In the previous section we worked out the difference between the tzimtzum of the name Elokim and the tzimtzum of the name Ad-ni, and we saw that even the mashal (the parable) the student received is not considered a concealment: not only in relation to the teacher, but even within the student's own world the mashal is still attached to the teacher. Now we will take this up in detail, in the subject of yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah.
The name Ad-ni and the reality of time and space:
Before we expand on yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, there is one more point to sharpen in the concept of Ad-ni, which is the sefirah of malchus: what sort of reality came into being as a result of this tzimtzum? We used the word «separateness»: the world is experienced as something separate. In Tanya the Alter Rebbe adds that a reality of time and space came into being. The entire concept of time and space exists only because of the tzimtzum of the name Ad-ni; had the name Elokim alone been shining, there would be no concept of time and space at all.
The reason for this was explained at length in an earlier lesson, and briefly: time and space mean hierarchy, change and gradations, higher and lower, past and future, east and west, all of them kinds of levels. A relationship of «this one is more and this one is less» is possible only when the lower one itself occupies a place and has some value of its own.
As was brought in the mashal: about a wise man it makes no sense to ask in which country he is wise, or how long he has already been wise. The question has no meaning, he is wise. But about a king it does make sense to ask how long he has been reigning, over which territories he reigns, and over what sort of population: if he reigns over very wise people, his stature is thereby elevated; if he reigns over simple people, the level of his kingship is lower. The reason is that the whole concept of kingship presupposes a nation, a reality of separate beings over whom he reigns, and from the very fact that he reigns over them it is evident that they have value and occupy a place. And that very measure of occupying a place is precisely the concept of time and space.
Had there been no descent and tzimtzum in the name Ad-ni, reality would still exist, the same world and the same territories, except that it would have no value of occupying a place and no importance. What difference would it make whether something is higher or lower, when all of it is nothing but an expression of the divine power? There would be no high and low, no past and future, everything would be one single point. But once the Holy One revealed a power called Ad-ni, the created being became something of value that occupies a place. And why was this necessary? Because without it His kingship could not be revealed, since the whole concept of kingship applies only over separate beings. Therefore a reality of separate beings with importance was created, and once they are important it becomes possible to ask who they are and on what level they stand, and here all the ranking and all the gradations came into being. This is the result of the descent of the name Ad-ni, and this is what the Alter Rebbe mentions in Tanya, that the concept of time and space came into being as a result of this tzimtzum.
Yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah:
In the previous lesson we studied the intertwining of the name Havayah with the name Ad-ni, and that there are two kinds of such intertwining:
Yichuda ila'ah (the higher unity): the name Havayah is dominant, and the name Ad-ni is woven into it.
Yichuda tata'ah (the lower unity): the name Ad-ni is dominant, and the name Havayah is woven into it.
In the siddur this is expressed in the order of the letters: when the order is yud, alef, hei, daled, the opening letter belongs to the name Havayah, and that is yichuda ila'ah; when the order is alef, yud, daled, hei, the opening letter belongs to the name Ad-ni, and that is yichuda tata'ah. The letter that opens is what determines which of the two names prevails.
Four levels: «two that are four»:
Here in Tanya only two levels are discussed: yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, Havayah intertwined with Ad-ni and Ad-ni intertwined with Havayah. But in other maamarim of chassidus the subject is expanded, in the language of the Mishnah in tractate Shabbos, «two that are four»: each of the two unities splits into two levels. We will first look at the two extremes, and from them our understanding of the two intermediate stages that Tanya discusses will come into focus.
The lower extreme: the name Ad-ni alone:
Ad-ni means Master of all, and that implies that there is an «all»: there is a reality, there is time, there is space, there is a world. The world occupies a place, it has value and it has existence. And heaven forbid that we should think this means the world insists it has no source: that very world, even though it is created and occupies a place and considers itself important, understands what is explained in chapter one of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, that if the letters of the Holy One were to cease bringing it into being for even one moment, it would not exist. It says: I exist, I am a reality, and together with that I know and I agree, I believe and I even feel to some degree, that my existence depends on the Holy One bringing me into being at every single moment.
