TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 7 · What Is a Divine Tzimtzum?

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we saw that the Holy One watches over every single detail, because everything is Him, and before Him all is equal: the small no less than the great. Now we continue with the language of the Rambam, and from there we move on to a further foundation that also rests on what we learned in chapter 7: the concept of tzimtzum.

«ואין דבר נעלם ממנו, ואין ידיעה זו מוסיפה בו ריבוי והרכבה כלל» («Nothing is hidden from Him, and this knowledge adds to Him no multiplicity or composition whatsoever»). Nothing is concealed from Him, and what He knows about some new gnat that has just come into the world is not a new piece of information acquired by Him. He formed it; it is He Himself, part of Him, and therefore nothing in Him has changed. This is the meaning of «אתה הוא עד שלא נברא העולם, אתה הוא משנברא העולם» («You are He before the world was created, You are He after the world was created»): it is all one.

«ולפי שזה קשה מאוד לצייר בשכלנו» («And since this is very difficult for our minds to picture»): it is extremely hard for our intellect to imagine such a thing, since everything registers with us in an entirely different way. «על כן אמר הנביא» («therefore the prophet said»): the Rambam brings verses from the prophets that express our inability to grasp the Creator's conduct, for in truth we simply have no capacity for it.

  • «כי גבהו שמים מארץ כן גבהו דרכי מדרכיכם ומחשבותי ממחשבותיכם» («For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are My ways higher than your ways and My thoughts than your thoughts»). Just as the heavens are high and distant from the earth, so are His thoughts distant from our thoughts. In truth the gap is infinitely greater, for between heaven and earth there is a distance that can at least be measured, whereas between Creator and created there is no proportion at all. It is simply that the created being is given an analogy he can grasp, as if to say: just as you can see the distance between heaven and earth, so is the distance between My thoughts and yours, and you have no ability to grasp it at all.

  • «החקר אלוק תמצא וגו'» («Can you by searching find out God?»)

  • «וכתיב: העיני בשר לך, אם כראות אנוש תראה» («And it is written: Do You have eyes of flesh, do You see as man sees?»). Is Your seeing like the seeing of a human being? Eyes of flesh receive information from the outside, whereas with Him everything is Him. And although Scripture speaks of «an eye that sees and an ear that hears», using the concepts familiar to us from our own world, it is not at all the way we see and hear, «שהאדם רואה ויודע כל הדברים בידיעה שחוץ ממנו, והקב"ה בידיעת עצמו. עד כאן לשונו» («for man sees and knows all things with a knowledge outside of himself, while the Holy One knows with the knowledge of Himself. End of his words»).

That is the end of the Rambam's language, which the Alter Rebbe cites at length in order to explain the principle of «אני ה' לא שניתי» («I, God, have not changed»), and he notes: «עיין שם בהלכות יסודי התורה» («see there in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah»), meaning that the entire quotation is based, with certain additions, on the Rambam's words there. «והסכימו עמו חכמי הקבלה, כמבואר בפרדס מהרמ"ק ז"ל» («and the masters of Kabbalah agreed with him, as explained in the Pardes of the Ramak of blessed memory»).

Why is this whole explanation brought here?

Because all of it leans on, and is built upon, what we learned earlier in chapter 7. Once we understood that there is not only yichuda ila'ah (the higher unity) but also yichuda tata'ah (the lower unity), that even the lowest creature, the one that feels its own independent existence, is in truth one with the Creator, we can understand why «I, God, have not changed», and why «You are He before the world was created and You are He after the world was created»: because it is all Him.

And the fact that we do not feel this way is itself part of the wonder the Holy One granted us: to feel otherwise. As we discussed in chapters 5 and 6, it is from the side of gevurah, from the side of the Name Elokim, that we were given the sense of being a separate existence; and beyond that, from the side of the Name Adnus we were even given the sense of separation. But this is not the truth as it is from His side, only from the side of the perception that we were given. Hence from our side there is change in our knowledge, while from His side, «I, God, have not changed».

That is one great foundation in the principle of «I, God, have not changed», and it rests on the understanding that came before. Now the Alter Rebbe moves on to a further foundation, no less important, which also rests on that same understanding: the concept of tzimtzum in Elokus.

The concept of tzimtzum:

Where does this concept come from? In the writings of Kabbalah, in the description of the order of hishtalshelus (the chain of worlds descending one from another), it is taught that at first the Ohr Ein Sof, the infinite light, filled all of the «space»; then the Holy One withdrew His great light to the side and contracted it; and afterwards He revealed a light of a thin, measured «line» (kav). Obviously one must not look at such a description with coarse, physical eyes and picture it as an actual event; it has to be studied with a great deal of abstraction, as is explained in the maamarim of chassidus. In any case, the concept of tzimtzum is written in Kabbalah, and its meaning is: the Holy One contracted the unlimited light so that limited worlds and created beings could come into existence.

Let us begin from the lowest level, in our own world of concepts: what is a tzimtzum? Tzimtzum means definition: reduction, limitation and placement. And this concept of placement and definition does not apply only to physical things, but to spiritual ones as well:

  • The intellect: the intellect is a spiritual thing, and nevertheless it is defined by place, it is in the brain and not in the feet. And why do the feet not absorb intellect? Because they do not have the vessels to receive it.

