TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 4 · What Do We Mean When We Call the Almighty “HaGadol”?

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we looked at the flow of G-dly life force that brings created beings into existence. Now we turn to the basic difference between seder hishtalshelus, the ordered chain of unfolding within creation, and yesh me'ayin, creation of something from nothing. In hishtalshelus there are no leaps: chesed gives to gevurah, gevurah carries over into tiferes, tiferes into netzach. Each middah influences only the middah immediately adjacent to it, and skipping a level is impossible, because between two distant middos there is simply no relationship.

But in creation yesh me'ayin, what is the distance between the «something» and its source in the «nothing»? An infinite distance. Coming into being from ayin to yesh is therefore «greatness» in the truest sense of the word: there is no greatness higher than it, an infinite greatness that has no equal.

What the praise «HaGadol» means:

When we praise the Almighty with the word «HaGadol», the Great One, we mean the spreading forth of His life force to infinite creatures, their coming into being from nothing into something as a free gift of chesed, and their continued existence at every single moment through a G-dly kindness that brings them from ayin to yesh constantly.

[A question: why does the Alter Rebbe keep returning to the expression «from ayin to yesh», and never stress the reverse, «from yesh to ayin»? The answer: that point was already discussed at length in chapter 1, that were the letters that create a thing to withdraw, everything would revert to nothingness. Here, however, he is speaking about reality as it actually stands, being brought into existence at every moment from ayin to yesh. And furthermore, we do not actually see existence dissolving: even when the soul is taken from a person, his body does not turn to nothing in that instant.]

And why is this middah called gedulah, greatness? Because it comes from the greatness of the Almighty Himself, in His very own Essence. This is the greatest of all greatnesses, for no one has the capacity to make something from nothing except by the unlimited power of the Creator: «כי גדול ה' ולגדולתו אין חקר», «For great is Hashem and His greatness is unfathomable», and therefore He also bestows life and existence from ayin to yesh upon worlds and creatures without end, for it is the nature of the Good to do good. And what does «doing good» mean here? Revealing His powers and His life force, to infinite creatures and for infinite time, exactly as He wishes.

This is the true concept of «great». Everything we call great in our frame of reference, a great man, a great scholar, is only relatively great within our world, and that is not true greatness. Truly great, without limit, is the Almighty alone, and this is the greatness beyond which there is nothing. This is the first praise in the order of praises of the Almighty in the Shemoneh Esrei: «HaGadol», the middah of chesed, and the Name Havayah that brings everything into being at every moment. After it comes the praise «HaGibor».

«והנה בסידור שבחיו של הקב"ה», a precision in the wording:

It is worth noticing that when the Alter Rebbe comes to quote «HaGadol HaGibor», he does not write «and behold, in the siddur it says HaGadol HaGibor». He uses a longer phrase: «והנה בסידור שבחיו של הקב"ה», «and behold, in the arrangement of the praises of the Almighty». He is not merely telling us where the words appear; he is stressing that these are praises, and in that there are two meanings:

  • A praise that belongs to Him alone: no created being could ever be praised with anything comparable, since this is an unlimited praise.

  • A praise that only He reveals: we cannot praise something we have no knowledge of. Had the Almighty not revealed to us that He is great and that His greatness is unfathomable, we would have had no ability whatsoever to offer Him this praise, since we have no grasp of it at all.

The middos are revealed to us through the Almighty's Torah: He disclosed to us in His Torah that He has a G-dly power called «gadol» and a G-dly power called «gibor».

Beyond the comprehension of created beings:

That we have no ability to grasp His greatness is plain and obvious. We cannot create so much as the wing of a gnat, and all the more so we cannot create anything at all in the world, nor do we have any comprehension of the matter whatsoever. The Alter Rebbe now adds a further point: just as we cannot grasp the infinite force of bringing something into being, so too, precisely, we cannot grasp the second middah, «HaGibor». Measured by our inability to comprehend, both middos stand on exactly the same footing.

In his words: «והנה כמו שמידה זו היא שבחו של הקב"ה לבדו, שאין ביכולת שום נברא לברוא יש מאין ולהחיותו», «And behold, just as this middah is the praise of the Almighty alone, for no created being has the ability to create something from nothing and to give it life». No creature can create something from nothing; and even if you were to hand him something already created and tell him that he is spared the work of creating and need only keep it alive, that too is beyond him. «וגם מידה זו היא למעלה מהשכלת כל הברואים והשגתם», «and this middah is also above the intellect and comprehension of all created beings». To the same degree that we cannot create, we cannot understand the power to create. One cannot say: true, we cannot create, but at least we will understand the process that is taking place. Even the process is beyond our ability to understand.

And why? If the only reason were that this phenomenon does not exist in our world, there would be nothing remarkable about it: there are many things that do not exist in our experience and that we do not grasp, and not necessarily because of their loftiness. Even in the animal kingdom, which is lower than the human, there are many things we do not know and cannot even explain, simply because they are not found in us. So the Alter Rebbe emphasizes a deeper reason: this middah is «above the intellect of all created beings», above the entire conceptual world of a creature as such.

«שאין כוח בשכל שום נברא להשכיל ולהשיג מידה זו ויכולתה לברוא יש מאין», «no created intellect has the power to conceive of or grasp this middah and its ability to create something from nothing». And why? «כי הבריאה יש מאין הוא דבר שלמעלה משכל הנבראים, כי היא ממידת גדולתו של הקב"ה, והקב"ה ומידותיו אחדות פשוט», «because creation of something from nothing is a matter above the intellect of created beings, for it stems from the middah of the greatness of the Almighty, and the Almighty and His middos are a simple unity». The Creator is not, Heaven forbid, assembled out of various middos and powers; rather He and His powers and His middos are one, «כדאיתא בזוהר הקדוש ד'איהו וגרמוהי חד'», «as the holy Zohar states, that He and His attributes are one». And therefore: «וכשם שאין ביכולת שום שכל נברא להשיג בוראו, כך אינו יכול להשיג מידותיו», «and just as no created intellect can grasp its Creator, so too it cannot grasp His middos».

[In the language used in the maamarim of Chassidus: «אילו ידעתיו הייתיו», «had I known Him I would be Him». Were a creature capable of knowing the Creator, he would himself be like Him. All we have is analogy and comparison, not knowledge of His existence and certainly not knowledge of His essence.]

To summarize: in this section we learned that in seder hishtalshelus there is no skipping from one middah to another, whereas bringing something into being yesh me'ayin, where the distance between the «something» and its source is infinite, is true greatness. This is the meaning of the praise «HaGadol»: the spreading forth of life force to infinite creatures and their coming into being from ayin to yesh at every moment as a free gift of chesed, a middah that stems from the greatness of the Almighty in His very Essence, «and His greatness is unfathomable», for it is the nature of the Good to do good. We noted the precision in the phrase «in the arrangement of the praises of the Almighty»: a praise that belongs to Him alone, and one that only He reveals to us through His Torah. And we learned that this middah is withheld from us not only in deed; it is above the intellect and comprehension of all created beings, since the Almighty and His middos are a simple unity, «איהו וגרמוהי חד», and just as no creature grasps its Creator, so it does not grasp His middos.

In the next section we will take up the middah of gevurah, the power of tzimtzum and concealment, and we will see why it too, even though it seems to have some parallel in our world, is entirely beyond the grasp of created beings.