TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 8 · Every Thought in the World Is Driven by an Emotion

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we learned, from what is plainly visible in a small child, that every emotion is a product of the intellect, and that there is no such thing as a neutral, free-floating emotion. Now we move on to the third level: from the middos (the emotions) are drawn the words and letters of thought.

The third level: the letters of thought

«ומהמידות שבנפש נמשכות בה תיבות ואותיות המחשבה» (« and from the middos of the soul are drawn the words and letters of thought »). Here something entirely new comes into being: letters. Within the middos themselves there were no letters at all, for a middah is a raw emotion, abstracted from any letters. Here, in thought, letters are formed. And where do they come from? They are the product of the emotion. The examples the Alter Rebbe brings cover every possible case:

  1. «שהנפש מחשבת בדבר שאוהבת» (« the soul thinks about the thing it loves »). This is the simplest and clearest case: a person thinks about what he loves. If he loves a fellow Jew with a great love, he thinks about him, about his goodness, about the pleasantness of what he does. Here it is obvious that the letters of thought came from the emotion that fed them.

  2. «או איך לפעול החסד ורחמים וכן בשאר המידות» (« or how to act with kindness and mercy, and likewise with the other middos »). A person thinks and plans how to express his love in practice, how to act on what the emotion is telling him: how to give expression to love, to anger, to irritation, to mercy, and so on.

  3. The third possibility is the person who says he is simply thinking ordinary thoughts, or purely intellectual matters, a mind wandering with no plan at all, apparently with no emotion involved. To this the Alter Rebbe says: «ובכל מחשבה שבעולם מלובשת בה איזו מידה המביאה לחשוב מחשבה זו» (« and in every thought in the world there is clothed some middah that brings a person to think that very thought »). Every thought in the world, in any field whatsoever.

What does « clothed » mean here? The middah descends into the thought and invests itself within it. If a person will stop and examine why he is thinking about precisely this matter and not another, he will find some pull, some feeling, some sympathy toward it. Even if he cannot analyze it on the spot, with a bit of hisbonenus (contemplation) he will see that there is a middah driving his thinking. And more than that: «ומידה זו היא חיותה של מחשבה זו» (« and this middah is the very life-force of that thought »). The middah does not merely set the thought in motion, it is literally its vitality. This expression is abstract, and we will leave it for now; when we reach the letters of speech it will become clearer, and from there we will understand this backwards as well.

[Some illustrations: why does a person think right now about one particular intellectual idea and not another? Because it draws him and stands before him, either because he enjoys learning at this moment, or because he is busy with the electric bill and he cares about saving money. The same is true of memory: why does a person suddenly remember a certain thing? Because the matter touches him, and being « touched » is an emotion. And even when a person is working through an intellectual idea, his thinking is never entirely objective and clean. Not that he is thinking under the influence of a bribe, but there is a feeling and an interest that is steering him toward this particular area.]

The same holds true even of undesirable thoughts. We learned in Tanya that there is a yetzer tov and a yetzer hara, that there are emotions coming from the positive side and emotions coming from the negative side, and that there is a war between them. A thought that disturbs a person, one he is trying to push away, comes from the middos of the yetzer hara, precisely when he would rather be absorbed in something else. So too during davening: the thoughts that come in the middle of the tefillah have their source in the yetzer, that is, in the middos. The yetzer hara arouses some craving or other and throws a thought at the person that grows out of the middos. It is davka there that one sees tangibly how thought comes from emotion.

Distinguishing between understanding and thought

People sometimes confuse thought with understanding, but they are not the same thing. Understanding is chochmah (and binah), the first level, which is above the middos. Thought is the third level, and it is set in motion by the intellect that entered the middos, and from the middos into thought. Thought means thinking in letters.

The fourth level: the letters of speech

«ומאותיות המחשבה נמשכות אותיות הדיבור» (« and from the letters of thought are drawn the letters of speech »). When a person speaks, those very letters must necessarily have been in his thought beforehand. And the Alter Rebbe adds: «והן חיותן ממש» (« and they are literally their vitality »). The letters of thought are the life-force of the letters of speech.

You can see this in the difference between two ways of speaking. One person sat at home beforehand and thought through the idea he is about to speak about, or even thought through one particular sentence, and his speech now flows out of the strength of that thought. Another person is figuring out what he wants to say while he is already saying it. The speech is completely different. Not in volume, not in tone, but in the weight and the vitality it carries, because the thought is present inside it now.

It emerges that the letters of thought are what give life to speech. If they were in thought before the speaking, the vitality they give it is smaller; when they are present inside the speech at the very moment it is said, they give it far more vitality.

And it is the middos that give life to thought. This too is plainly observable: when a person thinks out of an open, awakened emotion, the thought is full of life. But when the middah is hidden away somewhere in the soul, so that a person has to go searching for where this came from, there is less vitality in the thought, and therefore that thought slips by and races through without any real attention being paid to it.

« What to say » and « how to say it »

There is an interesting definition that brings this out: there is « what to say » and there is « how to say it ». The « what » comes from thought; the « how » comes from the emotion. That is why, when a person is angry, his speech sounds different. And likewise you can hear in someone's speech whether he is giving an instruction, speaking words of love, or speaking in anger. The tone is different, because it is the emotion that determines the manner of the speech. A strong emotion produces a strong tone; a delicate emotion, a delicate tone. But the content of the words, the « what to say », is drawn from thought.

For this reason the sifrei mussar write that the advice for someone who is angry is to be silent. And there is a further point here: not only does the emotion give birth to the speech, but the speech itself feeds the emotion and intensifies it, whereas when a person does not speak, everything settles down.

In summary: in this section we learned that from the middos are drawn the words and letters of thought, that in every thought in the world there is a middah clothed within it which brings a person to think that thought, and that this middah is the thought's very vitality. This is so whether one is thinking about the thing he loves, or thinking how to act with chesed and rachamim, or engaged in what seems to be a purely intellectual or wandering thought. We clarified the difference between understanding (chochmah) and thought (letters), and that from the letters of thought are drawn the letters of speech, which are literally their vitality. We also saw that there is a « what to say », which comes from thought, and a « how to say it », which comes from the emotion, and that therefore the advice for one who is angry is to be silent, since the speech itself feeds the emotion and intensifies it.

In the next section we will reach the fifth level in the order of hishtalshelus within the soul: « and speech leads to action ».