TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 7 · How Can Hashem Possibly Hold So Much Information?!

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we saw that a human being is, through and through, a composite: intellect and emotion, with thought, speech and action clothed over them. That is precisely why every piece of information a person takes in changes him. In this section we turn to the simple oneness of the Holy One, blessed be He, where knowledge adds nothing whatsoever to Him, and we return to the Alter Rebbe's words in chapter 7.

With the Holy One, blessed be He: a simple oneness

Above, none of this applies. «ה' אחד» (Hashem is One) means that He is not composite in any way at all: He Himself, His knowing, the information known, and His very essence, all of it is one, in time, in place, and in every respect, as He was, is and will be. This is the Rambam's language: «הוא היודע והוא הידוע והוא הדעה עצמה - הכל אחד» (He is the Knower, He is the Known, and He is the Knowledge itself, all one). And the Rambam immediately adds: «ודבר זה אין כוח בפה לאומרו ולא באוזן לשמעו ולא בלב האדם להכירו על בוריו» (this is something the mouth has no power to express, nor the ear to hear it, nor the heart of man to grasp it clearly). The mouth cannot explain this oneness within G-dliness; and even if someone were found who could explain it, there would be no one capable of hearing it and absorbing it, and the human heart cannot recognize it as it truly is.

There is an interesting precision here: the Rambam rules out only recognizing it «על בוריו», clearly, in its full truth. The implication is that a recognition that is not full is in fact possible: a person can arrive at an understanding that this is how it is with the Creator, together with the understanding that we have no capacity to grasp it.

An illustration: a person sees with his own eyes something that makes no sense and cannot be grasped. Did he understand what he saw? No. Does he begin to doubt that it really happened? Also no. He says that it does not seem logical and that he has no idea how to explain it, and nevertheless he has not a shred of doubt about the fact itself, because he saw it tangibly, with his own eyes. A person can therefore connect to something and recognize that it is so, even while he does not understand it. And just as this works with the sight of the eyes, so too the intellect itself can recognize that logic demands that the Creator is not assembled out of parts but is One, and that the limited instruments of a human being simply cannot understand how.

Something similar took place at Mount Sinai: «וכל העם רואים את הקולות» (and all the people saw the sounds). There was seeing there, but not understanding and internalizing. Had they understood and internalized it, the sin of the golden calf would not have followed.

«מהותו ועצמותו ודעתו הכל אחד ממש»

And why is it in fact this way with the Creator, so that the mouth has no power to say it nor the ear to hear it? «כי הקב״ה מהותו ועצמותו ודעתו - הכל אחד ממש מכל צד ופינה בכל דרך יחוד» (because with the Holy One, blessed be He, His essence and His being and His knowledge are all literally one, from every side and angle, in every manner of unity). We try to understand this from inside our own world and our own habits of thought, and so we ask: surely information about a multitude of creatures has been added to Him, how does it not preoccupy Him? But we have no ability to absorb this, exactly as the Rambam says, the mouth cannot say it and the ear cannot hear it. All that is clear to us is that with Him everything is literally one, «ואין דעתו דבר נוסף על מהותו ועצמותו, כמו שהוא בנפש האדם, שדעתה דבר נוסף על מהותה ומורכב בה» (His knowledge is not something additional to His essence and being, as it is in the soul of man, whose knowledge is something added to its essence and compounded within it). With a human being, the intellect, the information and the knowledge are additions to himself, and that is why he is able to expand them, contract them and develop them.

And here is the proof that in a human being knowledge is an addition, a composite: «שהרי כשאדם לומד ויודע איזה דבר, כבר היתה בו נפשו המשכלת בטרם שלמד וידע, ואחר שלמד וידע נתוספה ידיעה זו בנפשו» (for when a person learns and comes to know something, his intellectual soul was already present in him before he learned and knew, and after he learned and knew, this knowledge was added to his soul). His intellectual soul was his before he studied as well, only that after studying he grew wiser, developed and changed, and tomorrow he will grasp something still more complex, because he has developed his understanding. «וכן מדי יום ביום, ימים ידברו ורוב שנים יודיעו חכמה» (and so it goes day after day, days shall speak and a multitude of years shall teach wisdom): the more he learns, the more his faculty of wisdom changes, and he himself changes, «ואין זו אחדות פשוטה כי אם מורכבת» (and this is not a simple oneness but a composite one). «אבל הקב״ה הוא אחדות פשוט בלי שום הרכבה וצד ריבוי כלל» (but the Holy One, blessed be He, is a simple oneness, with no composition and no aspect of plurality at all).

Even though we do not understand how it works with Him, one thing is clear to us: He is not conditioned or bounded by our limitations. He created us, and it makes no sense to load onto Him the limitations He placed within us. Just as it is obvious to every person that He has no physical body, since a body is limited and confined, so too one must fold away and remove from Him every concept we know from the physical world, and even every spiritual concept we know, for every such concept is itself something He created, with its limitations and in its particular mode, while He in Himself is above all of it. «ואם כן על כרחך מהותו ועצמותו ודעתו - הכל אחד ממש, בלי שום הרכבה» (and therefore, of necessity, His essence and His being and His knowledge are all literally one, with no composition whatsoever).

And since with Him everything is one, it follows that just as we cannot apprehend the Creator Himself, so too we cannot apprehend His knowledge and how He knows. «ולפיכך, כשם שאי אפשר לשום נברא בעולם להשיג מהות הבורא ועצמותו, כך אי אפשר להשיג מהות דעתו» (and therefore, just as it is impossible for any creature in the world to apprehend the essence and being of the Creator, so it is impossible to apprehend the essence of His knowledge). For if we could understand the manner of His knowing even while not understanding His essence, that would imply that He and His knowledge are two separate things. The moment we apprehend, we have created plurality. Because of our limitation we have no way at all of apprehending how He knows, as in the well known phrase: «אילו ידעתיו הייתיו» (if I knew Him, I would be Him).

Then why do the Torah and its commentators use examples and analogies at all? So that we should be able to understand certain things. But one must strip the analogy away from what it points to and know that it is no more than an analogy. So too when we say of the Holy One, blessed be He, that He is «חכם», wise, and it is known that there were those who objected even to using such an expression, the intent is only that He is not not-wise, just as He is not not-mighty. We imagine that calling Him wise is a dignified description, but that is only because in our world there is a hierarchy of titles and levels, and so the title of wisdom strikes us as dignified. The same is true of the term «מלך», King, which we use constantly. All of these expressions mean that the Holy One, blessed be He, contracted Himself and allowed us to address Him this way; but one must not conclude from them that our definitions actually apply to Him.

So what is left to us? «רק להאמין באמונה שלמעלה מהשכל וההשגה, שהקב״ה יחיד ומיוחד, והוא ודעתו הכל אחד ממש» (only to believe, with a faith that is above intellect and comprehension, that the Holy One, blessed be He, is one and unique, and that He and His knowledge are all literally one). And why do we believe that it is so? Because that is what is written in the Torah: the prophet Malachi says «אני ה' לא שניתי» (I, Hashem, have not changed), and in our daily prayers we say «אתה הוא עד שלא נברא העולם, אתה הוא משנברא העולם» (You are He before the world was created, You are He since the world was created). Do we understand it? No. But we believe that it is so, for we are Jews who believe, and we believe everything written in the Torah.

And faith is like seeing. Just as a person sees something and does not understand how it can be, and nonetheless has no doubt about it, so it is with faith. And precisely for this reason a person can believe and at the same time do things that run directly against his faith, like the thief who breaks in through the wall and calls out to the Holy One, blessed be He, to help him succeed: he absolutely believes, and he steals anyway. For faith is like a photograph of the matter without internalization; the person has not become part of it and has not changed. And if he does not drive the matter inward, think about it and study it, it will not act upon him.

«הוא בידיעת עצמו מכיר ויודע»

Here comes the central point. When we know something, our knowing comes from knowledge that is external; something from outside added information to us. With the Holy One, blessed be He, the knowledge does not come from outside; rather, «ובידיעת עצמו מכיר ויודע כל הנמצאים עליונים ותחתונים» (and by knowing Himself He recognizes and knows all existing things, higher and lower). It is like the analogy we learned in the earlier chapters: the light of the sun never actually leaves the sun. The created being feels as though it has gone out, because that is the sensation the Holy One, blessed be He, gives it, to be inside and to feel itself outside, but in truth it is always inside and is part of Him. So there is no database here being fed by external reports transmitted to Him; rather, all of it is He.

