In this section we will do a general review of the chapters of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah as they unfold, because what we are about to learn touches directly on the very points with which the Alter Rebbe opened in chapter 1.
A review of the flow of the chapters:
Chapter 1 opens with the verse: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד», «Know this day and take it to your heart that Havayah is G-d in the heavens above and on the earth below, there is nothing else.» At first glance, one reads the verse simply as announcing that there is one G-d and no other god besides Him. On this the Alter Rebbe asked: to say something like that there is no need for the lengthy expression «וידעת... והשבות אל לבבך», «know... and take it to your heart», a phrasing that indicates a matter which is hard to accept and which demands great effort to grasp. Rather, the intent of «אין עוד», «there is nothing else», is not that there is no other god, but that there is no other existence at all: everything is null and void.
In order to lead us to this understanding, the Alter Rebbe first explained at length that every existing thing exists only by the power of the letters of G-d's speech, which create the creations and give them life at every single moment. This was not only during the six days of creation; the act of bringing into being continues constantly, and in every last detail. And since the creation's entire existence is nothing but the result of the divine word that brings it into being at every moment, it has no independent existence whatsoever, and it stands in complete bittul to the Holy One, blessed be He.
In chapter 3 we learned what this measure of bittul truly is: like the bittul of sunlight within the body of the sun itself. There the nullification is absolute, to the point that one cannot even call it «light» at all. That name applies to it only once it is outside the sun; while it is inside, it is utterly nullified. So too the world is nullified to its Creator.
At the end of chapter 3 the question was raised: if in truth the world is nullified, why does it not look that way to our eyes? We do not see the bittul of the sun's light within the sun, and we do not even see the bittul of the sunlight that is outside the sun, for the light that emerges from the sun is also nullified to its source, and anyone understands on his own that light depends on the luminary. With the world the situation is reversed: it presents itself as an independent entity, entirely cut off from its source, and in order to know the truth one has to learn it from a book. It does not emerge from looking at the world on its own terms.
By contrast, when a person looks at sunlight, nobody has to warn him not to be mistaken, to inform him that there is a sun from which this light and radiance come. It is obvious and clear to him. If someone were to tell him that the sun set several hours ago and that the light visible here is light that remained from it and was stored away (like the Chelm sages who covered the barrel in which they had saved the moon for Kiddush Levanah), it would sound like nonsense. That is how our view of the world ought to be as well: clear and obvious that it is being given life every day and every moment by the power of its source.
The reason it is not so is the name Elokim. Just as the sun has a «shield» that covers it, so in the analogue there are the name Havayah and the name Elokim:
The name Havayah brings the creation into being and gives it life, creating it yesh me'ayin, something from nothing.
The name Elokim gives the creation, which in truth is null and void and absolutely nullified to its source, a sense of independence and a sense of being disconnected from the source, as though it depended on nothing.
The purpose of all this is that there should be a creation that exists, whose avodah will be to reveal the truth within the world. Without this concealment and hiddenness, no world would have been created at all, and such a reality would be impossible.
This is what we learned in the previous section, at the beginning of chapter 6: the very existence of the name Elokim is itself an act of chesed. First, its purpose is chesed, for without the tzimtzum, the concealment and the sense of being a yesh, the world would be nullified and would not exist; it is out of G-d's kindness, since He desired that there be a world, that He granted the creations their sense of self-existence. And more than that: this is gevurah that is included within chesed, a complete merging of the two attributes. The divine light called chesed (the name Havayah) brings the creation into being, and the divine light called gevurah (the name Elokim) gives it its sense of being a yesh, and although they are literally opposites, they work together, with the gevurah included within the chesed.
«והנה מהתכללות המידות זו בזו»:
«והנה מהתכללות המידות זו בזו נראה לעין דאיהו וגרמוהי חד», «And behold, from the inclusion of the attributes within one another it is plainly seen that He and His 'instruments' are one.» From what we have learned, that the divine middos are included one within the other, meaning that chesed and gevurah operate in constant partnership: revelation and concealment go together, and the concealment serves the revelation and assists its function. The revelation comes to create a world, and the concealment grants it the capacity to be, for precisely by giving the creation a sense of its own reality the world is able to exist. From this mutual inclusion one sees tangibly that «איהו וגרמוהי חד», He and His middos («גרמוהי» in Aramaic means His attributes and vessels) are one.
«כי מאחר שהן בייחוד גמור עמו לכן הן מתייחדות זו בזו וכלולות זו מזו», «since they are in complete union with Him, therefore they unite with one another and are included one within the other.» The ability of the divine middos to be included within one another stems from the fact that they are united with His very Essence. As Eliyahu said: «אנת הוא דקשיר לון ומייחד לון... ובר מינך לית יחודא בעילאי», «You are the One who binds them and unites them... and apart from You there is no union above.» You are the One who connects and joins the opposing middos, and without You there is no possibility of uniting them at all.
