TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 6 · The Interinclusion of the Middos and the Answer to the Question That Opened Shaar HaYichud

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we dealt with the meaning of the name Elokim, the tzimtzum and the concealment, and with the fact that it is not a force opposing the name Havayah but is included together with it. Now the Alter Rebbe shows how the very interinclusion of the middos one within the other is open proof that «ihu vegarmohi chad» (He and His instruments are one), and from there he returns to answer the question with which Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah opened.

The interinclusion of the middos: proof that «ihu vegarmohi chad»

The Alter Rebbe's words: «והנה מהתכללות המידות זו בזו נראה לעין דאיהו וגרמוהי חד», «And behold, from the interinclusion of the middos one within the other it is plainly seen that He and His instruments are one.» The very fact that chesed and gevurah are included within each other is a striking novelty, for they are two opposites, fire and water. How can it be that chesed acts as chesed and gevurah acts as gevurah, and at the same time they complete one another and work in harmony? From this we have tangible proof that «ihu vegarmohi chad», the Creator and His middos and His kelim are one. The chesed is He, and the gevurah is He, and therefore there is no contradiction between them whatsoever, for the Essence does not contradict the Essence.

A parable: a king appointed one minister over water and another minister over fire. As long as they are two separate ministers, conflict is liable to break out between them. When do they become united? When they stand before the king, as in the phrase «oseh shalom bimromav» (He makes peace in His heights). But that unity comes about only because each of them is weakened as he stands before the king and is not at his full strength; once each returns to his own office and operates at full force, they go back to quarreling and neither yields an inch to the other, this one pulling here and that one pulling there. In our world, the only way to combine opposites is to weaken this one a little and that one a little, and only then can they be joined.

With the Holy One, by contrast, the joining does not come from weakening the chesed and weakening the gevurah. From the outset everything is He: the chesed is He and the gevurah is He, and therefore there is no obstacle at all to the combining of opposites.

Along the same line of thought: in this chapter we are speaking of the gevurah within chesed, but the same applies to «chesed shebigevurah», chesed within gevurah. The very fact that one can say «chesed within gevurah» means that opposites are being combined here: the gevurah does its work with full force, because it has a task assigned to it, and the chesed assists it; and in gevurah within chesed it is the reverse, the chesed acts and the gevurah assists it. Each case according to its own context, but the principle is one: every middah does its work at full strength and does not contradict its fellow.

And all this is because of the interinclusion of the middos within Elokus: since the middos are in complete union with Him, the chesed being the Creator's chesed and the gevurah His gevurah, therefore they unite with one another and are included one in the other.

Combining opposites: only from the side of kedushah

From here the matter descends below as well: a combination of opposites is possible only in kedushah. In kedushah two things that are opposites can dwell under one roof and act together. In kelipah, by contrast, everything is separate, each one wants to rule and is in no way willing to yield to his fellow, and from there come baseless hatred, the inability to be happy for another, and the like. From the side of kedushah it is the opposite: if your fellow is succeeding, help him succeed even more, for no man touches what is prepared for his fellow, and opposites can dwell together. Such a feeling comes only from the side of kedushah, whose source is the Holy One, with whom the middos are in interinclusion; and when a Jew is close to kedushah, this works within his soul an interinclusion even with a person who is his complete opposite.

«וכמאמר אליהו: אנת הוא דקשיר לון ומייחד לון», as Eliyahu said: «You are He who binds them and unites them», You are the one who binds and unites them, chesed and gevurah, «ובר מינך לית יחודא בעילאי כו'», «and apart from You there is no unity above», without You there is no unity at all. The oneness that exists between opposites comes solely from the side of the Holy One.

With this we have completed the explanation of the name Elokim and its role, and why it does not conceal absolutely throughout the entire order of hishtalshelus: since it is included together with chesed, the two go together and are intertwined, and wherever the word Elokim appears, the intent is the name Elokim as it is blended with chesed.

The answer to the question with which Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah opened

Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah opens with the verse: «And you shall know this day and take it to your heart that Havayah is Elokim in the heavens above and upon the earth below, there is nothing else.» And there, in chapter one, the question was raised: when we come to tell a Jew that there are not two gods but only one God, does that really require such protracted avodah? It can be explained simply, and the Rambam writes it in three or four lines at the beginning of Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah, with a straightforward logical argument that if there is a God, He must necessarily be one and not two. Yet from the wording of the verse, «and you shall know» and also «and take it to your heart», it is implied that this is not grasped simply and that one must labor hard over it. Why?

Now it is understood: the intent is not to implant in the mind that there is no second god, that can be achieved easily. The intent is to implant in the mind that there is no other existence at all: there is no separate reality, and everything is He; every single thing a person sees is nothing but an expression of the Holy One. This is not something a person's consciousness absorbs automatically, and in fact the opposite: naturally a person looks and says that the existence of a world is obvious, while God is something one has to search for and find. And here we come and tell him the reverse: there is only God, and there is no reality of a world separate from Him at all. Such a recognition has to be driven into the head with a great deal of thought and toil.

And where is this hinted at in the verse? «כי ה' הוא האלוקים», «for Havayah is Elokim.» What is this doubled expression? The name Elokim means tzimtzum, darkness, a separate world; and the verse comes and says: do not think that this separate world is a separate reality, rather «Havayah is Elokim», the name Havayah, which is chesed, is itself the name Elokim. In order that His influence be able to endure and stand, He partnered the name Elokim with it, but this is not a reality separate from Him. This is the joining of the name Havayah with the name Elokim.

