TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 4 · The Name Elokim: The Power That Conceals and Creates a Sense of Independent Existence

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we examined the attribute of gedulah: bringing into being yesh me'ayin, something from nothing, which is the praise of the Holy One alone and lies beyond the understanding and comprehension of every created being. Now we turn to the second attribute, gevurah.

The second attribute: «hagibor», the Mighty One

Everything said until now has only been an introduction. After we have marveled at how utterly incapable we are of grasping the attribute of gedulah, the Alter Rebbe tells us something new: to precisely the same degree, we are incapable of grasping the second attribute, gevurah, which is the power of tzimtzum, of concealment and hiddenness.

And the novelty lies specifically in this order. For had he told us first that gevurah cannot be grasped, it would have been self-evident that what is higher than it certainly cannot be grasped. After all, of these two powers, which one has any parallel in our world? The power of bringing something into being from nothing is entirely beyond us and has no analogue whatsoever; whereas the power to constrict, to conceal and to regulate, that we do have.

Logic would therefore dictate that of gedulah we have no conception at all, while of gevurah we have some conception of the concept itself, not at the intensity in which it exists Above, but the concept itself is familiar to us.

To sharpen the point: everyone understands that building a dam against flowing water is possible. With a small flow a person can do it himself; with a larger flow he will need tractors and blocks set in place quickly. But to stop the ocean, that we cannot do, and we cannot even picture how it would be done. Even so, the very idea of stopping a flow we understand perfectly well; the gap in our comprehension is only a matter of quantity.

With creation yesh me'ayin, by contrast, we do not have even a crumb of an analogue. We take a seed and bury it in the ground, and have we thereby made something from nothing? It is the divine power that is at work there, and we have no part in it whatsoever; we could not create so much as the wing of a mosquito. With gevurah, however, it would seem that we do possess that crumb, as in the analogy of the dam. Why then do we say that we have no grasp of the Holy One's attribute of gevurah?

Here the Alter Rebbe clarifies a fundamental point: the gevurah being spoken of here is not gevurah in the sense we imagine, a curtain, a regulating, a constricting, where we do have some conception and grasp. This is an entirely different kind of gevurah: a gevurah that creates a new reality.

Once the attribute of gedulah has created a yesh out of ayin, the power of «hagibor» comes and instills in that very yesh the sense that it exists in its own right and depends on nothing. This is not merely a dimming of the intensity of the light; it is the granting of a feeling of total disconnection from the source, and that in itself is incomprehensible, since the creature's entire existence depends on nothing but its source.

It is as if one were to say: let us take the light of the sun as it is within the sun itself, prevent its intensity from being revealed, and leave the illumination with the sensation that it exists all on its own. No such ability exists, for these are two opposites. (In the folk tales of the wise men of Chelm they trapped the light in a barrel and were left holding the barrel, but in reality there is no such thing.) Accordingly, with this sort of gevurah it is not that we are merely missing information about its intensity; we have no capacity at all to understand how such a state of affairs comes about.

The Alter Rebbe's words:

«וכמו שאין ביכולת שום שכל נברא להשיג מהות מידת גדולתו, שהיא היכולת לברוא יש מאין ולהחיותו, דכתיב עולם חסד יבנה» - «Just as no created intellect has the capacity to grasp the essence of His attribute of gedulah, which is the ability to create something from nothing and to give it life, as it is written: the world is built through chesed» - the world is built and sustained by the attribute of chesed, and it is chesed that creates and brings the creature into being at every single moment. Of this bringing-into-being we have no understanding, no grasp and no absorption at all; it is written that this is so, but the essence of the matter is not grasped.

«כך ממש אין ביכולתו להשיג מידת גבורתו של הקב״ה» - «so too, precisely, he has no capacity to grasp the Holy One's attribute of gevurah.» Exactly to the same degree. Just as «hagadol» is the praise of the Holy One, so «hagibor» is the praise of the Holy One, and to precisely the same degree no created being can grasp the essence of His attribute of gevurah. For the power of gevurah is not merely to conceal the intensity; were it only concealing, the result would be that the creature too would not be seen at all. Rather, here a situation is produced in which, on the one hand, there is concealment, and at the same time the creature exists and feels that it is in no way dependent on the source that is dwelling within it at that very moment. Such an absurd state of affairs can be produced only by an infinite power, and that is what is called gevurah.

