TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 9 · A Pause to Review

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

We have arrived at the final section of chapter 9. Last week we stopped at the beginning of the hagahah (the Alter Rebbe's own gloss) printed on page 87. In this part we will finish the gloss and complete the chapter, but first let us briefly review the material covered in the earlier sections.

A reminder: how can the Holy One be called «wise»?

The verse states «כולם בחכמה עשית», «You have made them all with wisdom». The sefirah of chochmah, which for created beings is the loftiest and most refined thing there is, is reckoned relative to the Holy One as mere asiyah, mere doing. For human beings the gap between the world of intellect and the world of action is enormous, an ein aroch (an utter incomparability), and the verse comes to teach that relative to the Holy One even the sefirah of chochmah has no value at all.

If so, how can we apply to Him the title «wise»? After all, it would never occur to anyone to call the Holy One a «table», a physical object from the world of action that has no connection whatsoever to the Creator. And according to what we just said, the title «wise» stands in that very same ein aroch, since chochmah too has no value relative to Him. And yet we do use this title, as in the well known formulation of the Rambam: «הוא היודע והוא הידוע והוא המדע», «He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge».

The explanation: He is the source of chochmah

The core of the explanation we learned is that the Holy One is the source of chochmah, and therefore He can be called «wise». But this needs clarifying: He is equally the source of the table and of the stone, since «ממך הכל», «everything comes from You», and nevertheless we do not call Him «table» or «stone». The difference lies in the manner in which these things came into revelation: chochmah was drawn down and emanated from Him, whereas the other creations are in the category of «yesh», independent existence.

When the Holy One created the world and emanated and revealed all the powers and matters He wished to reveal, the truth is that everything created, formed and revealed is an ein aroch relative to Him and takes up no space at all. Yet together with this, the Holy One arranged that things would be revealed in two different ways:

  • Creation «yesh me'ayin», something from nothing: things in which the incomparability is felt, in which it is evident that they have no connection to Him. This «yesh» is a distant yesh; in itself and by its very nature it experiences itself as detached. Therefore the Creator cannot be called by any of the names of these creations.

  • Hamshachah and atzilus, drawing down and emanation: things made in such a way that one senses that they belong to Him, that they are G-dly, that they were emanated from Him. They too are an ein aroch, yet the relationship between source and result, between the giver and the receiver, is perceptible in them. For this reason there is no obstacle to calling the higher one by the name of the lower.

The term «atzilus» is taken from the verse «ואצלתי מן הרוח אשר עליך ושמתי עליהם», «I shall draw from the spirit that is upon you and place it upon them». The Holy One told Moshe Rabbeinu to transfer some of the spirit of prophecy resting upon him to the seventy elders he had gathered. There one could sense that the very same thing that was by Moshe passed over to the elders, and that is the meaning of ha'atzalah, emanation.

At the end of the previous page, just before the gloss, the Alter Rebbe writes: «ודרך ועניין ההמשכה והאצילות איך ומה ידוע למשכילים», «and the way and the nature of this drawing down and emanation, how and what it is, is known to the maskilim».

We mentioned the analogy of a person speaking words of wisdom on a high level who must bring them down to a student far simpler than himself. The words of wisdom that come down to the student are on a lower level, yet the relationship between teacher and student remains perceptible: by the teacher it is an intellectual matter, and when it descends to the student's level it is still an intellectual matter, only on a lower level. And if the student then brings the material down to someone who understands less than he does, the drawing down and the relationship are still visible.

But it could never happen that through many successive descents, from student to student to student, something entirely different would emerge at the end. If the subject under discussion is houses and stones, an actual stone will never emerge at the final level, since a stone and an intellectual concept are two worlds with no relationship between them. What will emerge is a lower and lower level of intellect, but even the lowest of the low will remain intellect, will remain spiritual.

This is tzimtzum as we know it within our own frame of reference: however much a thing is constricted, it always remains within the same proportion and the same domain. In our world of concepts there is no such thing as a tzimtzum in which something descends and becomes something else entirely.

