TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 9 · The Secret of the Tzimtzumim

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we saw why the Holy One is called «wise»: because chochmah and the rest of the sefiros were drawn down and emanated from Him. Now we will read the closing words of the Alter Rebbe and explain the foundation of the matter: what the aspect of «adam» is Above, what Adam Kadmon is, and what the order of the tzimtzumim is, whose whole purpose is that the light be clothed within keilim.

«The manner and nature of the drawing down and the emanation is known to the maskilim»:

The Alter Rebbe concludes: «ודרך ועניין ההמשכה והאצילות איך ומה, ידוע למשכילים», «and the manner and nature of the drawing down and the emanation, how and what it is, is known to those who comprehend». The question is how this works: by what process does a situation arise in which, on the one hand, He is utterly beyond comparison, and yet there is still a connection. To this he says that it is «known to the maskilim», and in the gloss the Alter Rebbe admits us into the company of the maskilim and reveals the secret to us.

A preface is in order. Certainly He is present everywhere, and certainly the tzimtzum is not to be taken literally, as we learned in chapter 7. Even so, the world of Atzilus too came into being only after many tzimtzumim, three general ones, except that these are not like the tzimtzum involved in creating physical, material existence. Even though ten sefiros came into being here, and they seem to be limited (chochmah, binah and daas, chesed, gevurah and tiferes, and so on), He is united with them (איהו וגרמוהי חד, «He and His attributes are one») in such a way that He can be called by their names, since the very expressions «drawing down» and «emanation» indicate closeness.

In the gloss the Alter Rebbe lists three general tzimtzumim:

  1. «סוד הצמצום באור אין סוף ברוך הוא», «the secret of the tzimtzum in the Ohr Ein Sof», which in Kabbalah and Chassidus is called «the first tzimtzum».

  2. «וצמצום א"ק», the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon.

  3. «וסוד הדיקנא», «and the secret of the dikna».

At this stage these are no more than floating letters for us. Let us now explain them.

Can the Holy One be called «adam»?

On the one hand, we find that the Holy One is called «adam». In the merkavah that the prophet Yechezkel beheld, four chayos appear: the face of a man, the face of a lion, the face of an ox and the face of an eagle. So too at the creation of the world it says «Let us make man in our image, after our likeness», from which we see that there is an aspect of «adam» Above as well.

On the other hand, we find explicitly that He is not «adam», in the verse in the book of Shmuel: «כי לא אדם הוא להינחם», «for He is not a man, that He should relent», and as the verse continues there, «and the Eternal One of Israel does not lie nor relent».

These words were said to King Shaul. Shaul had violated the command and left Agag, king of Amalek, alive, along with the sheep and the cattle. Shmuel the prophet came to him and asked him what this sound of sheep was that he was hearing, and after Shaul offered his explanation, Shmuel informed him that the Holy One had taken the kingship from him and given it to David. Shaul broke into weeping and pleading, said that he regretted it, that he was doing teshuvah, and asked to receive the kingship back. Shmuel answered him: «for He is not a man, that He should relent».

At first glance Shaul could have raised a very simple objection: the fact is that the Holy One gave him the kingship, and because of what he did He took it away from him, so there is, as it were, a «change of mind» here. Why, then, did Shaul not ask this question? The answer is that Shaul grasped the depth of what «not a man» means, and once he grasped it, there was no room for the question at all.

What «adam» is and what «not adam» is:

«Adam» means a soul structure of ten faculties: a human being has a nefesh, and the nefesh comprises ten powers of intellect and emotion. Accordingly, when the Holy One contracts Himself and clothes Himself in ten faculties, it is fitting to call Him «adam». But in His own right, where He is utterly beyond comparison and the ten sefiros occupy no place with Him whatsoever, He is «not adam», a level above the very concept of «adam», which does not enter at all into the definition of the tzimtzum called «adam».

The ten sefiros as they already stand detailed, chochmah, binah, daas and all the rest, this is the aspect of «adam». And the first point that made this state possible is called «Adam Kadmon»: the «adam» that precedes the «adam» of the ten, the source of that «adam». These are the initials א"ק that appear in the second line of the gloss: Adam Kadmon.

The order of the tzimtzumim:

Now that we have grasped the heart of the matter, let us lay out the stages of the tzimtzumim. Obviously one must not take this physically and say that this is literally how it happens, but in order to put our understanding in order we have to place them in stages. At the very beginning there is the Ohr Ein Sof filling all the space of the void, and in that state there was no room for worlds to stand: no existence, and not even the possibility of the beginning of existence.

  1. The first tzimtzum: This is like a great teacher who understands something with lofty depth and wants to explain a deep concept to a small child. If he pours out before the child everything shining in his own mind, the student will understand nothing and will simply be confused, like pouring an entire river into a tiny cup, which retains nothing of it. Therefore he must first conceal the entire force of the light in his mind, and only afterward extract from that enormous whole one small point that the student is capable of absorbing, and that is what he gives him. This is the act of the first tzimtzum, which makes room for the concept of worlds.

  2. Adam Kadmon: This is the result of the first tzimtzum. Ten detailed sefiros have not yet come into being, but there is already room given for ten sefiros, the very possibility that they should exist. This is a general world that includes all the details that will come after it, like a seed that contains within it the tree, the trunk, the leaves, the fruit and the fruit of the fruit, and even the many trees that will come out of it: all of them are included in it only in potential, and they cannot be found in it in a revealed way.

