TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 7 · A Pause to Review

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

We have reached chapter 7 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, page 82b (page 164), and we stopped at the third or fourth line from the top. The subject matter is intricate and abstract, so before we move on let us go back over the foundations we have already learned and sharpen them, since only review and repetition bring an idea inside. As the Rebbe would often say when he finished explaining a concept: «May these words have their effect on me and on those who hear them.»

The central theme of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah:

In this Shaar the Alter Rebbe sets out to explain that the existence of the Holy One is the only existence there is, the sole and exclusive reality, and there is nothing besides Him. Everything rests on the wording of the verse: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד» (You shall know this day and take it to your heart, that Havayah is God in the heavens above and on the earth below; there is nothing else).

Why does the verse need such heavy emphasis, «וידעת» (you shall know) and «והשבות אל לבבך» (and take it to your heart)? If all the verse wanted to tell us was the fact that there is a God, two words would have been enough. But the verse is saying something far greater: not only that there is a God, but that there is no world.

This does not mean that the world does not exist. It certainly exists, and the Torah testifies «בראשית ברא אלוקים את השמים ואת הארץ» (In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth). It means that the world is utterly nullified to the Holy One. This bittul, this self-nullification, is not at all obvious to a person's natural sense as he walks around in the world; on the contrary, his natural sense is that the world is a powerful, functioning reality, the most absolute thing there is as far as he is concerned. That is why a great deal of work is needed to bring the true reality into one's awareness, and that is why the Torah spells it out at length: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים».

The end of the verse is precise as well: «אין עוד» (there is nothing else). The word «עוד» (something else, something more) describes a secondary item, something of lesser importance which nonetheless is there. By saying «אין עוד» the verse teaches that the world's bittul is absolute, to the point that one cannot even call it an «עוד».

Two stages in understanding this:

Up until chapter 7 one point has been explained: the difference between the name Havayah and the name Elokim, about which the verse says «כי ה' הוא האלוקים». From chapter 7 onward a third name enters the picture, the name Ad-noy, and with it a new point.

Review: the name Havayah and the name Elokim:

In order to create the world the Holy One joined two forces together. Both are divine forces, but they operate in opposite directions:

  • The name Havayah is a force of chesed, of bringing into being and of giving, which brings every creature into existence from nothing into something.

  • The name Elokim is a force of tzimtzum and gevurah, of contraction and restraint, which gives the creatures their sense that they exist and that their existence is real.

How is such a sense even possible for them, when from the side of the name Havayah they are completely nullified, on the level of bittul of sunlight within the sun itself, where it is simply inconceivable that the light should have any sense at all that it exists? That is where the power of the name Elokim comes in, the power of the One «המפליא לעשות» (who acts wondrously), a tremendous power which is a great praise of the Creator: it has the ability to give creatures a sense that they are here and that they exist.

And we stressed that this sense exists only relative to the creatures, not relative to the Creator, as in the analogy we learned: an etzem does not conceal an etzem, a thing does not conceal itself. One's hand does not count as a head covering in place of a yarmulke, since the hand is part of the person's own body, and only something foreign can be considered a covering. So too the name Elokim gives the creature a sense of being a reality, yet it is in no way a covering with respect to the Creator.

The new element in chapter 7: the name Ad-noy:

After the revelation of Havayah and then the revelation of the name Elokim, a further name is added here which gives the creatures a new sense of themselves: the name Ad-noy. In terms of the divine sefiros: Havayah is chesed, Elokim is gevurah, and Ad-noy is malchus, as in the phrase «אדון עולם אשר מלך» (Master of the world, who reigned).

And what is malchus about? «אין מלך בלא עם» (there is no king without a people). A king can reign only over subjects who are completely separate from him, over a reality that is foreign to him. Over his sons or over his ministers, who are close to him, he is not considered a king: to his sons he is a father, and to his ministers he is a commander and superior, but not a king. Kingship applies specifically over an «עם», a people, a word related to «עוממות», dimness, people who are strangers and separate.

In the human soul malchus corresponds to the power of speech, as Pasach Eliyahu puts it: «מלכות - פה» (malchus is the mouth), and as the verse says «דבר מלך שלטון» (the word of a king rules). The king rules his people through speech. And in speech itself the same point is evident: a person speaks only to a reality outside himself, to someone who is not himself.

The Holy One wished to reveal His kingship to the creatures, and to that end He planted within them the sense of distance and separateness. For without a sense of separateness the creatures would not be an «עם» at all but would remain close-by sons; and so that there should be a reality of distance upon which kingship could be revealed, the Holy One implanted in the creatures the feeling of being separate. This is what the name Ad-noy adds beyond the name Elokim of the previous chapters.

The analogy of the teacher and the student:

In the earlier chapters, when the learning dealt with the uniqueness of the name Elokim as against the name Havayah, the concept of the name Ad-noy had not yet been explained, and at times the analogies got mixed up with one another. Now that the differences between them are clear, let us set out the precise analogy for each one.

