TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 2 · The Divine Power That Brings Every Detail Into Being, Constantly

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

We are in the final portion of chapter 2 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, daf 77b (page 154). We read up to roughly the last third of the page, and in this section we will first review the foundations explained until now, before returning to the Alter Rebbe's own words from the line beginning «ve'al zeh ne'emar» (And regarding this it is said).

The subject matter of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah is complex and abstract, and at the same time it is critical, one of the foundations of faith that a Jew is meant to live with constantly. That is why these ideas have to be reviewed, returned to, and thought through again and again, until they produce a real change in one's perception of the world, in both senses of the phrase: how to grasp what the world is, and how to look at it.

The central theme of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah:

An explanation of the concept of the oneness of G-d, and the meaning of the verse «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד» (Know this day and take it to your heart, that Hashem is G-d in the heavens above and on the earth below, there is nothing else). This is the concept that has to be understood, and this is the concept one has to live with.

Summary of chapter 1:

  • The word of G-d brings the created thing into being and is found inside it. Building on the teaching of the Baal Shem Tov, the Alter Rebbe explained that the divine power that created each being for the first time during the six days of creation is called «osiyos», letters, as in the verses «ויאמר אלוקים יהי אור» (And G-d said, let there be light), «ויאמר אלוקים תדשא הארץ» (And G-d said, let the earth sprout vegetation), and as our Sages put it in Pirkei Avos, «בעשרה מאמרות נברא העולם» (With ten utterances the world was created). The letters are the mashal, the analogy, for the divine power that dwells within the created thing and brings it into being.

  • At every single moment. This is not a one time creation that happened during the six days of creation and was over. At this very moment that same divine power is inside the creation, continuing to produce it, to bring it into being and to enliven it, as the verse says, «לעולם ה' דברך נצב בשמים» (Forever, Hashem, Your word stands firm in the heavens). Were the word of G-d to stop, G-d forbid, for even one instant from bringing the creation into being, that creation would revert to absolute nothingness, exactly as it was before it was first brought into existence.

  • Not only existence itself, but every single detail. Bare existence is identical in all creations, and about every created thing you can say the very same sentence: it exists because the divine power is bringing it into being. But each creation also has its own individual personality, its own unique qualities, the details that distinguish it from any other creation. And that is the emphasis in the Alter Rebbe's words, that the divine power is found within it: every detail you can identify in a created thing, its existence, its properties, its particular capacities, exists solely because at this very moment the word of G-d is inside it, bringing each and every detail into being and enlivening it. Were that word to withdraw, all of it would vanish as though it had never been.

  • «Mehaveh» and «mechayeh», bringing into being and enlivening. These two points are expressed in two different terms. «Havayah», being, refers to the sheer existence of the creation; «chiyus», life force, refers to the details, the qualities and the particular energies within it. Both of them alike come from the word of G-d that is present inside it at this very moment.

  • Tzimtzum of the divine power. Since the word of G-d is present in every creation according to that creation's own capacity, its own nature and its own character, this means that the divine power contracts itself, tzimtzum, literally for each and every individual creation, in order to enter into it and bring it into being.

  • Where is a «stone» found among the ten utterances? This is the source of the lengthy discussion at the end of chapter 1. It is not mere textual precision. Since every detail and every quality in the world exists only because the word of G-d is inside it bringing it into being at this very moment, it must be that every single detail, the stone, the table, the tree, and even each and every species of butterfly, is found in its source among the ten utterances; a general expression that sweeps everything in is not enough. The explanation is that some things are stated explicitly, while others are present there through exchanges of letters, substitutions and gematrios: the greater and more original the divine energy within a creation, the closer its letters are to the source and the more explicitly it is mentioned; and the more contracted the creation, the further removed its letters are and the more exchanges and substitutions are needed. But all of it is literally there.

[And what about creations that change their own properties, such as bacteria and disease agents that undergo changes and mutations in response to the medications given to them? Nothing new has been brought into existence here, only a change of form, like a person who takes raw silver and fashions a goblet out of it. Nothing was created; the same thing itself simply moved from one form to another. The same divine utterance is bringing the thing into being, and it changes into this form or that according to the ability and the wisdom that the Creator granted to man, including in matters of medicine and the like.]