  3. The tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon: Since on the level of Adam Kadmon everything is included in potential only, nothing will yet emerge from it, and a second tzimtzum is required. Its function is to bring the particular details out of that potential state so that they can be revealed as particulars.

  4. The world of Kesser: After the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon there are already particulars, and even ten sefiros, but they are still on a lofty, infinite level that cannot truly be divided and limited.

  5. The tzimtzum of sod ha'dikna: This is the third tzimtzum, and the most powerful of all. «Dikna» in Aramaic means a beard, that is, hairs. There is life force in hairs too, but it is so contracted relative to the source from which it comes that one can cut a hair without feeling any pain at all. This is a tremendous tzimtzum.

  6. The world of Atzilus: After the third tzimtzum the ten sefiros emerged, and from here on it is fitting to speak of «adam» in the plain sense, as opposed to Adam Kadmon, which is only the potential for it to be.

Worth noting: just as there are four particular worlds, so there are four general worlds. Relative to the order of hishtalshelus that precedes it, the world of Atzilus is called, in general terms, «Asiyah», since it already contains ten sefiros; and relative to the worlds that come after it, which are more limited than it, and where the tzimtzum leading to them is drastic, it is called «Atzilus».

Back to the question: «the drawing down and the emanation, how and what»:

This was the question: how were the ten sefiros emanated and drawn down, and why do we still use the language of «drawn down» and «emanated» with regard to that which is beyond all comparison? To this comes the answer, «known to the maskilim»: it is known that there is such a thing as tzimtzumim, and that they are many, and in general terms three. The distance and the utter incomparability between one tzimtzum and the next is immense: the last tzimtzum, sod ha'dikna, is a tremendous contraction relative to the one before it, and so too the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon relative to the first tzimtzum, and the first tzimtzum relative to the revelation that preceded it. And nevertheless the ten sefiros that follow these three tzimtzumim are described as «drawn down and emanated», because He is revealed within them, to the point that He can be called by the names of the ten sefiros.

From here comes also the resolution of the two approaches: the Maharal cries out, how can He be called «wise», while the Rambam uses expressions such as «knows» and «known» regarding Him. Both are correct. In His own right the Creator is utterly beyond comparison, and the Maharal is right that He cannot be given any title at all; but as He has contracted Himself and made it possible for there to be a drawing down and an emanation from Him, in this mode of revelation He can be called «wise» and «kind».

There is an analogy for this in the human soul. The soul has many faculties, lofty ones and lowly ones: there is the power to understand things and to feel things, and there is the power to pick up a hammer and bang on a wall. Both are powers coming from the very same soul, and yet we distinguish between them: of the one we say «a soul power», and of the other «a technical skill».

So it is here. Everything comes from the Creator, and everything is beyond comparison to Him, except that there are powers He created through the route of «drawn down and emanated», and there are, as it were, powers He created through the route of «something from nothing». This is how He chose, and therefore those things that came into being through the route of drawing down and emanation are more distinguished, and He can be called by their names; whereas the creations brought into being through the route of yesh me'ayin are lowly, and He is not called by their names.

Let it be emphasized: the fact that He is called by the names «wise» and «kind» is not because He has become such a thing, God forbid. That which is beyond comparison remains beyond comparison; it is simply that He decided to reveal Himself here in a manner of «drawn down and emanated», and this is how He wanted it to be. And in what manner was it drawn down and emanated? After passing through many tzimtzumim.

In this light, let us read the words of the gloss again: «סוד הצמצום באור אין סוף ברוך הוא», this is the first tzimtzum; «וצמצום א"ק», the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon, the second tzimtzum; «וסוד הדיקנא», the third tzimtzum. And after these three tzimtzumim the ten sefiros were drawn down and emanated, «שסוד כל הצמצומים הוא לצמצם האור שיתלבש בבחינת כלים, די' ספירות», «for the secret of all the tzimtzumim is to contract the light so that it should be clothed in the aspect of keilim, of the ten sefiros». The purpose of all the tzimtzumim is that the light should be clothed in the ten sefiros; and since He is present there and shining there, He can be called by their names.

In summary: in this section we read the closing words of the Alter Rebbe, «and the manner and nature of the drawing down and the emanation, how and what it is, is known to the maskilim», together with the three tzimtzumim listed in the gloss. We learned that the Holy One is called «adam» as He contracts Himself and clothes Himself in ten faculties, and «not adam» in His own right, where He is above that definition, and this is the depth of the verse «for He is not a man, that He should relent», said to King Shaul. Adam Kadmon is the first point and the source of the «adam» of the ten sefiros. We laid out the order of the three general tzimtzumim: the first tzimtzum (the analogy of the teacher and the student), which gives rise to Adam Kadmon, containing everything in potential like a seed; the tzimtzum of Adam Kadmon, which gives rise to the world of Kesser; and the tzimtzum of sod ha'dikna, through which the ten sefiros are revealed in the world of Atzilus. Finally it was explained that even though everything is utterly beyond comparison to Him, since the light is clothed in the keilim and shines within them, it is fitting to call Him by the names of the sefiros, and this is the purpose of all the tzimtzumim.

In the next section we will continue and expand on this gloss and on the Alter Rebbe's further words in the chapter.