And His knowing extends «עד שלשול קטן שבים ויתוש קטן בטבור הארץ» (down to a small worm in the sea and a tiny gnat at the center of the earth). The worm is the smallest creature in its dimensions; the gnat is the lowliest in importance, the cheapest, the one nobody pays any attention to. How many gnats there are, and where exactly each one of them will be, all of it is within His knowledge. For Him there is no difference between what goes on in the great galaxies and what goes on with one particular gnat. For us one is big and one is small; for Him it is all absolutely equal, the same knowing and the same absence of any burden, because all of it is He.

«המגביהי לשבת המשפילי לראות»

We have already mentioned the verse in Tehillim chapter 113, the opening psalm of Hallel and therefore familiar to many: «רם על כל גויים ה', על השמים כבודו. מי כה' אלוקינו, המגביהי לשבת, המשפילי לראות בשמים ובארץ» (Hashem is exalted above all nations, His glory is above the heavens. Who is like Hashem our G-d, who dwells on high, who lowers Himself to look upon heaven and earth). Chassidus explains what these two verses are saying:

  • For the nations of the world: «רם על כל גויים ה', על השמים כבודו». They too believe in Him, but as they see it He is lofty and exalted, and therefore His glory is to be found in the heavens: not only in the sense of location, but that He is present in heavenly matters, while with lowly, inferior, cheap things it would be beneath His dignity to occupy Himself.

  • For Israel: «מי כה' אלוקינו, המגביהי לשבת». Precisely because He is so high and so exalted, therefore «המשפילי לראות בשמים ובארץ»: for Him it is the very same lowering, the very same tzimtzum (self-contraction), in heaven and on earth, in absolutely equal measure. He is not closer to the heavens and further from the earth; for Him it is all one single point, and the knowing, the involvement and the hashgacha over every single detail, all of it is He.

What does it mean that He «watches over every detail»? The foundation is this: all of it is He. Think of a person: if he is struck on the hand, of course he notices. But even if he gets a small burn on the nail of the little toe of his left foot, he feels it. Why? Because it is part of him. With regard to what is part of the person himself there is no difference between big and small; he feels all of it.

[There is the well known joke about a man who claimed that during prayer he feels nothing at all. His friends wanted to show him that he was not living in fantasies, so in the middle of davening one of them gave him a light poke with a pin, and he did not stir. He poked him again, harder, and again he did not stir. The third time he poked him with all his strength, and the man jumped. Said the friend: there, you do feel! He answered: but the first two times, you did not feel a thing...]

With the Holy One, blessed be He, it is not so, for all of it is He. It makes no difference whether we are speaking of a small worm in the sea, a tiny gnat at the center of the earth, or the planet Mars and enormous heavenly bodies; with Him it is all the same.

To summarize: In this section we learned that unlike a human being, who is a composite, the Holy One, blessed be He, is a simple oneness, and «מהותו ועצמותו ודעתו הכל אחד ממש» (His essence and being and knowledge are all literally one). His knowledge is not something additional to His essence, as it is in the soul of man, where knowledge is added to the intellectual soul after he has studied. Therefore, just as no creature can apprehend the essence of the Creator, so it cannot apprehend the essence of His knowledge, and all we can do is believe with a faith that is above intellect. We also learned that by knowing Himself He recognizes and knows all existing things, down to a small worm in the sea and a tiny gnat at the center of the earth, and that precisely because He dwells on high, He lowers Himself to look upon heaven and earth equally. And we explained what hashgacha over every single detail means: just as a person feels every part of his body, the small as much as the large, because it is part of him, so with the Holy One, blessed be He, all of it is He, and with Him it is all the same.

In the next section we will continue with the Rambam's language, «ואין דבר נעלם ממנו» (and nothing is hidden from Him), and from there we will move on to a further foundation: the concept of tzimtzum.