TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 7 · Can Anyone Invent Gematrias?

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we learned that the root of the even (stone) is the name Ban, and that the extra alef in the word comes from a different name, since the whole purpose is to take that « Ban » and lift it up. Now let us turn to luminous stones.

Stones That Shine:

To round out the subject, let us bring a fascinating passage from another sefer of the Alter Rebbe, Likkutei Torah, containing a remarkable insight about stones. Broadly speaking, there are two kinds of stones. In last week's parshah we read about the stones of the Choshen, the breastplate: odem, pitdah and the rest, stones that literally gave off light, and more than that, Elokus was revealed through them. From the outset, even before they were set into the Choshen, luminous stones with special segulos were chosen for it, and the Torah gives a whole list of their names. To this day there is an entire body of knowledge among those who deal with the properties of stones and their uses. And over against these there are stones that are nothing more than plain rock.

And here is the great wonder: a stone is domem, inanimate, the very lowest level of creation, and nevertheless it shines (a diamond, after all, is a kind of stone). Creatures on a higher level, plant, animal and man, do not shine at all, and it is specifically the small, silent stone that gives off light.

True, we do find great tzaddikim who shone. The Gemara tells of Rabbi Eliezer who was ill, and Rabbi Yochanan came to visit him and noticed that the house was dark. Rabbi Yochanan rolled up his sleeve, and the light that came out of his arm lit up the entire house. So too it is written of Adam HaRishon that he dimmed the orb of the sun, that the light radiating from him eclipsed the light of the sun. But in the ordinary way of the world there is no such thing, and only in stones do we actually see light.

Precious Stones That Shine: Likkutei Torah, Parshas Re'eh:

Let us look at the Alter Rebbe's own words in Likkutei Torah, Parshas Re'eh: והנה בזה יובן עניין אבנים טובות שהם דומם ואף על פי כן מאירות, ומאין יש להם כוח זה? והעניין, כי עיקר גידולם הוא מן הכוכבים, « With this one can understand the matter of precious stones, which are inanimate and nevertheless give off light. From where do they have this power? The explanation is that their essential growth comes from the stars. » The stars exert an influence on the stones. And which stars are these? Just as there are two kinds of stones, so too there are two kinds of stars:

  • ולא מן הכוכבים הנראים , « not from the visible stars » , the stars we can see have a number, they are limited in quantity.

  • אלא מן הכוכבים שאינם נראים , « but from the stars that are not visible » , stars that are not seen at all, שאותם הכוכבים באמת אין להם מספר כלל, ואינם מתגלים ונראים, אלא סגולתם להאיר לאבנים טובות, « for those stars truly have no number at all, and they are not revealed or seen; rather, their special property is to give light to precious stones. »

And why specifically these? והיינו לפי שהם דומם, שהיא בחינה מדרגה יותר תחתונה, מקבלים אור מהכוכבים שאין להם מספר כלל, שאינם נראים, שהם למעלה מן הכוכבים הנראים לנו, « And this is because they are inanimate, which is the lowest level, and therefore they receive light from the stars that have no number at all, which are not seen, which are higher than the stars visible to us. » Precisely because the stone is the lowest rung, the level of domem, it receives its light from the very highest source.

והנה לפי ריבוי הכוכבים עד אין מספר, כך ריבוי הארות משונות באבנים טובות, וריבוי שינוי מראיתם וטוהרם, « And in accordance with the multitude of stars beyond number, so is the multitude of varied illuminations in precious stones, and the multitude of differences in their appearance and clarity. » The sheer variety of illuminations within the stones, to the point that in a single stone you can see the light reflected differently from every angle, flows from the multitude of stars.

« Even » as Alef plus Ban:

The maamar continues: והנה אבן זה א' בן, שהוא בחינת בהמה בגימטריה בן, אלא שנמשך בו בחינת הא' שהוא שם מה במילוי אלפין, « Now, even is alef plus Ban, which is the aspect of behemah, numerically equivalent to Ban; except that there is drawn into it the aspect of the alef, which is the name Mah spelled out with alefs. » The Alter Rebbe states here explicitly that the alef points to the name Mah, since the name Mah is the name Havayah spelled out with alefs. The stone is the « Ban » that has been refined by the name Mah, and once it has been refined, it shines.

From here it also becomes clear that not every stone receives its alef from the name Mah. If so, why are they all called by one name? Because they are all included under the general term « even », but in detail they do not all share the same quality: if the alef is from the name Mah, this is a luminous stone; and if the alef comes from some other source, it will be a piece of gravel. And here too there is a vast range of stones and a vast range of types.

This small glimpse teaches us that even in stones there is such a general classification, one that flows from the letters of the name Havayah and from the gematrias, an enormous tzimtzum. From here one begins to have respect, not for the stones, chas veshalom, but for the Divine power within them: « How manifold are Your works, Hashem », to what extent He is present in every last tiny detail, and « ihu tafis bekula », He is literally found within every single detail.

Refining the « Ban » Through the « Mah »:

And this is how the Alter Rebbe concludes the sentence: והיינו בירור נפש הבהמית על ידי הנפש האלוקית, « and this is the refinement of the nefesh habahamis through the nefesh ha'elokis. » Our nefesh habahamis, the animal soul, is the « Ban »; the nefesh ha'elokis, the G-dly soul, is the « Mah »; and when a person refines himself, that is the birur, and through it he becomes a true ben adam, a human being.

If the alef shines within the « Ban », the result is a luminous stone, a refined stone; and if the alef does not shine within it and it remains mere « Ban », it is in trouble. So too, when a person takes a simple stone and uses it for something holy, he raises it from « Ban » to « Mah ». And all of this translates into one's own avodah: a person works on himself to refine himself and to elevate his « Ban » into « Mah », and that is the inner meaning of every illumination and every revelation.

The « Ban » is the behemah, our nefesh habahamis (« Ban » has the numerical value of behemah), and these are the sparks that fell down into the lowest possible place. We rectify them, and in doing so we ourselves are elevated into that illumination. The Aibershter created this tzimtzum and expects us to bring elevation into the creation, and this is why a Yid is called a « partner with the Holy One in the work of creation », for he produces and brings about these illuminations and these transformations.

And as he concludes: ועל ידי בירור זה נעשה אבן טוב ומאיר, על דרך עליית בן בסג שלמעלה ממה, « and through this refinement it becomes a precious, luminous stone, in the manner of the ascent of Ban into Sag, which is higher than Mah. » The ascent is to a level higher still.

How Are These Connections Arrived At? A Mashal from the Rebbe:

A question was asked: what is the source for all these connections between letters and their numerical values, who established them, and can anyone try his hand at it? The answer lies in a mashal the Rebbe gave regarding a different matter, which applies to our subject as well.

The Rebbe addressed the question of why the Rishonim, in their commentaries and in their responsa, answer with extreme brevity, half a page and the matter is finished, whereas the Acharonim, in the later generations, write answers that stretch over whole pages, sometimes an entire sefer before reaching a conclusion. Does this mean the Acharonim were more learned? Rashi will sometimes write two words in his commentary on the Gemara, and in the commentaries on Rashi you will find a whole scroll written to explain those two words (already with the Rashbam, Rashi's grandson, you see this at great length in Bava Basra).

To this the Rebbe gave a beautiful mashal. A man is standing in a large room, an enormous hall, and the place is pitch dark, so that he cannot see a thing. He is told: your task is to get out. He begins feeling along the wall, reaches a place where he senses an opening, and says to himself, at last I have found the door. He feels around and discovers that this is not the way out, because the opening does not reach the floor but only halfway down, a sign that it is only a window. He continues, reaches another opening, and this time immediately identifies it as a window without wasting time. He continues and comes to a different sort of opening that feels like a door; he runs his hand from top to bottom, and apparently this is the exit. He opens it and steps in, only to discover that it is a closet. He comes out, keeps going, enters a room and takes two steps, and discovers that it is an inner chamber. And so he goes on getting more and more entangled, until he finally finds the opening and gets out.

