We now turn to chapter 2 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, which begins on daf 77a (page 153). Before we take it up, let us review the foundations laid down in chapter 1, and from there continue into chapter 2.
Review of the foundations of chapter 1:
In Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah the Alter Rebbe establishes a great principle in faith in G-d and in the oneness of G-d: the Holy One is the only reality, in the sense of «ein od», there is nothing besides Him. Yet at first glance we see before our eyes a vast world, full of existence. The Alter Rebbe therefore explains at length what it is that makes the world's existence possible: not only the bare fact that it is here, but also its qualities, its details, and everything found in each and every creature. Where do all of these come from, and what sustains them so that they continue to exist?
The answer is that everything flows from one single point, exactly as it did at the very first moment when the Holy One created the world during the six days of creation. The Alter Rebbe builds this principle on the verse «Forever, O G-d, Your word stands firm in the heavens». At every single moment, from the six days of creation until now, the word of G-d continues to bring the creation into being and to enliven it, literally something from nothing, just as it did the first time. And the power that brought the world into being at the outset was a power of letters and of speech, as our Sages say, «With ten utterances the world was created»: these are the utterances listed at the beginning of Bereishis, the Divine speech that produced the entire creation. These letters, in which the Divine power is clothed, do not act only during the six days of creation to draw the creature out of nothingness into being. They remain present within the creatures and enliven them from nothing into being at every single moment.
Toward the end of chapter 1 the Alter Rebbe raises a question: the ten utterances do not mention by name all the creatures in the world. They list only certain general categories, while the world contains thousands upon thousands of kinds of creatures (the example he brings is a stone, and it is only an example). If the source of the life force of every creature is in the ten utterances, and from there it receives its vitality to this very moment, how can that be, when its name does not appear there at all?
The essence of the answer is that in truth everything is included in the ten utterances, but there are different levels in how it is included. Some things appear there directly, and some appear in concealed form, by way of exchanges of letters, substitutions, gematriaos and permutations, like the 231 gates of Sefer Yetzirah, which present various ways of combining letters. Contained within the power of the letters of the ten utterances is the whole of creation, and those letters continue at every moment to bring each creature into being from nothing into something.
And were the letters to withdraw from the creature, G-d forbid, and cease bringing it into being even for one instant, the creature would not exist at all. Not only that: the absence would not be merely from that point onward. It would revert to exactly the state before the six days of creation, as though it had never been and never been created, with no possibility of saying that something had once been here.
But the Holy One does not withdraw the letters from the creature, because there is a plan and a goal to the creation: that the Holy One desired a dirah betachtonim, a dwelling place in the lower realms. Therefore the world continues to exist at every moment by the power of those very letters.
The point to carry away from chapter 1 is this: when we look at a world, we are not seeing a world, we are seeing Divine letters that are forming a world. That is how one must look at the world. The world has no independent existence of its own in any sense whatsoever, neither the physical substance of the creature nor its qualities. The entire reality of the world is nothing but an expression of the Divine power that brings it into being and draws it from nothing into something at every moment. And this is the point of the verse «And you shall know this day and take it to your heart, that the L-rd is G-d in the heavens above and upon the earth below, there is nothing else».
Chapter 2: from faith to intellectual understanding
In chapter 1 the foundation rested on faith. How do we know that this is in fact how things are? Because that is what the verse says, «Forever, O G-d, Your word stands firm in the heavens», and because this is what the Alter Rebbe received from his teachers. A believing Jew knows that this is what is written and that this is how things work. In chapter 2 the Alter Rebbe comes to take that very same foundation and bring it down into the grasp of ordinary human intellect, so that it should not remain merely a matter of «this is what is written and we believe it».
In his words: "והנה מכאן תשובת המינים וגילוי שורש טעותם, הכופרים בהשגחה פרטית ובאותות ומופתי התורה", «And from here comes the refutation of the heretics and the revelation of the root of their error, those who deny individual Divine providence and the signs and wonders of the Torah». On the strength of the principle explained in chapter 1 we now hold the answer to the error of the heretics, the apikorsim and the deniers, and the exposure of the root of that error.
