TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 4 · Review of Chapter 3 and the Meaning of the Name Havayah and Chesed

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the last lesson we stopped at the beginning of chapter 4 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, on daf 79a (page 157), about a third of the way down the page, at the line beginning «כמו שכתוב לאיל», right where a new passage opens: «והנה בסידור שבחיו של הקב"ה». Before we go on, let us briefly review the subject we are studying and where exactly we are standing.

The essence of chapter 3:

In chapter 3 we learned a foundational principle, which is really the summary of the entire theme of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah: every creature, everything that we call a «yesh», a something, is in truth absolutely nothing at all. This was explained at length through the analogy of the ray of the sun, in which there are two situations:

  • The ray outside the sun: once the ray leaves the sun and shines out at a distance, it is granted the status of an existence. Not an independent, self standing existence, for even then it depends on the sun at every moment, and when the sun sets the ray vanishes with it. Still, as long as the sun shines, the ray is drawn out and spreads forth from it and takes on the status of «a ray», and it is the sun itself that gives it that status.

  • The ray within the body of the sun: this is a higher state, the ray as it is before it has gone out. Clearly, if there is a ray outside the sun there is a ray inside it as well, except that there one cannot call it a «ray» at all, because inside the sun there is nothing but sun. It is part of the whole, part of the source itself, and it has no independent existence whatsoever.

The same is true in the nimshal, in the world and its relationship to the divine power that brings it into being at every moment. That divine power is present inside the creation at all times, creating it and enlivening it from within, in every detail of it, in every cell and every quality. Every single detail of existence is nothing but a result of the divine life force that is within it at this very moment. It emerges that there is no entity here that has any importance or significance of its own, and nothing exists except an expression of the source.

If so, at what level of bittul (self nullification) are created beings supposed to stand in relation to the source that brings them into being? Like the bittul of the ray that has already left the sun, or like the bittul of the ray inside the sun? In truth, and by the logic of what we have explained, like the ray inside the sun, because it never actually left. In the analogy there really is such a case, the sun is here and the ray has gone out from it. But in the nimshal there is no such case: «מלוא כל הארץ כבודו», the whole earth is filled with His glory. There is no reality in which the creation has left the Creator; rather it is inside Him at every moment and as part of Him, and it has no being, no existence and no importance apart from the power bringing it into being right now.

The question with which chapter 3 closes:

By this reckoning, who ought to see a world and who ought not? One who sees and senses the divine source that brings creation into being, he should see a world, and even then a world that is nullified to its source. But one who does not see the source should see nothing at all, since there is no such thing as an existence without the source.

It is like a candle thrown into a blazing fire: certainly it is inside the fire, but not as a separate entity, only as part of it. It exists as long as the fire exists, and were we to remove the fire from it, nothing of it would remain.

Yet in practice both things exist at once, and they contradict each other. The Holy One has concealed from us any sight of the source, and at the very same time we see and feel an entity that appears to us to exist on its own and by itself. And the wonder is even greater than that. If we felt the world the way one relates to a ray that has left the sun, that would still be understandable, for although the ray is granted some measure of existence, it is obvious that its existence is dependent: the sun moves and the ray moves with it. But the human view of the world is nothing like that. A person sees it as a reality that depends on nothing and does not even need anything to depend on, a reality standing entirely on its own. So not only do we fail to see it at the level of the light's bittul inside the sun, we do not even see it at the level of the light's bittul once it has left the sun. We see it as though it were the sun itself, as though it existed all alone. How can such a thing be? With this question chapter 3 closes.

The opening of chapter 4: «shemesh umagen», a sun and a shield:

In the first part of chapter 4, which we have already learned, it was explained that in order to understand this we must know that the verse describes the name Havayah and the name Elokim with the analogy of «שמש ומגן», a sun and a shield. The name Havayah is like the sun, and the name Elokim is like the shield. We have to understand the role of each one in creation, what the sun does and what the shield does, and from grasping the meaning of the analogy we will understand what these two names are and what is actually happening in creation.

Here it emerges that the role of the shield is not merely the role of a curtain. A curtain placed in front of a floodlight regulates the light, weakens it and gives a dosage that can be tolerated, but it effects no change at all in the light itself. We will see that the shield, and corresponding to it in the nimshal the name Elokim, is a partner in creation. It produces something, and what we see in front of us is the result of the partnership of both forces together.

To put it in a word (and we will see this further on): the name Havayah is what gives the very existence of things, the divine energy that forms them, while the concealment, that darkness in which it seems to us that the world exists cut off from its source, is the work of the name Elokim. It turns out that the Holy One performs two wonders here at once: He creates the reality, and He places within that very reality a feeling of being entirely independent of its source. «אלוקים» has the same gematria as «הטבע», nature, so that the world feels as though nature stands on its own and needs no one. So this is not regulation alone, it is also an act of creation.