This is the very lowest level within yichuda tata'ah, and the Alter Rebbe does not deal with it here at all, since the yichuda tata'ah discussed in Tanya is one in which there is an intertwining of the name Havayah within the name Ad-ni. But in maamarim of chassidus it is explained that there is a level at which the name Ad-ni shines alone and the name Havayah does not shine at all: there is a world, except that this world understands that there is a power bringing it into being at every single moment. This is the very lowest extreme.
It is the name Ad-ni that gives the created being its sense of separateness, and with that sense a person is liable to think that he is capable of existing on his own. Regarding this he studies Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah and understands: even though we feel ourselves separate, and even after we have studied we do not stop feeling ourselves to be a separate reality, nevertheless we believe, and we learn through parables and illustrations, that our existence depends at every single moment on the divine reality. This is his bittul: that he understands that his existence depends on the existence of the Creator.
The upper extreme: the name Havayah alone:
From the standpoint of the name Havayah nothing occupies a place and there is no independent reality at all, only G-dliness. There is no entity here taking up space that one would have to explain to it that it is nullified. Even the perception of time does not apply: was, is and will be as one, everything in a single point, no past and no future and no room for time.
[The expression of past, present and future usually belongs together with the name Ad-ni and with malchus, as in the formula «Havayah melech, Havayah malach, Havayah yimloch», in which a reality of past, present and future is joined to the name Havayah from the perspective of the created being looking upward. But that is a different stage of the subject, and we should not get ahead of ourselves.]
And in the mashal of the teacher and the student: while the teacher is sitting by himself, before he has come to speak with the student, there is no parable in his mind at all. There is no need to ask whether the parable conceals him, since the parable simply does not exist and is not even a topic for discussion; what exists in his mind is the idea alone. This is the name Havayah shining alone.
Over against this, the name Ad-ni alone is the lower extreme: there is a student who has heard a parable, and he understands the parable very well, even better than the lesson it is meant to convey. After he has studied the parable properly, he understands that the lovely story he heard was meant to give him some grasp of an abstract concept, a concept he sees only dimly: he notices the connection, but the parable is what he grasps better. The parable he experiences, it is part of his world, while of the nimshal he understands only that the arrows point in a certain direction.
The two intermediate stages: yichuda ila'ah:
Here in Tanya the Alter Rebbe deals with the two stages in the middle, in which there is an intertwining of Havayah and Ad-ni, and not each one alone. And within that intertwining itself there are two modes, and we will begin with the higher of them.
Yichuda ila'ah means that the name Havayah is the one that dominates and shines, and within it the name Ad-ni is woven in. The illustrations for this were studied at length in Tanya: the light of the sun as it is included within the body of the sun's sphere. True, it is the sun's light we are talking about, but one cannot attribute to it any value or existence of its own. And likewise in the mashal: while the teacher is thinking in his mind about the parable he is about to say, that parable occupies no place at all, it is entirely nullified to the idea. This is yichuda ila'ah.
In this state, is there a world? Indeed there is, for the name Ad-ni is woven in here, and that means there is a world. It is only that the status of this world is one of complete bittul: it exists, but it is utterly nullified.
In summary: in this section we saw that from the name Ad-ni there came into being a separate reality, and with it the concepts of time and space, since kingship applies specifically over separate beings that have value and occupy a place. We learned the two modes of intertwining: yichuda ila'ah, in which the name Havayah dominates and the name Ad-ni is woven into it, and yichuda tata'ah, in which the name Ad-ni dominates and the name Havayah is woven into it. And we learned the four levels of «two that are four»: the upper extreme, in which the name Havayah shines alone, like the teacher who has nothing in his mind but the idea; the lower extreme, in which the name Ad-ni shines alone, like the student who lives inside the parable and knows only that his existence depends on the One who brings it into being; and the two intermediate stages that Tanya discusses, the first of which is yichuda ila'ah, the light as it is included in its luminary, where the world does exist but is completely nullified.
In the next section we will take up the level that follows, the yichuda tata'ah that Tanya discusses, in which the name Ad-ni is the one that dominates and the name Havayah is woven into it.