TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 6 · The Bittul of Created Beings, Like Sunlight Within the Body of the Sun

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous part we looked closely at the difference between the analogy of the soul and the body and the actual relationship between the Creator and the world: the soul does not bring the body into existence, whereas heaven and earth are brought into being out of absolute nothingness by the word of Hashem at every single moment. From here follows the Alter Rebbe's conclusion:

«ואם כן הם בטלים באמת במציאות לגמרי לגבי דבר ה' ורוח פיו יתברך» (and so they are truly and utterly nullified out of existence in relation to the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth): since the source that brings the world into being at every moment is itself G-dliness, the world is completely nullified and has no independent existence whatsoever. Its entire being is nothing but an expression of the Holy One, blessed be He.

The Alter Rebbe then adds a further phrase: «המיוחדים במהותו ועצמותו יתברך, כמו שיתבאר לקמן» (which are one with His very Essence and Being, as will be explained further on). That is, the bittul of the world is not merely to the «word of Hashem», but to something far higher. This is an important addition, and since the Alter Rebbe himself writes «as will be explained further on», we will not enter into it now.

This is where we stopped in the final part of chapter 6 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, folio 81a (page 161), in the last four lines on the page, up to the words «בתוך גוף כדור השמש». Let us begin with a brief review of the main points, and from there continue, with Hashem's help.

Chapter 6 closes and completes, at least at this stage, the subject we have been dealing with until now: the bittul of the world in relation to the Creator. The world is created at every moment by the divine utterances, the ten maamaros through which the world was created, which are the letters that clothe themselves within each and every creation to give it life. And although the divine power contracts itself into the framework of letters and into the framework of limited creations and a multiplicity of creations, nothing whatsoever has been added in relation to the Creator. If we were to say that until the creation of the world the Creator was alone, and now there is, as it were, something else as well, that would imply a change in the Creator. But with the Creator neither change nor multiplicity is possible, and one cannot say that the world is a reality, an entity that takes up any space in relation to Him. It is all nothing and void.

The Analogy of the Teacher and the Student:

When a teacher gives his student an analogy in order to explain a certain concept, the analogy is deliberately drawn from a subject entirely disconnected from the idea the teacher is actually speaking about, something lighter and simpler. For if the student had the intellect and the grasp to understand, the teacher would not need an analogy at all and would go straight to the idea itself. The use of an analogy stems precisely from the fact that the student is too small to understand, and therefore he is first given an analogy from some external matter, and through it he gradually draws closer to the idea.

At the stage when the student hears only the analogy and does not yet know what the lesson behind it is, the analogy conceals the idea from him absolutely. As far as he is concerned, this is a different matter entirely, foreign and external. And that is in fact the purpose of the analogy: to conceal the idea, so that only afterward will the student discover that behind the analogy a deeper concept is hiding, and that behind the story lies real depth.

And what about the teacher who gave the analogy?

For the teacher the analogy conceals nothing at all. He himself extracted the analogy out of the idea, and in every single detail of the analogy he sees the idea. The concealment exists only toward the student, so that he should not see the idea; but toward the teacher, even though he is using the analogy, there is no concealment or hiddenness here whatsoever.

From the Analogy to the Nimshal:

The entire reality of the world stands behind the concealment and hiddenness of the name Elokim, the attribute of judgment and tzimtzum (contraction), through which the Holy One, blessed be He, conceals His existence and gives created beings the sensation that they exist separately from Him, a sense of being an independent entity. But this sensation exists only on the side of the creation: the creation feels «here I am, a reality, I am separate, I exist on my own». In relation to the Creator, by contrast, no situation of a concealing, obscuring reality has been produced at all.

«For Havayah is Elokim»:

This is the meaning of the verse «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים» (Know this day and take it to your heart, that Havayah is Elokim). The two names in the verse express two opposite matters:

  • The name Havayah: being, giving and revelation, the connection to the source and to the Infinite.

  • The name Elokim: tzimtzum, concealment, and the sense of being a separate entity.

And so the verse teaches: «כי ה' הוא האלוקים» (that Havayah is Elokim), in relation to the Creator there is no difference between them at all. The name Elokim and the name Havayah are one and the same, it is all Him. The tzimtzum conceals toward the created being, but it conceals nothing toward the Creator.

«Ein Od»:

The final point we learned in chapter 6 comes to rule out a certain line of thinking: that while the world may not take up any space as a reality in relation to the Creator, nevertheless some small something has come into being here. The Alter Rebbe therefore draws our attention to the precise wording of the verse: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד» (Know this day and take it to your heart, that Havayah is Elokim in the heavens above and upon the earth below, there is nothing else).