We also learned the literal meaning of the name Havayah: the root of the word is the last three letters, hey, vav, hey, which mean «hoveh», bringing into being, the power that constitutes; and the yud at the beginning turns the word into something constant, that this bringing into being happens at every single moment.

«HaGadol HaGibor»: chesed and gevurah:

From here we continue where we left off: «והנה בסידור שבחיו של הקב"ה כתיב: הגדול הגבור כו'» (and in the arrangement of the praises of the Holy One it is written: the Great, the Mighty, etc.). The praises of the Holy One are arranged in the siddur, at the opening of Shemoneh Esreh, where we begin with praise of the Creator: «הא-ל הגדול הגיבור והנורא», the great, mighty and awesome God. The Alter Rebbe now comes to explain these two praises, «HaGadol» and «HaGibor», which correspond to the name Havayah and the name Elokim, to the sun and the shield: «HaGadol» is the name Havayah and «HaGibor» is the name Elokim. And in the order of the middos, «HaGadol» is chesed and «HaGibor» is gevurah.

«ופירוש "הגדול" היא מדת חסד והתפשטות החיות בכל העולמות וברואים לאין קץ ותכלית, להיות ברואים מאין ליש וקיימים בחסד חינם» (the meaning of «the Great» is the attribute of chesed and the spreading forth of life force into all worlds and creatures without end or limit, so that they come into being from nothing into something and exist through free, unearned kindness). What is «great»? The attribute of chesed and the spreading forth of the divine life force into all the worlds and all creatures. And into how many creatures? Without end or limit: endless creations, and more creations and more again, born and drawn forth without end, and every one of them receives divine life force. That itself is «great», for the ability to give life without limit is a praise that belongs only to One who is Himself unlimited, since a limited being cannot give without limit.

And there is a further emphasis in this greatness: «להיות ברואים מאין ליש», that they come into being from nothing into something. That is, there are two things here. First He forms them from nothing into something, and then, once they exist, He brings them into being, sustains them and enlivens them at every moment, as we learned in the earlier chapters, «do not read mechayeh (enlivens) but mehaveh (brings into being)». Each of these two points is in the category of «great».

The Midrash puts it this way: even if all the wise men of the world were to gather and sit together in order to create something new, they could not create so much as the wing of a gnat and place a soul in it. Meaning, they could neither form it nor enliven it.

And what about the Maharal of Prague, who made the golem? The answer is that this was done with a divine power. So too the Gemara relates of Tannaim who would form a calf on erev Shabbos so that they would have what to eat at the Shabbos meal, and likewise it is said regarding Moshe Rabbeinu, «ואם בריאה יברא ה'», if God creates a new creation: the making of a new reality through divine power. We will return to this, God willing, at the beginning of chapter 5, which speaks of divine revelation in the world through tzaddikim and through signs and wonders. This is not a creature producing something by its own power; rather, the Holy One placed in the power of tzaddikim the ability to reveal the divine power. But by human power, even if all the wise men of the world were to gather, no such thing exists at all.

And the reason is this: a limited human creature can give only what it has and only within its own limits, and creating something from nothing is entirely beyond it. Furthermore, every flow and every act of giving in creation passes from giver to receiver only when there is some relationship and closeness between them; where there is no relationship of closeness at all, no communication forms between them and the giver does not give.

For example, a wise man: to whom will he teach his wisdom? To intelligent people who are capable of understanding. But someone who does not understand, a person of limited intelligence, with him he has no common language and he cannot teach him. Only of Shlomo HaMelech, whose wisdom was unlimited relative to all of humanity, was it said that he was «wiser than all men», even than the fools, for he had the ability to communicate even with those who were infinitely distant from him. But in the natural order this is simply not possible.

In summary: we reviewed the foundation of chapter 3, that every created being is considered utterly null and void, like a ray within the sun that never left it, and the question with which that chapter closed: how can it be that we do not see the source, and yet we see an entity that appears to stand on its own, independent of anything? In chapter 4 the analogy of «shemesh umagen» was explained: the name Havayah gives the very existence of things, while the name Elokim («Elokim» has the gematria of «hateva», nature) is not merely a curtain that regulates but a partner in the act of creation, producing the concealment and the creatures' sense of independence. We also looked at the meaning of the name Havayah, from the word mehaveh, bringing into being at every single moment, and at the meaning of «HaGadol» in the siddur: the attribute of chesed and the spreading forth of life force without end or limit, both in creating beings from nothing into something and in enlivening them at every moment, something no human power whatsoever can do.

In the next section we will continue in the Alter Rebbe's own words and look at the meaning of the praise «HaGibor», the attribute of gevurah and the role of the name Elokim in creation.