TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 8 · The Middos Follow the Measure of the Intellect

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous lesson we stopped in chapter 8 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, on daf 85b (page 170), about a third of the way down the page, at the line beginning “כי המעלה והמדרגה הראשונה אצל הנבראים”, “For the first and highest level among created beings…” With chapter 8 a new and deeper subject opens up in Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, so let us first review briefly what was learned in the earlier part.

Two approaches to the question of ascribing titles to the Creator:

  • The approach of the Rambam - one may indeed describe the Holy One and say of Him «He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge itself.» That is, He Himself is the very faculty of knowing, and everything that takes place in the world is literally part of Him.

  • The approach of the Maharal of Prague - how can one say such a thing? Would it ever occur to us to call the Creator «the Knowledge, blessed be He» or «the Wise One, blessed be He»? For this reason the Sages of Israel found the precise title: «HaKadosh Baruch Hu», the Holy One, blessed be He. The meaning of «kadosh» is separate, set apart: set apart from every definition and every description, since any definition we can articulate is itself a reality that the Creator formed and brought into being outside of Himself, while He Himself is not captured by any definition at all.

The first portion of chapter 8, up to the second line at the top of the second side of the page, is a presentation of the Rambam's approach. From there on the Alter Rebbe alludes to the approach of the Maharal: “אבל באמת הקב"ה הוא רם ונישא וקדוש שמו, כלומר שהוא קדוש ומובדל ריבוא רבבות עד אין קץ ותכלית מדרגות הבדלות, למעלה מעלה מערך וסוג ומין כל התשבחות והמעלות שיוכלו הנבראים להשיג ולצייר בשכלם”, “But in truth the Holy One, blessed be He, is exalted and uplifted and holy is His Name, meaning that He is holy and separated by myriads upon myriads of degrees of separation, without end or limit, infinitely higher than the category and the species of all the praises and virtues that created beings are able to grasp and to picture in their minds.” In other words: the Creator is separated by countless removes even from the loftiest praise a creature is capable of uttering about Him, for every praise is a definition, and He cannot be defined by any definition whatsoever.

The ladder of levels within the soul of man:

From here to the end of the chapter the Alter Rebbe explains just how constricted and limited the concepts familiar to us in our world really are, and within our own world of concepts he lays out the two extremes of human excellence. These levels are arranged on a ladder of five rungs, from the highest down:

  1. Chochmah - which includes within it chochmah, binah and daas.

  2. Middos - the emotions.

  3. Machshavah, thought.

  4. Dibbur, speech.

  5. Maaseh, action.

Every deed a person actually carries out passes, in practice, through every one of these levels. And since these are the two extremes known to us, the upper extreme being chochmah and the lower extreme being action, it follows that the greatest praise with which we can praise a person in our world is to call him wise, for that is the highest excellence in our world. The Alter Rebbe will first describe the entire sequence, and with that he will conclude the chapter.

“כי המעלה והמדרגה הראשונה אצל הנבראים היא החכמה”, “For the first and highest level among created beings is chochmah”:

This refers to all created beings without exception, spiritual and physical alike. Even when we want to single out a particular animal as exceptional, we point out that it possesses this or that intelligence; and even of an inanimate object we say «a smart device.» Anything we wish to describe with the loftiest description, we describe using the language of chochmah.

And since chochmah is the first level in creation, “שלכן נקראת ראשית”, “which is why it is called «reishis», the beginning.” There is an allusion to this in the verse «reishis chochmah», “the beginning is wisdom,” and likewise in Targum Yonasan ben Uziel on the very first word of the Torah: «Bereishis» is rendered “בחוכמתא”, “with wisdom,” with chochmah G-d created the heavens and the earth.

“כי באמת היא ראשית ומקור כל החיות בנבראים”, “for in truth it is the beginning and the source of all the life force in created beings.” So it is in seder hishtalshelus, the chain of descent: in every single world chochmah is the first of the sefiros, and from it the life force flows down to all the sefiros that follow. And so it is as well in the hishtalshelus within the soul of man: everything a person does, says, thinks and feels has its source and its vitality in chochmah.

“כי מהחכמה נמשכות בינה ודעת”, “for from chochmah are drawn forth binah and daas.” The world of the intellect itself divides into three (ChaBaD):

  • Chochmah - the first flash of insight within the mind.

  • Binah - contemplating that point and giving it length, breadth and depth.

  • Daas - bonding with the matter and caring about the idea one has learned.

“ומהן נמשכות כל המידות שבנפש המשכלת, כמו אהבה וחסד ורחמים וכיוצא בהן”, “and from them are drawn forth all the middos of the intellectual soul, such as love, kindness, mercy and the like.” All the middos, that is, the emotions of the soul, are an expression of the intellect. Even a middah that is aroused without any prior thought or planning turns out, upon deeper examination, to draw its source and its nourishment from chochmah, binah and daas. The Alter Rebbe brings as examples love and chesed (which are really one middah: chesed is the root and love is its expression) and mercy (the middah of tiferes, which likewise is composed of chesed and love), that is, only the positive side of a person's middos. But in saying «and the like» he includes the negative side as well: anger, cruelty and so on.