But surely we find an inclusion of middos within a created being as well, so what is so remarkable here?
As was mentioned in the previous section, even in a creation there is such a thing as gevurah within chesed, or chesed within gevurah. A father who strikes his son is performing an act of gevurah, but what drives it is chesed and his love for his son, so this is gevurah that is included within chesed and serves it. If so, what is novel about the inclusion of the middos Above, such that from it one proves that «איהו וגרמוהי חד»?
The difference between the inclusion in creations and the inclusion Above:
In a created being, the inclusion of opposing middos is possible only because one of them has been weakened and is not standing in its full force. In the father who strikes his son there is no gevurah at full strength: the gevurah has been diluted, and in that low dosage it serves the chesed and goes along with it. Among creations, inclusion comes about through weakness.
Another example: government ministers whose roles and interests conflict. As long as each sits in his own office, they fight one another, each pulling the budget in his direction, unwilling to give up a penny. But when they come before the king, the king manages to make peace between them and find a formula they all accept. It is not that they have stopped being opposed; rather, before the king each one of them is nullified and is not standing in his full force, and therefore it is no great difficulty to bring them together. And once their force returns to them when they leave the king's presence, they go right back to clashing with each other.
The novelty Above is that the chesed is present in its full force and the gevurah is present in its full force, simultaneously. The proof is simple: on the one hand the world is in absolute concealment and hiddenness from Elokus, gevurah in all its force, hiding entirely the source that brings it into being, to the point that the creation thinks it is disconnected; and on the other hand the world exists yesh me'ayin by the power of the divine chesed that brings it into being at every single moment, chesed in all its force. Both middos are at full strength, and they operate together and are interwoven with one another. This is possible only because they are «בייחוד גמור עמו, ולכן הן מתייחדות זו בזו וכלולות זו מזו», «in complete union with Him, and therefore they unite with one another and are included one within the other.»
«וזהו שכתוב וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך»:
Here the Alter Rebbe returns to the verse with which he opened Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, and the verse has two halves:
«וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים», «Know this day and take it to your heart that Havayah is Elokim.» There is the name Havayah, whose theme is chesed, and there is the name Elokim, whose theme is gevurah. Do not think these are two opposing powers; rather, «ה' הוא האלוקים», everything is united with Him and everything works as one.
«בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד», «in the heavens above and on the earth below there is nothing else», that there is no other existence at all.
What is the connection between the first half of the verse and the second, that they are said in a single breath? On the face of it these are two separate matters, and they should have been stated as two separate verses.
Let us preface a question: the role of the name Elokim is to conceal and contract, but upon whom does it contract and conceal? Upon us. And why should we not say that the concealment applies to the Holy One, blessed be He, as well: that He created a world, and then acted through the name Elokim so that the world would be disconnected, and consequently the disconnection exists even in relation to Him?
To this the verse comes and says: do not think for a moment that because the world is a forceful reality to you, it is a forceful reality to the Creator as well. In relation to the Creator everything is null and void, «כי ה' הוא האלוקים», and precisely because all the middos are united with Him, therefore «בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד».
The analogy of the teacher and the student:
A teacher is teaching his student and estimates that the student cannot grasp the idea itself because it is too deep, so he begins with a parable. While the student is hearing the parable, he still does not know where it is leading, since all he has heard is a parable, and the parable is meant to bring him eventually to an understanding of the lesson it carries. At this stage the parable conceals the deep idea, and necessarily so: if it did not conceal, the student would not be able to understand, and if the teacher were to approach the deep idea directly, the student would not grasp it at all. The teacher has no choice but to begin with a parable, and the parable conceals.
But upon whom does the parable conceal? Upon the student. And does the parable also conceal the inner idea from the teacher himself, at the very moment he is telling it?
In summary: in this section we reviewed the flow of the chapters of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah: the verse «וידעת היום» and the meaning of «אין עוד» as the negation of any other existence; the continuous creation of all beings at every moment from the letters of G-d's speech, and their bittul, like the sun's light within the sun; and the role of the name Elokim, to conceal and to grant the creation a sense of being a yesh, which is itself chesed, and gevurah that is included within chesed. We learned that «מהתכללות המידות זו בזו נראה לעין דאיהו וגרמוהי חד», and we clarified the difference between the inclusion found in creations, which comes about through the weakening of one of the middos, and the inclusion Above, in which each middah stands in its full force. We also explained the connection between the two halves of the verse: the concealment of the name Elokim is only in relation to the creation, while in relation to the Creator «אין עוד». And we began the analogy of the teacher and the student, in which the parable conceals the idea it carries.
In the next section we will complete the explanation of the analogy, upon whom the parable conceals and upon whom it does not, and we will see the lesson it teaches about the concealment of the name Elokim.