And so we find in the Gemara: foxes dance in His Sanctuary and He is silent. The Beis Hamikdash is destroyed, foxes stroll through the Holy of Holies, such a disgrace, and the Holy One is silent. And so with countless other situations in which holiness is desecrated. Says the Gemara: «elu hein gevurosav», these are His mighty acts. This is His gevurah: that He has the power to allow a reality that thinks it does whatever it pleases, as though there were no one watching, observing and examining its deeds. That is the power of gevurah: the power to be present, and to give the creature the sensation that He is not present.

What the attribute of tzimtzum is:

«שהיא מידת הצמצום ומניעת התפשטות החיות מגדולתו, מלירד ולהתגלות על הנבראים, להחיותם ולקיימם בגילוי» - «which is the attribute of tzimtzum, holding back the spread of the life-force from His gedulah, preventing it from descending and being revealed upon the creatures, to enliven and sustain them in a revealed way.» It holds back the unlimited intensity of the divine gedulah from descending and being revealed upon the creatures. For if it did descend and reveal itself as the attribute of gedulah would demand, the creature would forever be immersed in its source and in bittul toward it. Certainly the Holy One continues to enliven and sustain them, for otherwise they would not exist at all, but this is not in a revealed way, «כי אם בהסתר פנים, שהחיות מסתתר בגוף הנברא», «but rather with a hiding of the face, for the life-force hides itself within the body of the creature.»

«וכאילו גוף הנברא הוא דבר בפני עצמו, ואינו התפשטות החיות והרוחניות כהתפשטות הזיו והאור מהשמש, אלא הוא דבר בפני עצמו» - «and it is as though the body of the creature were a thing in its own right, and not a spreading forth of the life-force and spirituality the way the radiance and light spread forth from the sun, but rather a thing unto itself.» A situation is produced in which the creature feels that it is in no way dependent on the sun. And more than that: it does not feel itself to be like the radiance within the sun, nor even like the radiance outside the sun, but as something entirely independent. This absurdity is precisely the power of gevurah.

«ואף שבאמת אינו דבר בפני עצמו, אלא כמו התפשטות האור מהשמש» - «and although in truth it is not a thing in its own right, but is like the spreading forth of the light from the sun.» That is the truth as it stands from the side of gedulah and chesed. But facing it stands the truth of gevurah, which is no less a divine truth. Heaven forbid that we should think gevurah is some foreign force doing battle with the divine power that seeks to be revealed. The Holy One Himself has His truth as He is from the side of «hagadol», and His truth as He is from the side of «hagibor». In the language of chassidus this is called daas elyon and daas tachton, for «Kel deyos Hashem», deyos in the plural, two modes of knowing.

A question: what does a mitzvah actually accomplish?

This way of looking at things answers a very powerful question. Why are we asked to perform mitzvos? We take the hide of an animal and turn it into tefillin. Beforehand it was a hide lying in the tanner's workshop with no holiness at all, and once a mitzvah was performed with it, it became holy, meaning that godliness now rests within it in a revealed way (not revealed to us, for we are in galus and do not see it, but in fact something has changed). The same is true of food over which a bracha is recited, and so on.

And a Jew may ask: not as it appears from our vantage point, but from the standpoint of divine truth, is there any difference between before the mitzvah and after it? From the standpoint of the infinite intensity that is present in every place and at every moment, and from the standpoint of the power that brings every thing into being from ayin to yesh and is literally within it, He is not present less before the mitzvah and more afterward; He is present in exactly the same measure. If so, what did the mitzvah accomplish? Is it nothing more than a game played with the creatures, a sleight of hand, chas veshalom, or is it something real, that beforehand there was concealment here and now there is revelation?

Here is the heart of the answer: the concealment itself is real, because the One doing the concealing is the Holy One Himself. He says, as it were: now I am concealing, and My will is that through your avodah you break through that concealment. The Jew's mitzvah breaks through a real concealment that the Holy One created with His infinite power. It is not a curtain that merely conceals and regulates toward the outside; it is a reality that was brought into being.