The deniers have a whole chain of errors, one mistake leading to the next:
The error on the surface: they claim that all the signs and wonders recorded in the Torah, at the exodus from Egypt, at the splitting of the Sea, and on other occasions, are not true, and they do not believe in them.
The error that precedes it: they claim that the world is not under providence, that there is no supervision by a Creator over what happens in the world, but rather the world rolls along on its own, one event following another naturally and entirely by chance.
The root of the error: they do not accept that the world is dependent on its Creator at every single moment. We are speaking here of people who do believe that the Holy One created the world, but who claim that once He created it He separated from it, and the world now rolls along by itself. Given that, it follows for them as a matter of course that there is no providence, and consequently no signs and wonders. The root of it all is the assumption that the world can exist without a Divine power present within it right now, at every moment.
The Alter Rebbe spells out that they err "בדמיונם הכוזב", «in their false imagination», a mistaken and untrue conception, "שמדמין מעשה ה' עושה שמים וארץ למעשה אנוש ותחבולותיו", «in that they compare the work of G-d, the Maker of heaven and earth, to the work of man and his devices». Their argument runs: what difference is there between what a human being produces and what the Holy One produces? Every manufacturer, every factory turning out its product, once the work is finished the product exists independently of the manufacturer, and he is not required to keep on producing what he has already produced. If so, why should we not say the same of the Holy One: He is the manufacturer, He produced a world, and once He produced it the world will go on existing by itself.
It is worth noting that this same question arises from a direction other than that of the deniers. A believing Jew can also ask it, in two formulations. First: if a flesh and blood manufacturer is able to produce something that goes on existing on its own, is the Holy One not able to do as much? And second, coming from faith at its very strongest: the Holy One is all capable, so why could He not create a world that would not require constant renewal of its existence? For the believing Jew the answer ultimately rests on faith, because this is what is written in the Torah.
And it is worth emphasizing: the Holy One is not bound by the rules of logic, and what is logical to us does not dictate how He conducts His world. For example, simple logic dictates that a father is older than his son. Had the Holy One wished to create the reverse, that a son should be older than his father, He could have done so, for He is not limited. It is only because He created the world in this particular way that such a thing strikes us as absurd and unthinkable. Accordingly, we have no way of proving by force of logic how things operate with Him. But the Holy One revealed to us in His Torah that on this point He did in fact create the world according to that very logic, and therefore the matter can also be explained intellectually. With this the Alter Rebbe opens his explanation of the difference between the work of a silversmith and the work of G-d.
The parable of the silversmith:
"כי כאשר יצא לצורף כלי, שוב אין הכלי צריך לידי הצורף, כי אף שידיו מסולקות הימנו והולך לו בשוק - הכלי קיים בתבניתו וצלמו ממש כאשר יצא מידי הצורף", «For once a silversmith has finished fashioning a vessel, the vessel no longer needs the hands of the silversmith; for even though his hands have been withdrawn from it and he has gone off to the marketplace, the vessel remains in its form and shape exactly as it left the silversmith's hands». A silversmith who has produced a goblet, a candlestick or a menorah: once he has completed his work, the vessel has no further need of him at all. His hands are withdrawn from what he has made and he goes off to his affairs in the marketplace, while the vessel stands where it is. There is no longer any connection between them, and the vessel remains in the very same form and shape in which it left the silversmith's hands, unchanged, and the silversmith is not called upon to hold its form in place at every moment.
To summarize: in this portion we reviewed the foundations of chapter 1: that the word of G-d contained in the ten utterances brings every creature into being and enlivens it from nothing into something at every moment; that all creatures are included in it through combinations and exchanges of letters; and that were those letters to withdraw, the creature would revert to absolute nothingness. From there we moved into chapter 2, which brings this principle down into intellectual understanding: the refutation of the heretics and the revelation of the root of their error, from the denial of signs and wonders, through the denial of hashgachah pratis (individual Divine providence), down to the root, the false imagination that equates the work of G-d with the work of man, as in the parable of the silversmith whose vessel goes on existing afterward without him.
In the next portion we will take up the fundamental difference between the craft of the silversmith, who makes something from something, and the creation of heaven and earth, which is something from nothing, and we will explain why this difference necessarily requires a continuous bringing into being at every single moment.