And here is the proof that the intensity of a middah, its targets, and the things that move a person, are all a function of the chochmah, binah and daas within him: “וכנראה בחוש שהקטן שאין בו דעת הוא בכעס תמיד ואכזרי, וגם אהבתו היא לדברים קטנים שאין ראוי לאוהבם, מפני שאין בו דעת לאהוב דברים הראויים לאהבה”, “as is plainly observable, that a small child, who has no daas, is constantly angry and is cruel, and his love too is for trivial things that are not worth loving, because he does not possess the daas to love things that truly deserve to be loved.”

A comparison with the wording of chapter 6 of Likkutei Amarim:

This very same idea, that the middos are a product of the intellect, appears at the beginning of the Tanya, in chapter 6 (daf 10), in these words: “כי המידות הן לפי ערך השכל”, “for the middos are in accordance with the measure of the intellect.” There too the proof is brought from the small child, except that the example and the formulation differ slightly. There it says: “כי הקטן חושק ואוהב דברים קטנים פחותי הערך”, “for the child desires and loves small things of little worth,” a young child craves specifically tiny things of minimal value, “לפי ששכלו קטן וקצר להשיג דברים יקרים יותר מהם”, “because his intellect is small and too limited to grasp things more precious than these.” Place a hundred dollar bill in front of him alongside a candy worth twenty cents and he will choose the candy, because that is what he understands; the value of the paper he simply does not know, and he has no connection to desiring things whose worth lies above the level of his mind. The Tanya continues there in the same vein regarding anger: the child becomes angry and incensed over small things, since a trifle is enough to disturb his calm.

In chapter 6 it says that the child becomes angry over small things, while here it says that he is «constantly angry.» In truth these are one and the same: since he becomes angry at every little thing, and little things confront him at every moment, it emerges that he is in a state of anger all the time. Someone who gets angry only at great matters has few occasions to be angry; but one whom every trifle throws off balance is in a perpetual state of anger.

And why, with regard to love, did the Alter Rebbe not use the phrase «he loves constantly,» but rather «his love is for small things»? Because such is human nature: for one whose daas is small, the accessibility and the ease of being aroused to anger come faster than being drawn toward something and loving it. To love something one must first see the good in it and be drawn after it, whereas anger stems from a person's self centeredness, so that anything that touches him sets him off immediately, and he feels his own self at every single moment. That is precisely why it is with respect to anger that it says he is angry constantly.

It is worth noting that «small child» is not necessarily a matter of age: even a person well advanced in years can remain at that same level of smallness, where every little thing disturbs his calm.

The anger and the cruelty found in a child:

As we plainly see, with a child every fly that passes in front of him throws off his whole routine, whereas a person of daas pays no attention to every trivial nonsense, since he is absorbed in matters of substance.

The word «cruel» that the Alter Rebbe uses is likewise plainly observable (and of course the «cruelty» described here is relative, measured against the tender feelings of a child): little children quarrel with each other and torment one another, and among them this is far more common than it is among adults in the ordinary course of things. It is enough to watch how children treat one another to appreciate the measure of cruelty involved. The middos of anger and cruelty are far less restrained in them than in an adult, because they lack the daas that serves as a barrier. The child likewise lacks the ability to delay gratification, unless he has been educated toward it, and such education can begin already at a young age, each child according to his level.

What we learn from this proof:

Every emotion, its magnitude, its targets and its intensity, is a function of chochmah, binah and daas, for the middos are a product of the intellect, and they are the second rung in the seder hishtalshelus from above downward. There is no such thing as a neutral emotion that is entirely unconnected to the intellect. This is precisely why the Alter Rebbe brings his example from the child, in whom the emotion appears to arise, as it were, with no thought behind it at all.

And the reverse is also true: sometimes we see a child who is young in years yet «born grown up,» possessed of more daas, and his whole conduct is calmer and he is not drawn after every piece of nonsense. The reason: his starting point of daas is higher, and consequently his middos are higher as an immediate result. Daas exists in every person; the only question is its dosage and its measure, and the middos follow accordingly.

In summary: in this section we reviewed the two approaches to the question of ascribing titles to the Creator, that of the Rambam and that of the Maharal, and we saw how the Alter Rebbe concludes that the Holy One, blessed be He, is exalted, uplifted and holy, separated from every praise and every virtue a creature could picture in his mind. We then traced the ladder of five levels within the soul, chochmah, middos, thought, speech and action, and saw that chochmah is the first and highest level among created beings, which is why it is called «reishis» and is the source of all the life force. From chochmah flow binah and daas, and from them flow all the middos of the soul, with the proof drawn from the child who has no daas, whose anger and whose love are in accordance with the measure of his intellect. We also considered the anger and cruelty found in a child, and the point that every emotion is a product of the intellect and that there is no such thing as a neutral emotion; and conversely, that a child possessed of more daas conducts himself more calmly and his middos are correspondingly higher.

In the next section we will move on to the third level in the hishtalshelus within the soul: from the middos are drawn forth the words and letters of thought.