Now, if the place were lit up, how long would it take him to get out? He would walk straight to the door. He would not examine the windows and rule them out one by one; he would not even look at them, he would go directly to the door.

The Rebbe explained that this is the difference between the Rishonim and the Acharonim. The Rishonim look into the Torah and immediately see the door. They have no need to write « perhaps this is the answer », and then bring eight proofs why it is not the answer, and move on to a second possibility that seems more plausible, and reject that too, until they reach a conclusion after a whole sefer. In the end the Acharonim also come out through the same door; it is only that the Rishonim see it at once and do not need to get entangled.

And from here to our subject. It is not our job to go searching on our own for everything, to find gematrias and imagine that we have discovered something, because we are liable to imagine we have found the way out while we are actually stuck inside a closet and do not know it. The great ones of Israel, beginning with the Arizal and the mekubalim who came after him, see these things immediately and reveal to us that this is how they are; they did not search and arrive, they saw and revealed. We learn their words and we know that this is so, because this is what they revealed to us. There are hidden matters we are not meant to go searching for, that are not our business, but they revealed them to us, boruch Hashem.

The End of Chapter 7 and a Summary of the Road So Far:

The conclusion of chapter 7 is a very important waypoint in Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah: we have completed here an entire subject, built layer upon layer. Chapters 1 through 7 are constructed one on top of the other in an orderly, clear fashion: the whole process of tzimtzum with the Divine names, the name Havayah, the name Elokim and the name Ado-nai, and what each one means; the entire descent and contraction, together with the fact that He Himself is right here; and the principle that the tzimtzum is not to be taken literally, as explained in chapter 7. And the conclusion that emerges from all of this: the oneness of the Creator.

General Background for What Begins in Chapter 8:

Seemingly we have finished the subject and everything is clear, yet from chapter 8 onward we will take up a further matter within the same theme. In the mitzvah of the unity of Hashem there are two verses: « Shema Yisrael, Hashem Elokeinu, Hashem Echad » and « Anochi Hashem Elokecha », and each verse represents a different level and a different meaning. Among the mitzvos of the heart, the chovos halevavos, these are two distinct mitzvos:

  • The mitzvah of Achdus Hashem, the unity of Hashem. This is what we have learned until now: « Hashem Echad », yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, and the extent to which the world, even though there is a reality and there is a world, is nullified and as nothing.

  • The mitzvah of Ha'amanas Elokus, faith in G-dliness. From here on we will not be speaking about the created beings of the world and how they are nullified to the Creator, but about the Divine sefiros and the Divine middos, which are likewise one with Him and add to Him neither multiplicity nor composition. It is all Him.

This is a loftier domain than what we have studied until now, and it too is of great importance: among the mitzvos a Yid is obligated in every single day are the mitzvah of Achdus Hashem and the mitzvah of Ha'amanas Elokus. The Tzemach Tzedek, the Alter Rebbe's grandson, in his sefer Derech Mitzvosecha, divided them into two separate mitzvos and wrote a full-length treatment of Achdus Hashem and a full-length treatment of Ha'amanas Elokus; here in Tanya the material is set down in condensed, concentrated form. That is the difference between the chapters up to chapter 8 and the chapters from chapter 8 onward. And with Hashem's help, just as we tried to dive into the waters in the first part, may we merit to dive into the second part as well.

A Further Mashal for the Nothingness of the World:

To close, let us complete a point connected to what we have learned: a beautiful mashal that can explain the nothingness of the world. We spoke about the world's nothingness on various levels, in general terms, and in terms of memaleh kol almin and sovev kol almin. In the previous lesson we examined three levels in the mashal of a human being: thought, the faculty of speech, and actual speech:

  • Thought, on this level the world is entirely nullified, like a thought that exists within a person and is united with him.