The words «ein od», «there is nothing else», do not come to tell us that there is no other god. That is obvious, and it was already ruled out at the very beginning of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah. «Ein od» means that there is nothing at all, no reality that takes up any space, not even a reality that could be called «od», «something else». The word «od» is a term for something secondary: something small, an afterthought of no importance, but still something.

So, for example, we pay no attention to an ant because of how small it is, yet it does exist. It exists in a very small way, and one can say of it that it is «od», something else. Every small thing, even one that can barely be seen under a microscope, is still something, and the word that defines it is «od». And when the verse says «ein od», the meaning is that there is not even a reality of «od» here, but literally nothing and void.

And if the entire world is nothing and void, to whom is the verse addressed?

The question does not begin specifically with the words «upon the earth below», but with the very opening of the verse: to whom is «וידעת», «know this day», said? To whom is «והשבות אל לבבך», «take it to your heart», said? The answer lies in the concept of yichuda tataah, the «lower unity», which will be explained with Hashem's help in chapter 7: there is a reality that the Holy One, blessed be He, created and to which He gave a sense of being a separate entity, a sense of existing, and it is to that reality that He speaks. And to it He says: even though you feel yourself to be a reality and an entity, and even though you see heaven and earth and the world and all that fills it, know that all of this is only in relation to you. But in relation to the existence of the Creator, the entire world from top to bottom is «ein od», and it does not even have the status of «od».

This Is Not Like the Relationship Between Soul and Body:

Why does the world not have even the status of «od»? Because this is not comparable to the relationship between the soul and the body. The soul gives life to the body, and clearly without it the body is dead, so that the essential thing is the soul. Even so, one cannot say that without the soul the body does not exist and is nothing and void, for the body was not formed out of the soul. The body was formed from a different source, and the Holy One, blessed be He, placed a soul within it. As long as the soul enlivens it, it lives, and when the soul departs from it, it dies, but it does not become nothing and void.

The relationship between the Creator and the world, by contrast, is not like the relationship between soul and body. Here, the entire existence of the world, its whole being, its whole sense of being something, everything we could possibly imagine, is nothing more than an expression of the fact that the Creator gives us the ability to see it that way. But from His side it is all bittul, literally nothing and void.

Back to the Alter Rebbe's Words:

Since the entire existence of the world is only on account of the spirit of Hashem flowing into it and bringing it into being and sustaining it at every moment, it follows that «ואם כן הם בטלים באמת במציאות לגמרי לגבי דבר ה' ורוח פיו יתברך» (and so they are truly and utterly nullified out of existence in relation to the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth): the entire existence of the world is absolutely nullified to its source, which is the word of Hashem, the divine speech that brings it into being at every moment.

But the Alter Rebbe adds, after «the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth», the phrase «המיוחדים במהותו ועצמותו יתברך כמו שיתבאר לקמן» (which are one with His very Essence and Being, as will be explained further on). The bittul of the world is not only to the word of Hashem, which is already an aspect of the power of tzimtzum, but a far more absolute bittul: in relation to His very Essence and Being, «as will be explained».

And on this the Alter Rebbe brings his analogy: «כביטול אור השמש בשמש» (like the bittul of the light of the sun within the sun). The measure of the world's bittul is like the bittul of the sun's light within the body of the sphere of the sun itself.

What has become of the light while it is within the body of the sphere of the sun, does it exist? It certainly exists, but one cannot attribute to it any existence as a separate thing, for all that exists there is the light of the sun within its own source.

In summary: in this part we reviewed the foundation of chapter 6: the entire existence of the world, created at every moment from the ten utterances, takes up no space at all in relation to the Creator, since neither change nor multiplicity applies to Him. We learned from the analogy of the teacher and the student that the concealment exists only toward the recipient and not toward the giver, and so too the name Elokim, the tzimtzum and the concealment, conceals only toward the created being, and «Havayah is Elokim». We examined the precision of the words «ein od», that not even the description «od», something secondary and small, applies to the world, and we saw the difference between this relationship and the relationship between soul and body. Finally we came to the Alter Rebbe's words, that created beings are «בטלים באמת במציאות לגמרי לגבי דבר ה' ורוח פיו» (truly and utterly nullified out of existence in relation to the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth), which are one with His very Essence and Being, «כביטול אור השמש בשמש» (like the bittul of the light of the sun within the sun).

In the next part we will continue with the explanation of the analogy of the sun's light within the body of the sphere of the sun, and we will see why the Holy One, blessed be He, created the world in such a way that there would be within it a sense of being a separate entity and a sense of independent existence, which is the subject of yichuda tataah that will be explained in chapter 7.