TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 6 · The Name Havayah for the Soul and the Name Elokim for the Body, and the Bittul of the World

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we studied the two proofs that the word «od» means something secondary, an appendage: the phrase in the Gemara, «Yehudah ve'od lekra», and the wording of the verse, «Ahalela Hashem bechayai, azamra l'Elokai be'odi», where the body is called «od» in relation to the soul. Now we will explain why the body can be called «od», while the world cannot be called that even in relation to the Creator.

Why the body is called secondary to the soul, while the world is not called that in relation to the Creator:

The difference is fundamental; there is no comparison here at all. «לפי שהנשמה אינה מהווה הגוף מאין ליש», «because the soul does not bring the body into being from nothing». The soul does not create the body and does not generate it; the body comes from another source, and it does not depend on the soul for its very existence. «אבל הקב"ה המהווה את הכל מאין ליש - הכל בטל במציאות אצלו, כמו אור השמש בשמש», «but the Holy One, who brings everything into being from nothing, everything is nullified in its very existence before Him, like the light of the sun within the sun», exactly as in the analogy explained in chapter three. That is why the body can be called «od», whereas of the world it says «bashamayim mima'al ve'al ha'aretz mitachat ein od», in the heavens above and on the earth below there is nothing else: even the label «od» does not apply to it.

This is along the lines of our Sages' teaching, «There is no blade of grass below that does not have a mazal above that strikes it and tells it: grow». And not only regarding its growth, but regarding its very coming into being, its existence and its continued being: all it is, is the divine word that brings it into being from nothing at every single moment.

[A clarification is in order: relative to the Holy One, the soul too is brought into being from nothing, and there is no question about that. Here, however, body and soul are being used only as an analogy. True, in many places this analogy is used to understand how the Creator conducts the world, as our Sages say on «Barchi nafshi»: «Just as the soul fills the body, so the Holy One fills the world». But that is a narrow analogy for one particular point, and it does not express the full relationship.]

«ולכן הוצרך הכתוב להזהיר», «and therefore Scripture had to warn». The Torah warns: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך וגו'», «and you shall know this day and take it to your heart». The Torah uses here a doubled, emphatic language of warning, to teach that a person must constantly guard himself from erring and becoming confused on this point.

«שלא תעלה על דעתך ששמים וכל צבאם והארץ ומלואה הם דבר נפרד בפני עצמו והקב"ה ממלא כל עלמין כהתלבשות הנשמה בגוף», «that it should not enter your mind that the heavens and all their hosts and the earth and all it contains are a separate entity in their own right, and that the Holy One fills all worlds the way the soul is clothed in the body». One must not imagine that the world is a separate reality to which the Creator granted independent standing. Even someone who knows with certainty that the Holy One created it may still think that after creation the world was given an existence of its own, dependent on the Creator yet separate from Him. That is not so, for then it would have a reality of its own.

And likewise one must not imagine that He merely «משפיע כח הצומח בארץ וכח התנועה בגלגלים ומניעם ומנהיגם כרצונו, כמו שהנשמה מניעה את הגוף ומנהיגתו כרצונה», «grants the power of growth to the earth and the power of motion to the spheres, moving them and directing them as He wills, just as the soul moves the body and directs it as it wills». The two examples correspond to «in the heavens above and on the earth below»: the earth, which has the power of growth, and the spheres, the galaxies, the stars, the sun and the moon, which have the power of motion. Even though it is clear that these forces come from the Creator, there is still room to err and think that the spheres and the earth have some reality of their own.

«Just as the soul moves the body and directs it as it wills»:

What is the word «as it wills» coming to emphasize? It can be illustrated with the analogy of an engine and a car. The engine supplies energy to the wheels and they turn, but it has no say in what their motion will be; the wheels move according to their fixed design, and the engine only gives them power. The soul's relationship to the body is higher than that: the soul moves the body as it wills, and the body has no input of its own, like a lifeless form dragged along after it.

So the body's level of bittul to the soul is high, and nevertheless it is not absolute bittul: at the end of the day the body was not created out of the soul, and it is a reality separate from it. The world's relationship to the Creator, by contrast, is incomparably higher.

«Atah Hu ad shelo nivra ha'olam», You are He before the world was created:

All of this rests on the foundations explained in chapters one, two and three: the Holy One created, He continues to create at every moment, and the created being never actually left Him, like the sunlight within the sun. And since these three stages are always in force, no separate reality was ever formed here. And the fact that reality experiences itself as standing on its own is the wonder of wonders: it is the power of the Holy One, «mafli la'asot», who works wonders, granting the created being a sense of independence, and this is the name Elokim.

True, there was a starting point to creation, and the bringing into being has continued from then on at every single moment. But there is no room for the question «what was before that»: the concept of time itself was created at that moment, and so was the concept of space and the entire capacity for grasping and thinking. There is no way to take the concept of time as we know it in this world and transplant it to before creation; before that there was «Hu ushmo bilvad», He and His Name alone, the reality of the Creator alone.

And here is the main point: the intention is not that He was alone only then, but that even now that is how it is. This is «ve'yadata hayom», and you shall know today: the world is not even stage scenery in relation to Him. As we say in the daily prayers, «You are He before the world was created, You are He since the world was created»: nothing changed. Precisely for this reason Scripture uses the expressions «ve'yadata» and «vahasheivota el levavecha», you shall know and take it to your heart: a person has to bring this into his mind and his heart again and again, because the moment one slips from it even briefly, the claim immediately returns: but there is a reality here, there is a world!

Let us review what we learned in chapter five: the existence of the world as we experience it is not an illusion, but a true reality. The Holy One created a genuine sense of reality for us, and nevertheless He is not affected by it in the least. His very Essence is exalted above the whole matter, and at the same time He created a reality in which we have this sense. And were it merely an illusory reality, there would be no room for commands, demands and mitzvos.

And this is the great chiddush: that very same Creator, who is utterly abstracted from everything and exalted above the whole matter, to that very same degree does not become constricted, and invests His entire Self into the small «compartments», down to the pair of tefillin sitting in the cabinet. We have no capacity to grasp how one and the same Being is entirely beyond and entirely within, and this is the wonder of wonders that we must keep in mind.

«אך באמת אין המשל דומה לנמשל כלל», But in truth the analogy does not resemble what it illustrates at all:

The Alter Rebbe says: «אך באמת אין המשל דומה לנמשל כלל», «but in truth the analogy does not resemble what it comes to illustrate at all». The analogy of soul and body bears no resemblance to the relationship between Creator and created, «כי הנשמה והגוף הם באמת נפרדים זה מזה בשרשם», «for the soul and the body are in truth separate from one another in their root»: two different things that the Holy One matched together, and even at their root they are distinct.

«כי אין התהוות שורש הגוף ועצמותו מנשמתו אלא מטיפות אביו ואמו», «for the root and substance of the body do not come into being from the soul, but from the drops of his father and mother». The body's beginning is not from the soul at all. «וגם אחרי כן אין גידולו מנשמתו לבדה, אלא על ידי אכילת ושתיית אמו כל תשעה חדשים, ואחר כך על ידי אכילתו ושתייתו בעצמו», «and afterwards too its growth does not come from the soul alone, but through the mother's eating and drinking for all nine months, and later through his own eating and drinking». Even during the nine months of pregnancy, when the fetus already has a soul (as the Gemara describes, that it learns Torah there), its growth and development come from the mother's nourishment; and so too afterwards, a person's life does indeed depend on the soul, but also on eating, drinking and sleeping. It turns out that the soul is only a partner, and it cannot claim absolute ownership and tell the body that it is nothing but a complete nonentity, for the body is a reality, even if it is small compared to the soul.

«מה שאין כן השמים והארץ שכל עצמותם ומהותם נתהווה מאין ואפס המוחלט רק בדבר ה' ורוח פיו יתברך», «which is not the case with the heavens and the earth, whose entire substance and essence came into being from absolute nothingness solely through the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth». The world has no separate source of its own, and it cannot claim that the Creator merely enlivened it after it already existed. And more than that: «וגם עדיין נצב דבר ה' לעולם ושופע בהם תמיד בכל רגע ומהווה אותם תמיד מאין ליש», «and moreover the word of Hashem still stands forever and flows into them constantly, at every moment, bringing them into being always from nothing». Not only at the starting point, but at every single moment, «כהתהוות האור מהשמש בתוך גוף כדור השמש עצמו, דרך משל», «like the light that comes into being from the sun within the body of the sun itself, by way of analogy»: at the highest level, where the created being never left its source.

And all of this hinges on «Havayah Hu haElokim», Hashem is Elokim. If the name Havayah were one force and the name Elokim another, there would be room to say that the Holy One created a world and then placed within it a power of concealment and hiddenness, forming a separate reality. But since «Havayah Hu haElokim», the concealment itself is nothing but Him, like the analogy a teacher gives a student, where the analogy does not hide the teacher from himself, for he sees in it the idea itself. Therefore the reality that came into being, even though it experiences itself as disconnected, is not truly disconnected but is nullified to Him, and this is «ein od», there is nothing else.

To summarize: in this section we clarified the difference between the analogy of soul and body and the relationship between the Creator and the world. The soul does not bring the body into being, and therefore, even though the body is nullified to the soul and directed as the soul wills, its bittul is not absolute. The heavens and the earth, however, have their entire substance and essence brought into being from absolute nothingness by the word of Hashem at every single moment, and therefore even the label «od» does not apply to them: «ein od». Hence the warning of the verse, «ve'yadata hayom vahasheivota el levavecha», that a person must fix this knowledge in his mind and in his heart again and again.

In the next section we will learn the conclusion of all this: «and if so, they are truly and utterly nullified in their very existence relative to the word of Hashem and the breath of His mouth».