TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 8 · All of God's Names and Middos Are Literally One

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we looked at the words of the Rambam, that with the Holy One «He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge» . The Rambam draws a line between the faculty of knowledge and the rest of the attributes: regarding the other middos he does not agree that they are actually in the Creator, only that «the Torah speaks in the language of men». It is here that the Alter Rebbe's chiddush begins.

The Alter Rebbe takes the Rambam's statement further: כן הוא העניין ממש בכל מדותיו של הקב"ה ובכל שמותיו הקדושים והכינויים שכינו לו הנביאים וחז"ל (precisely the same is true of all of God's middos, and of all His holy Names and the appellations given to Him by the prophets and the Sages). Every middah, every Name, every appellation is in Him, and even so He does not thereby become composed of many details. It is all Him Himself.

Seventy Names:

On the phrase «all His holy Names given to Him by the prophets», the Rebbe makes a note: how many Names and appellations does the Holy One have? In the book of Bamidbar (11:16) it says, «And God said to Moshe, gather for Me seventy men from the elders of Israel». The Baal HaTurim there explains why precisely seventy: corresponding to the seventy souls who went down to Egypt, corresponding to the seventy nations, and corresponding to the seventy Names that the Holy One has, and he lists them all, one by one (and there he also lists the seventy names of Israel). These are «all His Names and appellations» that the Alter Rebbe is speaking of.

The Alter Rebbe cites several of these appellations, and he climbs through them from the bottom upward:

  • חנון ורחום וחסיד וכיוצא בהן (gracious, merciful, kind and the like): these are the middos, the emotive attributes.

  • וכן מה שנקרא חכם, דכתיב «וגם הוא חכם וגו'» (and likewise that He is called wise, as it is written, «and He too is wise»): chochmah, which is above the middos.

  • וכן רצונו (and likewise His will): the highest level of all. כי רוצה ה' את יראיו (for God desires those who fear Him), וחפץ חסד הוא (and He delights in kindness), ורוצה בתשובתן של רשעים ואינו חפץ במיתתם וברשעתם (He desires the repentance of the wicked and does not desire their death and their wickedness), and טהור עינים מראות ברע (He is too pure of eyes to behold evil). All of these are expressions in which Scripture and the Sages describe the Creator as wanting and desiring.

And nonetheless: אין רצונו וחכמתו ומדת חסדו ורחמנותו ושאר מדותיו מוסיפים בו ריבוי והרכבה ח"ו במהותו ועצמותו (His will, His wisdom, His attribute of kindness and mercy and the rest of His middos do not, God forbid, add multiplicity or composition to His essence and being). Note that the Alter Rebbe stresses that even His will adds no composition. With will this is in a sense the easier case, since even in us one could argue that will is part of the nefesh itself, and yet we learned that even will constitutes a composition. On this the Alter Rebbe teaches: by the Creator, not only does His will add nothing to Him, but neither does His wisdom, nor His kindness. All the details are in Him, and He remains one.

This is a flat contradiction: definition and composition normally travel together, and here there are definitions and appellations and yet He remains utterly simple and abstract. Two opposites are holding together as one.

The correct way of looking at it, then, is that עצמותו ומהותו ורצונו וחכמתו ובינתו ודעתו ומדת חסדו וגבורתו ורחמנותו ותפארתו הכלולה מחסדו וגבורתו, וכן שאר מדותיו הקדושות - הכל אחדות פשוטה ממש, שהיא היא עצמותו ומהותו (His essence and being, His will, His chochmah, binah and daas, His attributes of chesed, gevurah and mercy, and tiferes which is composed of chesed and gevurah, and likewise all His other holy middos, are all literally one simple unity, which is His very essence and being). This is the theme of chapter 8: not only does the world add nothing to Him, but all the appellations, and the entire tree of sefiros that we are familiar with, which would seem to be adding something in Him, in fact add nothing whatsoever.

The Maharal of Prague denied the very possibility of attaching any appellation at all to the Creator. The Alter Rebbe says that all the appellations are indeed in Him, and he goes even further than the Rambam: the Rambam said this only of knowledge and not of the middos, while the Alter Rebbe says it about everything, the middos included, and despite that, they add nothing to Him.

«The mouth has no power to express it»:

The obvious question is: how is this possible, when these are two opposites? The answer is וכמו שכתב הרמב"ם ז"ל, שדבר זה אין כח בפה לאומרו ולא באוזן לשומעו ולא בלב האדם להכירו על בוריו (as the Rambam wrote, that this matter the mouth has not the power to express, nor the ear to hear, nor the heart of man to grasp it clearly).

Here the Alter Rebbe reveals a new reading of the Rambam's words. Someone who learns the Rambam plainly, and as he is cited elsewhere in Tanya, understands «the mouth has no power to express it» as referring to the very matter of His being the Knower, the Known and the Knowledge. The Alter Rebbe explains that this is not the intent. «The mouth has no power to express it» refers to the question of how He can have definition on the one hand and remain simple on the other, and he applies that expression to all the appellations given to the Holy One.

And what is the reason that we have no capacity to grasp this? Our own limitation. We look at everything through our own eyeglasses. With us, every concept is an addition to the essence, because we are composed of details, and therefore we have no ability to grasp anything that falls outside our own definition. We are inside the box. A proof: even that which is below us, the language of birds and fowl, falls outside our definition and we cannot understand it. How much more so that which is above us.

In the Alter Rebbe's words: כי האדם מצייר בשכלו כל המושכלות שרוצה להשכיל ולהבין אותם כמות שהם בו (for a person pictures in his mind every concept he wishes to conceive and understand as that concept exists in himself). Every concept and idea a person wishes to contemplate, he defines for himself out of himself. כגון שרוצה לצייר בשכלו מהות הרצון או מהות חכמה או בינה או דעת או מהות מדת חסד ורחמים וכיוצא בהן - הוא מצייר כולם כמות שהן בו (for example, if he wishes to picture the essence of will, or the essence of chochmah or binah or daas, or the essence of the attribute of kindness and mercy and the like, he pictures them all as they are in himself). When we say that the Holy One wants something, a person immediately turns to himself and says: just as I want, perhaps in some loftier fashion. But he cannot get outside himself. And therefore he will never be able to understand how the Creator is the Knower and the Known, and at the same time a simple unity that is not composite at all.

The same applies to the question of how the Holy One understands, or feels, as it were, a person's pain. He does not feel the way we feel, and in the words of the prophet, «For My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways My ways».

There is nothing surprising about the fact that we do not understand. What is surprising is that there are things we do understand. So it is with mitzvos: there are mitzvos called chukim, which the human mind cannot grasp, and there are mitzvos called mishpatim, which the human mind not only understands but even demands, such as the prohibitions of theft and murder and the honoring of parents (though even in mishpatim there is an aspect of chok; we are speaking in general terms).

A person's usual instinct is that he is more comfortable keeping what he understands, and about what he does not understand he wonders: what is this mitzvah really about? The outlook ought to be exactly the reverse. Are we in any position to understand the will of the Creator? That there are chukim we do not understand is no wonder at all, since He is infinitely beyond any comprehension and any definition. The great wonder is that He gave us mitzvos that we do understand, that He came down into our own intellect to the point where we can say: how true, how right, how good and how just this is.

And yet the Torah is full of expressions like «and I shall hear, for I am gracious». How does that fit? This is the concept of tzimtzum: that in truth He does, as it were, understand and feel, He comes down and contracts Himself. As we mentioned in the introduction to this shiur, and we will deal with it at length further on.

The transition to the approach of the Maharal:

At precisely this point the Alter Rebbe shifts, by hint, to the approach of the Maharal of Prague, although he never says so openly. The next sentence reads as a direct continuation of the previous one, so smoothly that one can read it without noticing at all that he has moved to another plane. Until now he has been explaining the Rambam, and even expanding on him: that there are appellations applied to the Holy One, and that these appellations are He Himself in simple unity. From here on he moves to the second approach, that of the Maharal, which negates all the appellations and all the definitions and maintains that no definition is fitting or, seemingly, true. From here to the end of the chapter, and into the chapter that follows, we are dealing with the approach of the Maharal, and only afterward will the teaching of Chassidus come and mediate between the two.

In his words: אבל באמת הקב"ה הוא רם ונשא וקדוש שמו (but in truth the Holy One is exalted and uplifted and His Name is holy). «Holy» means separate, that He cannot be captured by any definition: כלומר שהוא קדוש ומובדל רבוא רבבות עד אין קץ ותכלית מדרגות הבדלות, למעלה מעלה מערך וסוג ומין כל התשבחות והמעלות שיוכלו הנבראים להשיג ולצייר בשכלם (that is, that He is holy and separate by myriads upon myriads of endless levels of separation, immeasurably beyond the category and class and species of all the praises and virtues that created beings could ever grasp or picture in their minds).

In other words: let a person take the loftiest of creatures, and find the greatest possible praise of the Holy One, and think he has now said the most sublime thing there is. Know that the Holy One is separate and elevated beyond that loftiest description. Gather all the creatures of the world, bring every magnificent title and every great definition that could possibly exist, and you still have not arrived anywhere.

This principle is illustrated in the first berachah of Shemoneh Esrei. The Gemara in Berachos tells of one of the Tannaim who heard his student stretching out the praises in his prayer: «the great, mighty and awesome God, the powerful, the valiant, the strong...». He waited until the student finished, since at some point he had to stop; even if he had counted out all seventy Names that the Baal HaTurim lists, after seventy he would have stopped. And then he said to him: is that it? Have you finished them all? What he was really saying was: the truth is that nothing at all can be said. And why then do we say «the great, mighty and awesome God»? Because that is what Moshe Rabbeinu said, and we are only repeating his words. But whoever starts adding runs into trouble, because once you have begun to add you can no longer stop, since in truth He cannot be defined at all.

The flow of the rest of the chapter:

From here to the end of the chapter the progression is straightforward. The Alter Rebbe first describes the structure of the powers of our own soul and how they function, listing several levels: seichel (intellect), middos (emotion), machshavah (thought), dibbur (speech) and maaseh (action). The distance from one stage to the next is enormous, to the point that there is no comparison at all between one level and the next: the distance between an understanding in the mind and an action is like a chasm yawning between them, and the same is true of each of the stages in between.

The loftiest thing in us is the intellect, and therefore someone who comes to describe the Holy One will say that He is wise, since that is the highest quality we know of. To this the Alter Rebbe says: the distance between Him and the quality of wisdom is incomparably greater even than the distance between those stages from one to the other, because He is separate from every definition. This is the thread that runs to the end of the chapter.

It is worth distinguishing between seichel and machshavah. Seichel is the understanding itself, while machshavah is the garment, the letters. Understanding is abstracted from letters, whereas thought is already composed of letters, and therefore it is a far lower level (and thought can also be about emotion: a person feels something, and then thinks about what he is feeling). Put simply: you can ask a person in which language he thinks, and that is a legitimate question. But there is no sense in asking in which language he understands. Reuven understood and Shimon understood, the very same concept, because understanding is abstracted from letters.

כי המעלה ומדרגה הראשונה אצל הנבראים היא החכמה, שלכן נקראת «ראשית» (for the first quality and level among created beings is chochmah, which is why it is called «reishis», beginning). Where do we find that chochmah is called «reishis»? In «reishis chochmah» (the beginning of wisdom), and likewise in the first word of the Torah, «Bereishis», which Targum Yonasan ben Uziel renders «bechochmesa bara» (with wisdom He created). So «reishis» is translated as chochmah, and therefore chochmah is the loftiest of qualities.

כי באמת היא ראשית ומקור כל החיות בנבראים (for in truth it is the beginning and the source of all the life force in created beings). The starting point of all the middos, all the vitality and all of a person's conduct, is governed from the brain and from chochmah, and that is why it deserves the name «reishis», the beginning of everything. כי מהחכמה נמשכות בינה ודעת, ומהן נמשכות כל המדות שבנפש המשכלת (for from chochmah flow binah and daas, and from them flow all the middos of the intellectual soul), and from the middos comes the activation of the entire person.

To summarize: in this section we learned the Alter Rebbe's chiddush on the words of the Rambam: that not only knowledge, but all of God's middos, Names and appellations (seventy Names, by the Baal HaTurim's count) are literally one simple unity, «His very essence and being», and add no multiplicity or composition to Him. We saw that the phrase «the mouth has not the power to express it» refers, according to his explanation, to the contradiction between definition and simplicity, and that we have no capacity to grasp this because a person pictures every concept «as it exists in himself». From there the Alter Rebbe moved, by hint, to the approach of the Maharal, that He is «holy and separate» from the category of all praises and virtues, and he opened his description of the levels of the soul's powers, the first of which is chochmah.

In the next section we will learn the order of the levels within the powers of the soul, analyze the differences between them, and through that come to understand the Maharal's approach to the separateness and holiness of the Holy One from every definition.