but gave an explanation, the three tzimtzumim, and that is something we can understand. But how the limited and the unlimited are joined, that cannot be understood. Whatever can be understood, we are obligated to understand; and what cannot be understood, «we have no business with hidden things».

«אך הנגלות לנו להאמין אמונה שלמה דאיהו וגרמוהי חד», «But what is revealed to us is to believe with complete faith that He and His 'limbs' are one». «Ihu» is He Himself in all His power, and «garmohi» are His sefiros, and they are one with Him: the sefiros, though they are ten limited sefiros, are Elokus to the degree that He is called by their names. This is utterly incomprehensible: if they are limited, how can the Unlimited be named by them? But the answer is that He is revealed in them with all His power, to the point that one can say of Him that He is «wise». As he spells it out: «דהיינו מידותיו של הקב"ה ורצונו וחכמתו ובינתו ודעתו הם חד עם מהותו ועצמותו המרומם לבדו רוממות אין קץ מבחינת חכמה ושכל והשגה», «that is, the middos of the Holy One and His will and His chochmah and His binah and His daas are one with His Essence and Being, which alone is exalted with infinite exaltation above the level of chochmah, intellect and comprehension». All ten sefiros together with the Will are one with His Essence and Being: He is infinitely exalted above them, and at the same time one with them, in such a way that they are Elokus, limited and abstract at once.

«ולכן, גם ייחודו שמתייחד עם מידותיו שהאציל מאתו יתברך גם כן אינו בבחינת השגה», «And therefore, even the manner of His unity, the way He unites with the middos that He emanated from Himself, is likewise not in the category of comprehension». Since He is exalted above everything, the very way He unites with them is entirely beyond our grasp. We look at everything through our own glasses and try to understand it as we see it, and those glasses always create separation. Imagine all the waters of the ocean placed inside a cup, with the cup remaining a cup and the whole ocean inside it: the mind cannot tolerate it. And there both sides are limited, the ocean's limit being large and the cup's limit being small, and already we cannot grasp how a large limit enters a small one. Here we are speaking not merely of the unlimited, but of the source of the unlimited, the very Essence of the Creator, which is above any concept of limited or unlimited, and it is present in all its power inside the limitation of the ten sefiros, and they remain ten and remain abstract. That short sentence, «ihu vegarmohi chad», is beyond our power to understand.

«Raza dimheimnusa»:

«ולכן נקראו מדותיו של הקב"ה, הן הספירות, בזוהר הקדוש: רזא דמהימנותא», «And therefore the middos of the Holy One, namely the sefiros, are called in the holy Zohar 'raza dimheimnusa'», the secret of faith, «שהיא האמונה שלמעלה מן השכל», «which is the faith that is above intellect». For if one looks at the sefiros as a limited reality of ten sefiros, that is not their true nature; their true essence is the Creator's own Essence. And if so, why are they called sefiros at all? To this there is no intellectual answer, only emunah. The essence of the sefiros is emunah to such a degree that this is precisely their name in the Zohar: «raza dimheimnusa», the secret of faith, something intellect cannot grasp.

Worth citing here is the explanation of the Tzemach Tzedek on the verse «מכון לשבתך פעלת ה'», «a foundation for Your dwelling place, which You have made, O G-d». The sefiros are a «machon», a foundation and a vessel, «leshivtecha», for You Yourself to dwell in them. And how is such a thing possible? «Pa'alta Hashem», only You can bring it about. This is the concept of «ihu vegarmohi chad» in the language of Kabbalah, expressed in the language of the verse «machon leshivtecha pa'alta Hashem».

In summary: in this part we learned that the Holy One does not change, and that all the expressions «before the tzimtzum» and «after the tzimtzum» are said from our side. Through the analogy of the water in the painted glass we resolved the dispute between the Rambam and the Maharal: once the light has clothed itself in the keilim of Chabad it is applicable to say «He is the Knower, He is the Knowledge and He is the Known», and the keilim of Atzilus become the soul and life-force of all the worlds; but without the tzimtzum and the clothing He is not in the category of knowledge and knowing at all, and the level of chochmah is considered before Him like physical action. We further learned that the ten sefiros are limited, and nonetheless they are Elokus, «ihu vegarmohi chad», a union of two opposites that the mind cannot grasp, and therefore «we have no business with hidden things» but only to believe with complete faith; and for this reason the sefiros are called in the Zohar «raza dimheimnusa», as the Tzemach Tzedek explains in the verse «machon leshivtecha pa'alta Hashem».

In the next part we will continue our study of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah.