We have reached chapter 7 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, on page 83a (page 165). At the bottom of the page, in the last four lines, a new passage begins, «Vehinei mikan», and that is where we stopped. We already gave an introduction to the topic in the previous session, but let us open with a short review, and as we go along we will return to these points and sharpen them.
«Ani Havayah lo shanisi», the heart of the previous section:
The prophet Malachi says in the name of the Holy One: «Ani Havayah lo shanisi», I, G-d, have not changed. The obvious question is: what could have caused a change, that Scripture needs to stress that none took place? We might have imagined that the very creation of the world, dealing with it, watching over it, keeping it alive, would naturally produce a change, as if the Creator before the world was created is not the same Creator afterward. By way of a distant comparison: a person before he owned a car and after he owns a car is not the same person. He sleeps less well at night; he is preoccupied and worried about what will be and how it will be. A person gets caught up in whatever he is busy with. Yet here, even though there is a vast world and many worlds and creatures and countless details, we say: «Atah Hu ad shelo nivra haolam, Atah Hu mishenivra haolam», You are the same before the world was created and You are the same after the world was created, with no change whatsoever.
Here is the point of difference between creations and the Creator. We are made up of details and sub-details that come together into one. A person has intellect, he has emotion, and he has the information he takes in from his surroundings. When information is added, knowledge accumulates, and he acts accordingly; once new data arrives, he changes his behavior and adjusts himself to the situation. And why does he change? Because all the information entering the database in his mind comes from the outside, and something external that enters inside is constantly changing him.
With the Holy One it is entirely different. We quoted at length the language of the Rambam: He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge itself. That is, His knowledge of everything that happens is not external knowledge. It is not that there is a world out there somewhere, with worlds and creatures in it, and He receives a stream of data from them and acts accordingly. Were that the case, a change would certainly be produced in Him, G-d forbid, since new information keeps arriving all the time. Rather, everything is He and everything is within Him, and none of this knowledge is anything external at all.
True, in our own experience we are external to Him and separate from Him, but that very experience is itself a creation: the Holy One is the One who produced and implanted in the created being the sensation of separateness, as we learned at length at the beginning of chapter 7 regarding the name Ad-nai and the attribute of malchus. But that does not mean that real separateness came into being. From the standpoint of truth no separateness was created at all; everything is He and everything is within Him, even though the created being constantly feels itself to be an independent existence.
And why did the Holy One want to give us this sense of separateness? Because through it His kingship over us is revealed, for «ein melech belo am», there is no king without a people, and with this the whole concept of malchus came into being. From here comes our avodah: not in theory but in practice, to connect and to reveal the bond.
The second foundation of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah:
Now let us move on to what is taught in this chapter, which is a most fundamental matter. All of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah essentially comes to give us two foundations. One foundation we have learned until now; now we will learn the second, and the two together give us the complete recognition of the reality of the Creator's oneness.
The words of the Arizal and the dispute over their meaning:
The holy Arizal, speaking about the order of the world's creation, said a few sentences that were recorded by his students. Already in the first generation after him, arguments broke out among the mekubalim as to how to interpret his words and what he meant, and in general two approaches emerged. The Alter Rebbe will bring one of these approaches here, reject it on several grounds, and then present the approach that chassidus follows.
The Arizal's words are: «Betechilah hayah or ein sof memaleh es kol mekom hechalal, velo hayah makom laamidas haolamos», in the beginning the Or Ein Sof filled the entire space, and there was no place for the worlds to stand. Let us first understand the words themselves: there was a revelation of ein sof, of the infinite, of that which has no limit, and there was no place for the worlds to stand.
What does «there was no place» mean? It does not mean a technical location, but rather holding any place at all: there was no such reality as a world, as limit, as a created being. It is like a person sitting in a shiur or talking with a friend, and suddenly someone throws in a point that has nothing to do with the subject, and they tell him: «Your point has no place here», meaning it has no relevance, it holds no place. So too here: when there is a revelation of ein sof, there is no place for the concept of limit and of a world.
And the Arizal continues with the sentence around which the whole discussion revolves: «Silek oro hagadol hatzidah», He withdrew His great light to the side. What does «He withdrew His great light to the side» mean? In other words: He contracted, He made room, He made possibility, and here is where the opinions divide.
It is worth prefacing a point that is not written here but is brought at length in maamarim of chassidus: the dispute is actually made up of two separate questions, and from them four possible opinions could emerge:
Who is being spoken about in «He withdrew»: the Maor, the Luminary, meaning the Essence of the Creator Himself, or only His or, His light?
What does «He withdrew» mean: an actual withdrawal in the literal sense, or that this is not a tzimtzum kipshuto, a literal contraction, but only a concealment, something that is not seen but is nonetheless fully present?
Let us focus on the two extremes:
The first opinion: not only was the infinite light withdrawn, but the Maor as well, the very Essence of the Creator, and literally so: tzimtzum kipshuto, a contraction in the plain sense of the word.
The Alter Rebbe's position: the Maor, the Essence of the Creator, certainly underwent no tzimtzum whatsoever, and He is present in His full intensity right now as well. And if we speak of any change at all, it is only in the or, in the radiance; and even there the tzimtzum is not literal. It is not that the light was removed, but that we do not sense it. This is tzimtzum shelo kipshuto, a non-literal contraction, and in the light alone.
The root of the opinion the Alter Rebbe rejects:
Those who held the first opinion were great Torah leaders, and although when we learn this part of Tanya we find it hard to understand their view, its root lies in a desire to honor the Holy One: it is not fitting for the king's honor to be physically present in a garbage dump. It is not befitting for him to be in the storerooms, nor even in the outer hall; what befits him is to be inside his royal chamber.
And what about everything that happens in all places, even the lowest ones? Of course these great Torah leaders knew that the Holy One supervises every single detail and that everything is under His hashgachah. But in their view the form of that hashgachah is like a king sitting in his palace: screens are before him, he himself is not there, but at every moment he sees and receives an image from every place; and when he sees something that needs fixing, he sends his representative to arrange it this way or that, while he himself remains in his royal chamber. In their day there was no such virtual technology to describe, but that was the picture: the king supervises from his royal chamber, yet he is not there himself. And if he is not there himself, that is called having withdrawn himself from there so as not to be involved in it. Not that he does not supervise, and not that he handed the matter over to someone else, but that he himself is not present there.
Rejecting this opinion on several grounds:
First reason: the entire concept of «being here» and «not being here because the place does not befit him» applies only to something defined and limited. With a physical object, a cup belongs here, so it is here and not there. The same is true of something spiritual: where is the intellect located? In the brain, not in the feet. And what is the definition of «located»? That the place receives it, senses it, connects to it, recognizes it, and on that level the intellect is not in the feet. It emerges, then, that the very definition of «present» or «not present», whether in physicality or in spirituality, applies only to something defined and limited, which in the language of the Tanya is «mimikrei haguf», a general term for anything defined, whether physical or spiritual. But with regard to the Creator, the definition that He is not here because the place does not suit Him does not apply at all.
Second reason: it does not fit with the words of the Rambam. Even those who hold this view agree that the Holy One knows what is happening in the «garbage dump», and we must ask how He receives that information: is it something external that comes to Him, or is it that «He and His knowledge are one»? If you say the information is external, then it produces a change in Him, since new information arrives at every moment. You are forced to say that it produces no change in Him, because He and His knowledge are one. And if so, wherever His knowledge is found, He Himself is found, and it makes no sense to say that He withdrew Himself from there.
Third reason: the Alter Rebbe brings explicit quotations, among them from Tikkunei Zohar, from which it is proven outright that the tzimtzum is not to be taken literally.
To summarize: in this section we reviewed the foundation we had learned, «Ani Havayah lo shanisi», that there is no change in the Creator because His knowledge is not external knowledge but rather «He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge», and that the created being's sense of separateness is itself a creation, designed for the revelation of malchus. From there we moved to the second foundation of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah: the words of the Arizal that «He withdrew His great light to the side», the dispute over their meaning (is the tzimtzum in the Maor or in the or, and is it literal or by way of concealment), the root of the opinion that holds tzimtzum kipshuto (the honor of the king who dwells in his royal chamber), and the three grounds on which the Alter Rebbe rejects it.
In the next section we will learn the material inside, in the Alter Rebbe's own words, and after that we will look at both foundations together and at the overall picture of the chiddush of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah.