TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 7 · The Nature of the Levushim

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

We continue in the middle of chapter 7, on page 82b (page 164). We stopped in the middle of the page, at the line ending with the word «לתחתונים», and from there a new passage begins: «והנה במה שנתבאר יובן מה שכתוב» (And with what has been explained, we can now understand the verse).

Let us begin with a brief review of what we learned in the previous lessons, though this is no easy task, since the material is complex and abstract. We have been dealing with the foundations of a Jew's faith, the faith expressed in the verse «שמע ישראל ה' אלוקינו ה' אחד» (Hear O Israel, the L-rd our G-d, the L-rd is One) and in the words said immediately afterward, «ברוך שם כבוד מלכותו לעולם ועד» (Blessed be the name of the glory of His kingdom forever and ever). The point is that a Jew must absorb into his consciousness the oneness of the Creator, that He is the only reality there is. More than that, we discussed the higher level, yichuda ila'ah (the «upper unity»), according to which the world has no existence at all in terms of its own being and its sense of being; everything is nullified completely.

Why study such lofty levels?

A person might ask: we are busy with the most exalted levels of G-d's oneness. But where do we ourselves actually stand? It would be wonderful if we could even hold on to the lower level, yichuda tata'ah (the «lower unity»), remembering at every moment that there is an Owner who brings us into being, and having the bittul of light outside the sun, which knows that it has a source in the luminary. So what is the point of studying levels that we only read about in a book, levels we apparently have no chance of ever reaching?

Here lies a great principle, and it deserves a lengthy discussion: a person has to know what the truth is, what he is striving toward, what the goal is. True, we are not there and we do not feel it, but at least we will want to rise. If, however, a person sets himself only modest goals and tells himself: I am a reality, a reality dependent on the Almighty, but my existence is something real and solid, and his maximum is yichuda tata'ah in its simplest sense, the result can be a slide downward. For if I am a reality, then my desires are also a reality, and so are my fantasies, my wishes and my private world, until a person can end up in avodah zarah, either in a coarse form or in a subtle one.

In order not to fall, a person must know the truth: everything is null and void, there is no independent reality, everything is G-dliness, He is the Owner, He is the only reality and there is nothing else. It is precisely the knowledge and study of the highest levels that keeps a person pointed in the right direction.

We also mentioned briefly the two forms of unity, yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, and how they are alluded to in the holy Names: the combination of the Name Havayah with the Name Elokim, which takes place within G-dliness itself (chesed and gevurah), and the combination of the Name Havayah with the Name Adnus, which involves the sefirah of malchus, in the two ways we explained at length in the previous lesson.

«I, G-d, have not changed»:

The Alter Rebbe writes: «והנה במה שנתבאר יובן מה שכתוב אני ה' לא שניתי» (With what has been explained, we can understand the verse «I, G-d, have not changed»). On the basis of what we explained regarding yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, that everything taking place in the world is nullified to the Almighty, and that even a creature that feels its own existence is, in truth, utterly nullified, we can now understand the verse in the book of Malachi, «אני ה' לא שניתי». Put simply: I, the Creator, have not changed, and no change has taken place within Me.

The same idea appears in our prayers (there are different versions of the wording, but the idea is one): «אתה הוא עד שלא נברא העולם אתה הוא משנברא העולם» (You are He before the world was created, You are He since the world was created). On a superficial reading, this means that the Almighty is present now too, and one should not imagine that He has disappeared. But if that were the entire meaning, two words here would be superfluous, for it could have said: «You are He before the world was created and since the world was created». Why is the phrase «אתה הוא» repeated?

The repetition carries the emphasis: literally the very same «אתה הוא». Just as it is obvious to everyone that before the Almighty created the worlds, before the first tzimtzum, there was no other reality whatsoever, exactly so, with no change at all, it remains after creation as well.

But how can it be that there is no change?

After all, a world has now been added, there is a reality that the Almighty watches over, brings into being and sustains, from the highest level down to the lowest, an enormous multiplicity of creatures and details, with individual providence over every single detail. The very thought of so many details makes our heads spin, and it would seem that the Creator is occupied with all of it. Apparently, before creation and after creation are not one and the same thing at all.

With human beings the matter is clear: before a person learned a given subject the information was missing from him, and after he learned it his mind is not the same mind and the grooves of his brain are not what they were. True, on one hand one could argue that nothing was added, just as in mathematics, if you add a million, two million or ten million to infinity, you are still left with infinity. But in terms of preoccupation and involvement with details it is different: beforehand I was free, and now I have been given responsibility to watch over, say, additional people and additional enterprises, and apparently I am now busy with one more matter.

The Alter Rebbe continues: «פירוש שאין שום שינוי כלל, כמו שהיה הוא לבדו קודם בריאת העולם כך הוא לבדו אחר שנברא, וזהו שאומרים אתה הוא עד שלא נברא העולם אתה הוא כו'» (meaning that there is no change whatsoever; just as He alone existed before the creation of the world, so He alone exists after it was created, and this is what we say: «You are He before the world was created, You are He...»). He does not complete the rest of the text, because the entire proof lies in the repetition of «אתה הוא»: the same «You are He» before, and the same «You are He» after, with nothing changed and nothing added.

«בלי שום שינוי בעצמותו ולא בדעתו» (without any change in His essence, nor in His knowledge). There is no change in the essence of the Creator, as though previously He was without a world and now He is with a world, and likewise there is no change in His knowledge. Seemingly, before creation He did not have to know all the details of what is happening, since they did not exist, and now He knows them all. In a human database, every added detail makes a difference: another child is born, another entry is added to the government population registry, and immediately a calculation is made as to how much this will cost the state or how much will be collected from him. But in the Almighty there is no change even in His knowing and His knowledge, even though He knows every single detail.

