TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 2 · Creation Ex Nihilo and the Proof from the Splitting of the Sea

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we examined the claim of the deniers, who compare the making of heaven and earth to the work of a silversmith: just as the smith who fashions a vessel need not sustain that vessel once it is made, so too, they argue, creation requires no fresh bringing-into-being at every moment. In the Alter Rebbe's words: «כך מדמים הסכלים הללו» (“so do these fools imagine”), those fools liken the work of the silversmith to the making of heaven and earth.

And at first glance, why should they not be right? What is the difference between the one and the other? Why is the silversmith not required to hold his vessel in existence, while the Creator is? Seemingly this casts the Creator as the weaker of the two: the smith's power is greater, and the Creator's power is feeble.

What did the silversmith actually do?

The truth is that the silversmith innovated nothing at all. Let us break the goblet down into its two components:

  • The material: the raw material, the silver, existed before the smith and will remain after him. He did not create it, and on this point there is nothing even to discuss.

  • The form: within that raw material lies the potential for an infinite number of shapes. The smith took one of those infinite possibilities and brought it out into revelation. That very same lump of silver, in the hands of a different smith, would have emerged in a different form, and in the hands of a third, in a third form.

It turns out that the form was already present in the material beforehand, only in a hidden state, and all the smith did was reveal what was already there. Small wonder, then, that the vessel no longer needs its maker: the smith can walk away, and the vessel stands in its shape and image as before. The vessel owes him nothing, for he did not originate its existence and did not create it.

In the language of the Tanya: «אך טח מראות עיניהם ההבדל הגדול שבין מעשה אנוש ותחבולותיו» (“but their eyes are too plastered over to see the great difference between the work of man and his devices”). Their eyes are smeared shut and do not see straight. The work of man is never more than «יש מיש», something from something: he had one existing thing before him and made from it another existing thing, and even that second thing he did not originate but merely revealed. Had he genuinely introduced something new here, he would indeed have had to sustain his innovation constantly; but his entire act is «רק שמשנה הצורה והתמונה, מתמונת חתיכת כסף לתמונת כלי» (“he merely changes the form and the shape, from the shape of a piece of silver to the shape of a vessel”).

Not so the making of heaven and earth, which is yesh me'ayin, something from absolute nothing. The Holy One did not take raw material and alter its shape; He created the material and the form, all the potential latent within it and all of its properties, and none of this existed beforehand in any way whatsoever. And once an entirely new creation has been brought into being, it is impossible for that innovation to endure unless the One who innovates it renews it and acts upon it at every single moment.

The analogy of the thrown stone:

The maamarim of Chassidus bring a simple illustration of this principle from everyday life, something any child can observe at any moment: a person throws a stone upward, even just a few centimeters. How long the stone remains in the air depends on how much force was invested in the throw. Why does the stone not stay up in the air, unlike the vessel, which keeps its form even after the smith has gone?

The difference is straightforward. A stone possesses many properties, each stone with its own characteristics, but there is one property it does not have at all: the property of flight. Of itself, a stone has no capacity whatsoever to hover in the air. Therefore, when a state of flight comes to be in the stone, this is an utter innovation introduced into it by an outside force. The Holy One granted a created being the ability to introduce into the stone a state that does not exist within it on its own. And as long as the innovating force continues to act, the innovation endures; the instant that force ceases, the stone reverts to its own intrinsic nature and falls.

[And even if the stone were to be found in a place with no gravitational pull and were to hover there, this would not be because the stone's own nature had changed, but because external conditions produce that state. That very same stone, brought back here, would fall as stones do, proof that flight is not among its properties.]

Now to the nimshal: the existence of the world is, by way of analogy, like a stone in flight. Of itself the world has no claim to existence at all. Before the Holy One created the world there was no concept of a world existing whatsoever, so from where should it have any existence? During the six days of Creation the Holy One introduced an innovation and brought a new state into being, and that state endures only because the innovating force continues to renew it, «המחדש בטובו בכל יום תמיד מעשה בראשית» (“who in His goodness renews each day, constantly, the work of Creation”). The moment the innovating force stops innovating, as we learned in chapter one regarding the letters, that if the letters were to withdraw, heaven forbid, everything would revert to its prior state.