  • The faculty of speech, here a sense of independent existence already begins, yet the matter is still contained within the person himself.

  • Actual speech, speech has, as it were, separated and gone outside, and the existing world has passed through all the screens.

And we must know that even though it has passed through all the screens, the world that we perceive as a separate reality is in truth nullified to the Aibershter. The question is how each level regards the world: how Divine thought looks at it, how the faculty of speech looks at it, and how actual speech looks at it. All three arrive at the same conclusion, that a world which considers itself to be something is nothing but a lie, and the truth is that only the Aibershter exists, but each one of them views this on a different level.

To illustrate, picture three people walking into a room:

  1. The first says: « I saw a building flying. » We ask him: a building flying? Perhaps a bomb blew the building up? And he insists: there was no bomb at all, a building was flying! What do we tell him? « You are lying. A building is inanimate and it stands still. Did you really just see a building soaring through the air? » After all, he spoke in terms of existing concepts: « building » is a real concept, « flying » is a real concept, and even the pairing of « flying » with a physical object exists (a bird flies). It is only that he joined them together in a way that is not true, and therefore he is simply a liar.

  2. The second says: « I saw a round square. » Here we will not content ourselves with calling him a liar, and we will not get into an argument with him; we will tell him he is not in his right mind. A square is one thing and a circle is another. We can still conduct a dialogue with him and explain the absurdity of his words, but the level of rejection is far greater.

  3. The third says: « I was outside and I saw nothing. » With this man there is no conversation at all: there is no need to tell him he is lying, and there is no point in explaining that his words are beside the point. There is simply nobody to talk to, nobody to communicate with. Here the rejection is absolute.

And this is a mashal for the nothingness of the world on each of the Divine levels:

  • From the standpoint of sovev kol almin, from the standpoint of yichuda ila'ah, the world that shouts « I » is like nothing, and nothing is saying nothing. There is not even anything to relate to, since on that level there is not even the power that contracted itself into a world and a creation.

  • From the standpoint of the faculty of speech, which is already a descent and a tzimtzum into the concept of created beings, here there is already some grasp of something, but: do not claim that you are an independent reality, do not say something illogical, say something sensible.

  • From the standpoint of actual speech, this has already separated and conveys a sense of separateness, and here the world shouts « I am separate, I am a reality. » To this we say: you are simply lying. The concept of separateness was created by the Aibershter, but you are not truly separate; the truth is that you are completely bound up with Him.

The higher the level, the more absolute the world's nothingness becomes, and the mashal explains the matter to us in line with these three levels.

In summary: in this section we learned from Likkutei Torah about precious stones, which although they are inanimate nevertheless give off light, by the power of the stars that are unseen and without number, since specifically the lowest rung receives from the very highest. We saw that the stone, the lowest level in creation, shines, while plant, animal and speaker do not, apart from great tzaddikim in whom we find that they shone. We examined the hint that « even » is alef plus Ban, the refinement of the nefesh habahamis through the nefesh ha'elokis, and the fact that a Yid is called a « partner with the Holy One in the work of creation ». We learned from the Rebbe's mashal of the dark room and the lit room that it is not our task to go searching on our own, but to study what the great ones of Israel have revealed to us. We summed up the road we have traveled in chapters 1 through 7, the tzimtzum, the Divine names, the tzimtzum that is not literal, and the conclusion of the oneness of the Creator, and we closed with the mashal of the three men, which teaches the nothingness of the world on each of the Divine levels. The conclusion we must carry in our awareness: how to look at reality and at creation, and to know that it all exists only in order to connect things to the Aibershter, and not, chas veshalom, as some other reality.

In the next section we will begin, with Hashem's help, chapter 8, and take up the mitzvah of Ha'amanas Elokus: the Divine sefiros and middos, which are likewise one with Him and add to Him neither multiplicity nor composition.