  • The power of sight: this too is a spiritual power, and it is located specifically in the eyes, because it is absorbed specifically in the structure of the flesh of the eye and not anywhere else.

What does it mean to «be present» somewhere?

When we say of something that it is present in a certain place, we mean that the place contains it: it absorbs it, registers it, recognizes it, and there is a match between the giver and the receiver. But if there is no relationship at all between the place and the thing, the higher did not arrive and the lower did not receive, then we do not call that being present there. Accordingly, the intellect is present in the brain, because the brain has a vessel capable of absorbing it.

[An analogy: a man delivers a deep and fascinating lecture in Chinese to someone who does not understand Chinese. When the lecture is over, can we say that the ideas are now in the listener's head? Words of intellect were spoken, he has a brain, and he even heard them; but since he did not absorb them, they are not present in him. The same is true of a person's own vessels: when he lacks the vessels to grasp a new idea and express it, the idea is not present in him.]

And from here to the Ohr Ein Sof: since it is unlimited, a limited place cannot contain it; and since it does not contain it, we do not call that light «present» there. [The exception is the Kodesh HaKodoshim, where «that which is above place» was openly seen within place, as we discussed in an earlier lesson: the limited place contained the Unlimited.]

Everything, physical or spiritual, has a defined presence: the book is here and not somewhere else, because this place contains it right now. And even spiritual things are not present everywhere; they are contracted, their revealed and felt presence is in this domain and not in another. In other words: this is what is called tzimtzum.

With this we can understand what is written in Kabbalah: in order to create this physical world, the Holy One, as it were, contracted His light, withdrew His great light to the side, and created a limited order of hishtalshelus. And why was this necessary? In order to create limited worlds, because the Holy One desired a dirah betachtonim, a dwelling place in the lower realms.

Tzimtzum taken literally: the view of the «wise in their own eyes»:

A person who looks at the concept of tzimtzum with plain physical eyes, hearing the statement for the first time, will understand it literally: the Holy One contracted Himself, actually, meaning He is not present in a place that cannot contain Him, but rather remains in the higher state, and in the lower levels of hishtalshelus He merely supervises from above.

So said certain thinkers, and even Jewish thinkers said so: it is beneath His honor. What business does the honor of the king have rummaging in garbage heaps, overseeing that the refuse lies in its proper place? It is beneath His honor to be present even in the upper world, and all the more so beneath His honor to be present in this lowly physical world; and for this they cited «רם על כל גויים ה', על השמים כבודו» («God is exalted above all nations, His glory is above the heavens»). When He wishes, He supervises and sees, everything is transparent before Him, as it were by «remote control», but He is not present there. They are not saying, God forbid, that things happen on their own with no Master of the house; they say that He knows everything and supervises, only that His supervision is from above alone. And from this they arrived at the conclusion that the concept of tzimtzum said regarding the Creator is literally so: the Holy One contracted Himself and is not present here, «present» in exactly the sense we defined, that the place contains Him and He is within it.

The Alter Rebbe's response:

Everything we have learned until now is the ground on which the Alter Rebbe builds his answer to those thinkers, whom he calls «wise in their own eyes». They are convinced that with their words they are honoring the Creator and exalting Him, that a king does not dig in refuse. The Alter Rebbe tells them: with this you are not honoring Him at all, you are limiting Him and loading onto Him the conditions of a body. And there are two points in this:

  1. The concept of «present here and not present there» belongs to the conditions of a body, body in the broad sense, physical or spiritual, as we said that intellect is in the head and not in the feet. But in the Creator there are no bodily conditions whatsoever.

  2. According to everything that has been explained, it is all Him. And if one says that He merely «supervises from above», that implies that there is here a real existence separate from Him; and if there is a separate existence, then that existence has added knowledge to Him, so how can «I, God, have not changed» possibly hold true?

Therefore the Alter Rebbe says that the tzimtzum is not literal: the Holy One is present here in full force, and the word «tzimtzum» is only the use of a concept, not something to be taken literally.

In summary: in this section we learned that since it is all Him, «nothing is hidden from Him and this knowledge adds to Him no multiplicity or composition whatsoever», and His knowledge is knowledge of Himself and not a knowledge outside of Him, in the language of the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah, with whom the masters of Kabbalah agreed, as explained in the Pardes. We saw that this foundation rests on the yichuda tata'ah we learned in chapter 7, and that the change is only in our own knowledge, from the side of the Name Elokim and the Name Adnus. From there we moved to the further foundation, the concept of tzimtzum: we defined what presence means (that the place contains and absorbs), and what tzimtzum means (definition, limitation and placement); we presented the view of the «wise in their own eyes», that the tzimtzum is literal and the Holy One supervises from above alone, and the Alter Rebbe's response, that this loads bodily conditions onto Him, and that the tzimtzum is not literal.

In the next section we will learn the material from within, in the Alter Rebbe's own words, and we will expand at length on the concept of tzimtzum.