Why did the Alter Rebbe not bring this analogy?

The analogy is beautiful and accurate, and it is indeed found in the sefarim, and nevertheless the Alter Rebbe does not bring it here. The reason: this analogy can serve only after Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah has been learned; one cannot open with it. For if we open with it, the objection stands: who says that the Creator's act of forming is bound by the same rules that govern us when we throw a stone? He is all-powerful, and with Him it may well not work that way at all. Such a proof has no power to compel any conclusion about how things operate with the Creator.

The proof must therefore come from a different source: the Holy One revealed to us in His Torah that this is how He acts. Had He wished, He could have created a world and established its existence in some other fashion; but once He has revealed in His Torah that this is how He renews it, the matter also settles well with reason, and we even have tangible examples of it in the nature of the world. For this reason the analogy is not brought here.

The proof from the splitting of the Sea:

Now the Alter Rebbe moves to an example aimed at believers, not at deniers. The deniers reject the signs and wonders of the Torah, as he said earlier, and there is no point bringing them a proof from a Torah narrative that means nothing to them. With them he has already finished: they fail to distinguish between the work of man, which is yesh miyesh, and the innovation of yesh me'ayin.

But the believing Jew may well ask: the Holy One is all-powerful, exalted beyond all exaltedness, and He could have created a world that would sustain itself; why should we diminish His ability? To this the Alter Rebbe answers: in the Torah itself we have a revelation that this is how it is. The creation of the world is a greater wonder than the splitting of the Sea, and therefore the proof comes by way of a kal vachomer: if this is so at the splitting of the Sea, how much more so in the creation of the world.

What happened at the splitting of the Sea, and where in it do we see the principle the Alter Rebbe has established, that in every innovation the innovating force must be present within it at every single moment? The Book of Shemos says: «ויולך ה' את הים ברוח קדים עזה כל הלילה» (“and G-d drove back the sea with a strong east wind all the night”), and then «ויבקעו המים» (“and the waters were split”). The Torah reveals to us that the manner in which the Sea split was through the divine power clothing itself in a wind, and it adds that the wind acted «כל הלילה» (“all the night”). The Holy One could have done it some other way, yet He chose that the wind should stand there the entire night, and we must understand why.

And what did the east wind accomplish in the waters? A gradual process in three stages:

  1. «ויבקעו המים» (“and the waters were split”): the Sea opened into two.

  2. «ונצבו כמו נד» (“and they stood upright like a heap”): «נד» means waters gathered together; the waters stood gathered in one place. For an example of this one need not travel as far as the splitting of the Sea: water in a cup is gathered and does not spill off to the sides, because the cup holds it; and here the Holy One took the east wind to serve as a giant cup that would gather in the waters. At this stage nothing had yet changed in the nature of the water: it remained liquid water as before, only gathered together.

  3. «והמים להם חומה» (“and the waters were a wall for them”): at this stage the very nature of the water changed. A wall is made of stones, and stones stand one upon the other and do not collapse because the nature of stone is to be solid, just as the nature of water is to be liquid. Here the water took on the nature of a solid, and in this state of a wall it stood all the night.

In summary: in this section we learned the fundamental difference between the work of man and the making of heaven and earth. The silversmith creates neither the material nor the form; he merely reveals one of the possibilities latent in the raw material, «יש מיש» (“something from something”), and «רק שמשנה הצורה והתמונה מתמונת חתיכת כסף לתמונת כלי» (“he merely changes the form and shape from the shape of a piece of silver to the shape of a vessel”); and that is why the vessel no longer needs him. Not so creation, which is yesh me'ayin, in which everything was brought into being from absolute nothingness, and therefore the innovation cannot endure unless the Innovator renews it at every moment. We saw the analogy of the thrown stone as it appears in the maamarim of Chassidus, and the reason the Alter Rebbe does not open with it, since the proof must come from the Torah's own revelation. And finally we began the proof from the splitting of the Sea: that the wind stood all the night, and the three stages of the miracle, the splitting, the gathering like a heap, and the wall.

In the next section we will learn the kal vachomer that follows from the splitting of the Sea to the creation of the world, and the verse «לעולם ה' דברך נצב בשמים» (“forever, O G-d, Your word stands firm in the heavens”).