In the Alter Rebbe's words: «וזהו והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלקים, פירוש ששני שמות אלו הם אחד ממש», «And this is the meaning of 'and take it to your heart that Havayah is Elokim', that is, that these two names are literally one»: these two names, which seemingly contradict each other since each indicates the opposite matter, are literally one. «שגם שם אלקים המצמצם ומעלים האור, הוא בחינת חסד - כמו שם הוי"ה», «that even the name Elokim, which constricts and conceals the light, is an aspect of chesed, just like the name Havayah»: although it seemingly comes to constrict, to conceal, to hide and to darken, it is not another force, a separate force or an opposing force, but that very same Divine chesed as the name Havayah. Out of the abundance of His kindness toward us, He partnered the name Elokim with His chesed so that we would be able to receive.

For had He given the full chesed at its full intensity, there would be no world at all, everything would be He. And He wanted there to be a reality of an order of hishtalshelus of worlds, in which one begins to feel self-existence and distance, for the sake of the purpose contained in creation. It emerges that the sense of distance and concealment, which goes in stages and becomes denser and denser, is entirely a Divine chesed expressing itself in this form.

It is only that a person does not always identify this as chesed; at times he looks and sees total darkness, and does not understand where the chesed is. Were it evident and recognizable, there would be no need to say «and you shall know this day and take it to your heart». Knowledge alone is not enough, one must bring the matter back down into the heart, and that is avodah and toil: to exert oneself and arrive at «Havayah is Elokim», that this very tzimtzum is chesed just like the name Havayah.

And the reason for this: «משום שמידותיו של הקב"ה מתייחדות עמו בייחוד גמור, והוא ושמו אחד, שמידותיו הן שמותיו», «because the middos of the Holy One are united with Him in complete union, and He and His name are one, for His middos are His names»: His middah of gevurah is He, and His middah of chesed is He, and they are always partners together; and «He and His name are one» means that His middos are His names. Sometimes we see only the side of chesed, and sometimes only the side of gevurah, or the gevurah more than the chesed, or we do not see the chesed at all but only concealment and hiddenness, yet all of it is He, and all of it is chesed.

A parable: a son looking at his father while the father deals with him in a manner of gevurah, and at that moment he does not understand what this severity is about; when he grows a little older, he will thank him for all of it. So too we are destined to say to the Holy One «I thank You, Havayah, for You were angry with me», and to understand that all of this concealment was one part of His kindness.

[And from here we can also understand the sayings of Chazal about the Holy One moving from the throne of judgment to the throne of mercy: every statement of Chazal must be studied on its own terms, and one must understand that the words are said in a pictorial way so that we can grasp a direction, and that the intent is obviously and simply not something physical. According to what we learned in the previous chapter, the world must pass through the din of the name Elokim, for otherwise there would be no world at all; it follows that every single moment that the world exists in its present form is din, and the world's continued existence in its regular order and nature is the middah of din. And from time to time the Holy One reveals beyond that and gives gifts, and that is the middah of rachamim being revealed.]

And even if a person were to receive a little beyond his measure, he would say: enough, leave me be. Like the story of Choni HaMe'agel, when the rains came down with too much force and he said: this is not what I asked for, for the world cannot bear an excess of goodness. Therefore what we receive comes in a constricted way, and that very tzimtzum is chesed, gevurah within chesed.

«In the heavens above and upon the earth below»

Where is it that «Havayah is Elokim»? The verse continues: «in the heavens above and upon the earth below». In the upper worlds it is easier to understand that the tzimtzum is part of the chesed, since there one sees revelation, and one understands that the revelation is measured, and the measuring is the gevurah. But when one reaches «the earth below», the darkness and concealment down here, it is far harder to absorb that this darkness is chesed, for not a grain of chesed is visible here to take hold of, only darkness. Therefore the avodah here is far harder.

And this is what the Alter Rebbe continues: «ואם כן, ממילא תדע שבשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד», «And if so, you will automatically know that in the heavens above and upon the earth below there is nothing else.»

Let us pause here on this point: this is an avodah that is not simple at all, a very great avodah, complete bittul to the point of recognizing that «there is nothing else besides Him».

To summarize: in this section we learned that the very interinclusion of the middos one within the other is open proof that «ihu vegarmohi chad»: in our world a combination of opposites is possible only by weakening each of them, as in the parable of the ministers standing before the king, whereas above, the chesed is He and the gevurah is He, and the Essence does not contradict the Essence. From here it follows that the interinclusion of opposites exists only on the side of kedushah, while in kelipah everything is separate, as Eliyahu said, «You are He who binds them and unites them, and apart from You there is no unity.» With this, the question that opened Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah is resolved: «and you shall know... and take it to your heart» is not directed at knowing that there is no second god, but at implanting the recognition that there is no separate reality at all, and that even the name Elokim, which constricts and conceals, is that very same Divine chesed as the name Havayah, and this is harder to absorb «upon the earth below» than «in the heavens above».

In the next section we will deal with the Alter Rebbe's explanation of each of the expressions in the verse, «in the heavens above», «upon the earth below» and «there is nothing else», where every single word will receive its own explanation.