This is something we as creatures cannot grasp, but at least we can understand why it is beyond our grasp, and that too is something.

And here is the reason there is no change at all: «כי בידיעת עצמו יודע כל הנבראים, שהכל ממנו ובטל במציאות אצלו» (for by knowing Himself He knows all created beings, since everything comes from Him and is nullified in its very existence before Him). His knowledge of created beings is His knowledge of Himself, and it is He Himself. It is not like us, where we are one reality and the world around us is another reality, and in order to receive information about what is happening outside we must attach to ourselves something external that was not there before. We are a reality assembled from details and from external things that get added and that disappear, and we have no other way of absorbing anything.

An example from ourselves, and it is not a precise one: when a person receives information from things outside his own world, someone told him, or he read it or heard it, this information certainly produces a change in him, making him wiser and also troubling him. But there is information a person receives from himself: a source of heat touched his toe, and in that very second he feels it. No one on the outside informed him; the knowledge came from within him, it is not from outside but part of him. And yet, what caused the information was an entirely external influence.

Above, however, the knowledge by which the Almighty knows created beings and watches over them is all Him, all within Him, all nullified to Him and part of Him, and therefore nothing is added. And as we learned at length, even on the level of yichuda tata'ah, where the created being does feel its own being and existence and yet recognizes that its entire existence is united and one with the Creator because it is nullified to Him, the difference between yichuda tata'ah and yichuda ila'ah is only relative to the creatures, not relative to Him. Everything is nullified, and there is no information here arriving from something external. For this reason, we also have no analogy capable of explaining this matter.

On this the Alter Rebbe brings the language of the Rambam (a long quotation that continues almost to the end of the following page, with certain additions in the middle): «וכמו שכתב הרמב"ם ז"ל שהוא היודע והוא הידוע והוא הדעה עצמה - הכל אחד» (as the Rambam wrote, that He is the Knower, He is the Known and He is the Knowledge itself, all is one).

In a human being, knowing is composed of three separate things:

  • The knower, the person doing the comprehending.

  • The known, the object he is thinking about at the moment.

  • The knowledge itself, the intellect, the understanding and the contemplation through which he connects to the known.

When these three come together, information results, and when one of the components drops away the information is lost, because we are made up of three different things. In the Almighty, however, all is one.

Thought, speech and action as external levushim:

Take a human being: he has thought, speech and action, he has emotion and he has intellect. What is the relationship between them? We already learned at the beginning of Tanya that thought, speech and action are called the levushim, the «garments» of the soul. What is the definition of a garment? Something you can put on and take off, something entirely external. You can even put on a garment that does not fit the person at all, that does not suit him or is uncomfortable for him.

A simple example: «two plus two equals five» is a statement that is logically untrue, and nevertheless one can say it with one's mouth, write it, and even think it. A person can speak, write and think about things he has no connection to at all, that he does not understand, does not want and even utterly rejects. A person can deliver an entire lecture against smoking and at the end light himself a cigarette without the slightest difficulty; he speaks and explains, and he is not connected to the content at all. All this is because thought, speech and action are something entirely external to the person himself.

The beinoni and the levushim:

Incidentally, this is also the reason why, on the side of holiness, the first section of Tanya, which deals with the concepts of the tzaddik and the beinoni, states that every single person can be a beinoni, and that this is a demand placed on each individual. In what is the beinoni careful? In thought, speech and action. His desires may be of the worst sort and his understanding of the lowest sort, and nevertheless it is in his power to connect to the mitzvos in deed, to learn Torah and to think about what is fitting to think about, for these things are within his ability, even though he has not changed himself in any essential way.

The levushim, then, thought, speech and action, are external, while understanding and emotion are more internal. More than that: in the first section of Tanya the Alter Rebbe expresses it by saying that intellect and emotion are the soul itself.

Is the intellect truly the soul itself, literally?

That too cannot be, since the intellect is something that undergoes change: knowledge increases or decreases, and one person's capacity to understand is greater than another's. Emotion too can be developed and changed. True, changing one's worldview and changing one's feeling toward a particular thing is far harder than changing thought, speech and action, but in the end it is possible.

It turns out that the human being as a whole is built as a composite: intellect and emotion, with thought, speech and action clothed over them. His body too is composed of 248 limbs and 365 sinews, of a multitude of details and cells. As a result, every piece of information we absorb is something external that gets added to us and changes us: we thought about it and a change occurred; we lost it and forgot it and we are distressed. All our days we are caught in the constant fluctuation of being a composite.

In summary: in this section we learned the explanation of the verse «אני ה' לא שניתי» and of the repeated phrase «אתה הוא» in the prayers, that there is no change whatsoever in the Creator, neither in His essence nor in His knowledge, and that just as He alone existed before the creation of the world, so He alone exists after it was created. The reason: «בידיעת עצמו יודע כל הנבראים», by knowing Himself He knows all created beings, since all creatures are nullified to Him and are not external information added to Him; and in the Rambam's words, He is the Knower, He is the Known and He is the Knowledge itself, all is one. We also explained that thought, speech and action are external garments to the soul of man, which is why every single person can be a beinoni; and that intellect and emotion are more internal and are even called in Tanya «the soul itself», and yet they too change and develop, since the human being as a whole is a composite.