The wonder of hamshachah and atzilus

The wonder is not that the Holy One produced a physical reality. He is all capable, and He created yesh me'ayin. But there we do not say that physical reality came about through hishtalshelus, through a gradual chain of descent; there it is an absolute leap, an ein aroch with no relationship at all. The wonder concerns chochmah, binah and da'as and all ten sefiros, whose process of emerging from the Creator is called «hamshachah and ha'atzalah», meaning that they were drawn down in a way that allows us to say that they belong to Him.

This is something we do not grasp, for in our world of concepts every tzimtzum and every descent is proportional, whereas here we are speaking of a descent that is not proportional at all and bears no relationship whatsoever, and of that very descent we say «hamshachah», a drawing down. To call it creation yesh me'ayin is understandable; to call it hamshachah and atzilus, that is the question. And this is precisely the Alter Rebbe's question: what sort of special tzimtzum is this, in which something is produced that has no value relative to its source, and nevertheless we say of it that it came through a drawing down and a descent?

To this the Alter Rebbe answers: «ידוע למשכילים», «it is known to the maskilim». This is a matter that can be grasped intellectually, but not by ordinary human intellect; rather by the intellect of the teachings of Kabbalah, the teachings of the inner Torah and the teachings of Chassidus. There the process is explained, along with the various kinds of tzimtzum that produce a descent by way of a leap and a jump between levels that are an ein aroch to one another, and which is nevertheless called hamshachah and atzilus: that despite the discontinuity and the leap between levels, there is a continuum here.

The gloss: three stages of tzimtzum

In the gloss the Alter Rebbe notes: «סוד הצמצום באור אין סוף ברוך הוא, וצמצום א״ק (אדם קדמון), וסוד הדיקנא», «the secret of the tzimtzum within the Or Ein Sof, and the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon, and the secret of the dikna». These are three stages of tzimtzum that produced this state of hamshachah and atzilus. Let us begin with the concept of Adam Kadmon, and through it we will understand the matter.

«Adam» is a name for the Holy One. Why do we call Him that? Because «adam» is a term describing a structure of ten faculties. We are called «adam» from the phrase «אדמה לעליון», «I shall resemble the One above», an expression of likeness, because we resemble Him; and He is called «adam» because He brought forth the ten sefiros, and this configuration of ten sefiros is called «adam».

Within this level called «adam» itself there are stages: there is an «adam» corresponding to the world of atzilus, and there is a level that precedes it, «Adam Kadmon».

Adam Kadmon: the potential for the ten sefiros

«Adam Kadmon» (abbreviated A״K) is the potential for the world of atzilus. A potential already exists here, and for that reason this level is called «adam»; but since it does not yet contain ten sefiros in actuality, the word «Kadmon», meaning prior, is added to it.

The four general worlds

In Chassidus this level has another name: «the general world of Beriah». Just as there are four worlds, atzilus, beriah, yetzirah and asiyah, in the particular order, so too they exist in the general view (on the macro scale): atzilus di'klalus, beriah di'klalus, yetzirah di'klalus and asiyah di'klalus. For comparison:

  • Atzilus di'klalus: the Or Ein Sof as it is before the tzimtzum.

  • Beriah di'klalus: the level of Adam Kadmon.

  • Asiyah di'klalus: the world of atzilus, which in the particular order is what we call by that name.

What «beriah» and «yetzirah» mean

Every world is built of four elements: fire, air, water and earth. These elements exist physically, and they exist in spiritual terms as well, as we already saw at the beginning of Tanya. When the four elements are present in a revealed way, when the distinction between them exists and they are felt, we have a reality shaped into the form of fire, air, water and earth. And there is a state in which these four stages are not yet present in their revealed form, but only their potential exists: room has been made for there to be four elements, while they themselves do not yet exist.

To put it simply: a lump of silver can take the shape of a goblet, the shape of a lamp, or any other shape. As long as it is raw material it has no form, yet it holds the potential for some form; and once the form has been fashioned in it, we have a goblet before us (and if it is melted down it returns to its earlier state). The potential for form is called «beriah», and the form itself is called «yetzirah». From here come the names of the worlds: the world of Beriah is the potential for the form that will come afterwards, and the world of Yetzirah is the form itself. In the world of Atzilus, by contrast, there is not yet even the potential.