Chapter 2: from faith to understanding:

Everything explained in chapter 1 rests on emunah, faith. This is what a Jew believes, and this is what the Torah states: «לעולם ה' דברך נצב בשמים». One may say «I don't understand it», but one does not argue about the fact itself, and once we accept the words of our Sages, this is how things are. In chapter 2 the Alter Rebbe comes to bring the matter down to the level of understanding and intellect as well, to make the idea accessible to reason. Not that the Holy One is limited, G-d forbid, to the boundaries of intellect and comprehension; He could have created a world in which there would be no capacity whatsoever to understand this. But He chose to create a world in which we can also grasp logically how the thing works.

The question that arises is this: doesn't the fact that the divine power must be present inside the creation at every single moment indicate some weakness in that power? To put it differently: why does no residue remain from the original act, the way things normally work, where a force does its work and then withdraws, and the product it made remains in place?

The difference between «yesh miyesh» and «yesh me'ayin»:

  • «Yesh miyesh», something from something: the analogy of the silversmith. When a silversmith fashions a vessel and produces a goblet, the goblet does not need to remain attached to its maker. It stands in a display case, and the manufacturer is not required to hold on to it at every moment. The reason is simple: the silversmith didn't really do anything. He did not make the material, and he did not truly create the form either; he merely revealed one of the potential possibilities that already existed in the material beforehand. The proof is that from that very same piece of material one craftsman makes a goblet, another makes a menorah, and a third makes something else entirely, and it can be melted down and returned to what it was. And since he didn't really do anything, it is no wonder that the product is not dependent on its maker.

  • «Yesh me'ayin», something from nothing: the analogy of the thrown stone. A person throws a stone, and the stone stays in the air for a few seconds. Has the stone become a «flying stone»? Certainly not, for it gradually returns to its previous state. The stone in and of itself has no potential for flight at all, and the thrower is not revealing some existing possibility within it; he is creating in it a new state that is not part of its nature. As long as the propelling energy is present, the state continues; the moment that energy weakens or is spent, its product reverts to its former state as if it had never been at all, and the stone returns to its nature, which has nothing to do with flight.

This is an analogy that brings what is happening in the world somewhat closer to our own logic: the world in and of itself has no capacity for independent existence whatsoever, and its entire existence is nothing but the force of the word of G-d bringing it into being at every single moment, just like that stone, which flies only as long as the thrower's force is acting within it.

[A question came up here: if the Holy One were to stop bringing a particular tree into being, what would become of the seeds that came from it, the trees that grew from those seeds, and an apple that has already been detached from it? We have to distinguish between two scenarios. If we are speaking of erasing an entire category, say, the Holy One ceasing to bring the plant kingdom into being and wiping out its existence, then vegetation would not exist in any form at all, including everything that came from it. But if we are speaking of one particular individual, then all the other individuals that the Holy One continues to bring into being continue to exist: the seeds and the trees that grew from that tree stand on their own and draw from the divine utterance that brings them into being. So too, an apple that has been detached from the tree stands on its own and remains, whereas an apple still attached to the tree is nullified along with it.]

[Along these same lines is the well known story about the Alter Rebbe, who put a question to a Jew who came in to him: if the Holy One wishes that there be no table here, what does He have to do? No action is needed at all. It is enough that He cease bringing it into being, and it immediately reverts to absolute nothingness.]

To sum up: in this section we reviewed the foundations of chapter 1, that the word of G-d which brings a creation into being is literally inside it at every single moment, not only in its bare existence («mehaveh») but in every detail and quality it possesses («mechayeh»); that to accomplish this the divine power contracts itself, tzimtzum, for each and every created thing; and that consequently every single detail must be found among the ten utterances, either explicitly or by way of exchanges and substitutions of letters, depending on how close it is to the source. In chapter 2 the Alter Rebbe comes to bring this matter closer to the intellect, through the difference between creation that is «yesh miyesh», where the craftsman did nothing more than reveal a possibility already latent in the material, so that the product is not dependent on him, and «yesh me'ayin», which resembles a stone thrown upward, whose entire new state depends on the force propelling it, and when that force withdraws it reverts as though it had never been.

In the next section we will return to the Alter Rebbe's own words in chapter 2, from the line beginning «ve'al zeh ne'emar», and continue to delve deeper into the explanation.