The same applies in the analogy of the sun and the shield. The light of the sun without the shield is problematic not only because of its intensity, but because it is a light that cannot illuminate for creatures and serve them at all, since its whole character is to illuminate itself and not to give light to its surroundings. The light we benefit from, which lights up the world and allows us to see, is a different kind of light altogether. Who produces the change between the light as it is at the sun and the light as it reaches us? The shield. It turns out, then, that the shield did not merely regulate; it created a state of a different light. So it is with the name Elokim and with divine gevurah: this is not mere filtering, and it is not an imaginary concealment.

For if the concealment were nothing more than a curtain, consider: the one who hangs the curtain is inside and enjoys the light, and the curtain exists only for those outside. By that reckoning we would say that from the creatures' perspective it seems there is concealment, but in truth nothing has changed at all. Against this the Alter Rebbe comes and stresses at length: the Holy One Himself created two truths, the truth as He reveals Himself through chesed and the truth as He reveals Himself through gevurah. And both are truth.

In his words: «מכל מקום אלו הן גבורותיו של הקב״ה, אשר כל יכול לצמצם החיות והרוחניות הנשפע מרוח פיו ולהסתירו, שלא יבטל גוף הנברא במציאות, וזה אין ביכולת שכל שום נברא להשיג מהות הצמצום וההסתר, ושיהיה אף על פי כן גוף הנברא נברא מאין ליש, כמו שאין יכולת בשכל שום נברא להשיג מהות הבריאה מאין ליש», «In any event, these are the mighty acts of the Holy One, who is able to constrict the life-force and spirituality that flows from the breath of His mouth and to conceal it, so that the body of the creature will not be nullified out of existence; and no created intellect has the capacity to grasp the essence of this tzimtzum and concealment, and that nonetheless the body of the creature is created from nothing into something, just as no created intellect has the capacity to grasp the essence of creation from nothing into something.» The point is not that the creature does not know what tzimtzum is, tzimtzum he understands, but that he cannot grasp this kind of tzimtzum: that on the one hand there is constriction and concealment, and at the same time the body of the creature is literally being created from ayin to yesh at this very moment, with the ayin present inside it, and yet the yesh feels «ani ve'afsi od», I am, and there is nothing besides me. Precisely as the essence of creation is not grasped, so the essence of the concealment is not grasped.

At this point we have the answer to the question raised in chapter three: how can it be that the source is not seen, and yet the creature is not nullified, when with a candle before a torch, once you remove the torch, you no longer see the candle either? Indeed, if creation contained only the attribute of chesed, the argument would be correct: whoever does not see the source would not see the result either. But we have been shown that an additional divine power participates in creation, as in the statement «שיתף עמו מידת הדין», «He joined the attribute of din together with it»: the name Havayah and the name Elokim are partners in creation. The existence of every creature as we see it now is the result of both names together: the name Havayah brings it into being and enlivens it, and the name Elokim produces within it the sensation of «ani ve'afsi od».

The reality that has been produced we do grasp, but the very possibility of it we cannot absorb, just as we cannot absorb creation yesh me'ayin: we learn that this is how it is, we grasp the result, but the essence of the matter is beyond our comprehension.

In summary: in this section we learned that the attribute of gevurah and the name Elokim are not merely a regulating and constricting of the intensity of the light, but a power that creates a new reality: the sensation of being a separate yesh, independent of its source, even though the source is literally bringing it into being at that very moment. Just as the essence of creation from ayin to yesh («olam chesed yibaneh») is not grasped, so too, precisely, the essence of tzimtzum and concealment is not grasped. We saw that the concealment is neither imaginary nor a curtain that only screens outward, since the One doing the concealing is the Holy One Himself, and that both truths, the one that stems from chesed and the one that stems from gevurah, are divine truth. From here comes the answer to the question of what a mitzvah accomplishes: it breaks through a real concealment. And with this the question of chapter three is resolved: the name Havayah and the name Elokim are partners in creation, the one bringing into being and enlivening, the other producing the sensation of being a separate yesh.

In the next section we will continue with the Alter Rebbe's words, where he goes on at length through the end of chapter five, stressing the fundamental principle that the concealment is not a sleight of hand but a genuine divine power.