With this we understand what «the general world of Beriah» means: the level of Adam Kadmon. On this level there is still no form, no ten sefiros, yet the possibility of there being ten sefiros has already come into being. Therefore it cannot be called simply «adam», since that name belongs to a level where there are ten sefiros in actuality; and on the other hand, since the potential for the ten sefiros already exists in it, it is related to them and is called «Adam Kadmon» or «beriah di'klalus».

The three tzimtzumim in the gloss

For the reality of Adam Kadmon to come into being at all, a process is required, since it was preceded by a state in which not even this level existed, nor the potential within it. That process is tzimtzum, and this is the content of the first line of the gloss:

  1. «סוד הצמצום באור אין סוף ברוך הוא», «the secret of the tzimtzum within the Or Ein Sof»: the first tzimtzum, which brought about the existence of Adam Kadmon, that is, the potential for the ten sefiros.

  2. «וצמצום אדם קדמון», «and the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon»: the level of Adam Kadmon itself required a further tzimtzum, to bring the potential from the potential state into actuality. Yet even after this tzimtzum there are still no ten sefiros in the plain sense, no chochmah, binah and da'as, since what is drawn down is still exceedingly lofty: this is the level of Kesser, which includes all ten sefiros, except that they have not yet come down into perceptible detail.

  3. «וסוד הדיקנא», «and the secret of the dikna»: the third tzimtzum, in which the light descends into the order of ten sefiros with their particulars.

«Sod ha'dikna»

«Dikna» means the hairs of the beard. In Derech Mitzvosecha of the Tzemach Tzedek, in the mitzvah of the shaving of the metzora, there is a fascinating maamar on the subject of hair: sometimes hair is considered something holy, and sometimes it is bound up with the opposite of holiness, with kelipos and impurity:

  • Hair of holiness: the peyos and the beard, and likewise the hair of the head of a nazir, of whom it is said «קדוש יהיה גדל פרע שער ראשו», «he shall be holy, letting the locks of the hair of his head grow long».

  • Hair that is the opposite: «מסלסל בשערו», «curling his hair», said of Yosef, and likewise the hair of a married woman's head, which she is obligated to cover, because «שיער באישה ערווה», «a woman's hair is ervah».

So what is the governing principle here? It is explained there that hair is something that carries vitality, except that the amount of vitality and energy in it is extremely small and constricted, so much so that one can cut a hair without any pain and without feeling a thing. Hair thus points to tzimtzum; and whether that tzimtzum is desirable depends on what is being constricted. Where constriction is needed, the tzimtzum is necessary and good; where there is no need for it, it is cumbersome, superfluous and nothing but an obstruction.

An illustration of this from the use of analogy: the purpose of an analogy is to bring an intellectual idea closer to the understanding of a simpler person, so an analogy is a form of tzimtzum. When the idea is deep and the listener cannot grasp it, the analogy is excellent; it brings the matter close, it is precious and we examine its details carefully. But when something plain and self evident has been said, as when one points to a table and then wants to explain by way of an analogy what it is, the words of the analogy are nothing but idle and superfluous talk.

Here we are dealing with tzimtzum of the good kind. «Sod ha'dikna» is an analogy teaching that this is a tzimtzum of the type of the hairs of the beard, which carry holiness, a tzimtzum of great importance, whose purpose is to bring the abstract supernal light down into the order of ten sefiros.

An interesting precision is brought in the Previous Rebbe's maamar on this gloss: regarding the first two tzimtzumim the Alter Rebbe explicitly uses the word «tzimtzum», «the secret of the tzimtzum within the Or Ein Sof» and «the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon»; but regarding the third he does not say «and the tzimtzum of the dikna» but rather «and the secret of the dikna», without mentioning the word tzimtzum at all. The reason: the leap from stage to stage in the first two is an enormous leap, whereas the descent from Kesser, which has already emerged into actuality, to the ten sefiros, though it too is a descent and a tzimtzum, is not of the same type. Therefore he did not call it a tzimtzum, in order to distinguish between the kind of descent in the first two levels and the kind of descent in the third.