The tzimtzum of the name Elokim: gevurah:

Picture a teacher sitting by himself, with no students, his mind flowing with a great abundance of insight: a deep thinker, in whom one idea gives birth to the next, and each idea brings an example, an analogy, a depth and a further depth. Set against that flow there is another power within him which says to himself «stop» and contracts him, because if he were to let the flow of his mind spread out unchecked he would never arrive at organized, structured intellect.

It is told of the Mitteler Rebbe, the son of the Alter Rebbe, that when he said maamarim of chassidus the chassidim would sit in utter silence and listen, and nevertheless he would stop every so often in the middle of the maamar and say: «Sha, sha.» It was not the listeners he was hushing, nobody was disturbing him, but the flow of his own mind, which was so abundant that from time to time it needed to be contracted and halted.

This halting is not some outside, foreign factor interfering with the idea in the teacher's mind. It takes place within his own mind: he himself sets his own boundaries, this far the flow may come and here it stops. That is the analogy for the name Elokim.

Accordingly, if the creatures had been created from the name Elokim alone, without the name Ad-noy, they would have felt themselves to be a reality and at the same time they would have perceived the reality of the Creator. The power of the name Elokim is a divine power, and it does not conceal Godliness; its entire function is to give the creatures a sense of existence.

The tzimtzum of the name Ad-noy: malchus:

Here the analogy is a teacher with a student sitting beside him who is on an entirely different level. In order for the student to grasp the idea, the teacher has to give him an analogy. And the analogy, before the student has grasped its connection and what it is pointing to, looks like a shift to a different subject entirely, a trip to another country, a story that has nothing at all to do with what the teacher had been discussing, since the analogy in and of itself lies outside the subject. This is a far more severe concealment and tzimtzum than the previous one, in which the teacher held back the flow of his mind within himself, because here a reality has already been formed which is external and entirely foreign.

Which of the two tzimtzumim is the stronger one?

  • The tzimtzum of the name Elokim: On the one hand it is stronger, since this is literal din, severity, which stops the idea and the intellect altogether. The mind was flowing and suddenly it came to a halt, as though a force had entered the teacher's mind saying «stop», and such a contraction is far more drastic. On the other hand, everything that is happening is inside the teacher himself: within his own mind the force of chesed and the force of gevurah are at work, kindness and severity, and there is no foreign reality here at all.

  • The tzimtzum of the name Ad-noy: On the one hand the concealment is far greater, since a genuinely separate reality comes into being here: the analogy, and a student who is entirely foreign. On the other hand, whom does the analogy conceal from? From the student alone; from the teacher himself the analogy conceals nothing whatsoever.

In the chapters up to chapter 7 the discussion was about the name Havayah and the name Elokim, and the Alter Rebbe explained why the name Elokim is not considered a concealment and a hiding: it is all Godliness, and an etzem does not conceal an etzem. True, within the name Elokim there is gevurah and there is room given for the creatures to be a reality, but there is as yet no «student» side to things. Everything is within the «teacher», and Godliness itself is what contains the two forces: the force of din and gevurah and the force of chesed.

But once we arrive at the name Ad-noy, a reality comes into being, a world that feels itself to be a reality, and the question returns and presses: how is this not a concealment? To that comes the answer in the subject of yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah, the higher unity and the lower unity. This entire explanation comes to make clear why the analogy that the student received is not considered a concealment: not only relative to the teacher, but even within the student's own world it is connected to the teacher and is not entirely hidden from him.

In summary: In this section we reviewed the foundation of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, «כי ה' הוא האלוקים... אין עוד»: not only that there is a God, but that the world is nullified to Him with absolute bittul, to the point that it cannot even be called an «עוד». We examined the two forces explained up to chapter 7: the name Havayah, which brings everything into being from nothing into something, and the name Elokim, which contracts and gives the creatures a sense of being real, a sense which is not a covering with respect to the Creator. And in chapter 7 a new name was introduced, Ad-noy, which is malchus, whose principle is «אין מלך בלא עם», and in order for kingship to be revealed the Holy One planted in the creatures the sense of separateness. We explained the difference between the two tzimtzumim through the analogy of the teacher: the tzimtzum of the name Elokim is the halting of the flow of the mind within the teacher himself, whereas the tzimtzum of the name Ad-noy is the analogy given to the foreign student, which creates an external, separate reality, one that conceals from the student alone and not from the teacher. We also explained that even the analogy the student received is not considered a concealment: not only relative to the teacher, but even within the student's own world it is connected to the teacher, and that is the answer provided by the subject of yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah.

In the next section we will sharpen the concept of Ad-noy and the reality of time and space that came into being from it, and we will take up the two modes of combination: yichuda ila'ah and yichuda tata'ah.