It is worth noting that here we are speaking of only three tzimtzumim, and the matter is being presented in very broad strokes; once one enters into the details, there is an immense multitude of tzimtzumim and particulars. The Alter Rebbe formulates all of this in a line and a half, and on that line and a half whole volumes have been poured out in explanation.

«Hamshachah ve'ha'atzalah»

What emerges from all this? That we have before us a process of tzimtzum for which there is no parallel or analogy among us creations. As explained, among created beings the entire concept of tzimtzum exists only between things that bear some relationship and proportion to one another; here we are speaking of a leap in which there is no relationship and no proportion whatsoever, and of a drastic tzimtzum. And nevertheless, the entire process is called «hamshachah and ha'atzalah»: however much the result is an ein aroch to its source, and however many descents and tzimtzumim it has passed through, the ten sefiros of the world of atzilus are still G-dly. For this reason the Holy One can be called by the names of the sefiros, the Wise One, the Kind One, the Mighty One, and this involves no diminishment of Him. And this process is «known to the maskilim».

And what is the secret of all these tzimtzumim, that is, what is their purpose? «לצמצם האור שיתלבש בבחינת כלים די' ספירות», «to constrict the light so that it may become clothed in the vessels of the ten sefiros», so that the Holy One should reveal Himself within the ten sefiros, that He should be revealed in chochmah, in binah and in da'as.

This is not like the kind of tzimtzum involved in yesh me'ayin, which is a kind of severance and leap in which the «ayin» is not felt within the «yesh» that comes into being from it. The ten sefiros are a different kind of tzimtzum, one in which the very Essence and Being of the Creator is revealed within them, within the ten sefiros of the world of atzilus.

Resolving the dispute between the Rambam and the Maharal

With this the Alter Rebbe mediates between the view of the Maharal and the view of the Rambam, which we discussed at length in the earlier sections. The Maharal insists forcefully that the Holy One cannot be called by any name at all, and that any name applied to Him, even the finest and most exalted of names such as «wise», is a diminishment and does not apply to Him. The Rambam, on the other hand, holds that one can indeed say of Him that He is the Knowledge, the Knower and the Known; and the Alter Rebbe even went beyond the Rambam, saying that one can also call Him the Kind One and the Mighty One.

In light of what we have learned, the matter resolves itself: everything depends on whether we are speaking before the tzimtzumim or after them. Before the tzimtzumim, it is certainly impossible to call Him by any name at all; but after the tzimtzumim, through which He constricted Himself and brought about that He should be revealed within them, He can indeed be called by them. It turns out that the Maharal is speaking of before the tzimtzum, and the Rambam is speaking of after the tzimtzum.

To summarize: In this section we reviewed the question of how the Holy One can be called «wise», given that the verse «כולם בחכמה עשית» implies that even chochmah has no value relative to Him. We learned that the distinction between creations brought into being «yesh me'ayin», in which the severance is felt, and the sefiros that were drawn down and emanated from Him, in which the relationship is felt, is what makes it possible to call Him by the name of chochmah. We dwelt on the wonder of hamshachah and atzilus, a descent that is not proportional and yet contains a continuum, a matter that is «known to the maskilim» in the inner Torah. We then learned that the level of «Adam Kadmon» is the potential for the ten sefiros, and that it is «the general world of Beriah» among the four general worlds; we clarified the meaning of the names beriah and yetzirah (potential for form, and form in actuality) through the analogy of the lump of silver and the goblet; we enumerated the three tzimtzumim in the gloss, the tzimtzum within the Or Ein Sof, the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon which brings about the level of Kesser, and «sod ha'dikna» which brings the light down into the order of ten sefiros; we explained the idea of hair as tzimtzum, and the precision in the fact that the word tzimtzum is not used for the third. We also saw that «the secret of all these tzimtzumim» is that the Holy One should be revealed within the vessels of the ten sefiros, and that this is why the process is called «hamshachah and ha'atzalah», and from here comes the resolution between the Maharal, who speaks of before the tzimtzum, and the Rambam, who speaks of after it.

In the next section we will continue reading the gloss and explaining the continuation of the Alter Rebbe's words.