In the previous section we completed chapter 1 of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah. It is worth noting that we did not find an explicit explanation as to why the Alter Rebbe chose precisely this order of presentation, and why he did not lay out the whole matter at once from the start, but there is no doubt that every detail here is precise and deliberate. Now we turn to the beginning of chapter 2.
Chapter 2: The Answer to the Minim
The Alter Rebbe opens: «והנה, מכאן תשובת המינים וגילוי שורש טעותם, הכופרים בהשגחה פרטית ובאותות ומופתי התורה» (And from here comes the answer to the minim, the heretics, and the revelation of the root of their error, they who deny hashgacha pratis, individual Divine providence, and who deny the signs and wonders of the Torah). In other words: from the foundation laid down in chapter 1 there flows the answer to the view of the minim, and the root of their error becomes exposed.
Who are the minim being spoken of here?
The reference is not to those heretics who hold that the world is eternal and sustains itself. The term «minim» is a general category (the Rambam, in Sefer HaMada, lists the positions that make a person a min, and there he also explains the difference between a «min» and a «kofer», and this is not the place to elaborate). Here we are speaking of people who do believe that the Holy One formed and created the entire world, except that in their view, once He created it He left it to exist and run on its own, by a natural process: whatever happens, happens by itself.
It follows that they deny hashgacha pratis, and not in the sense we are used to, but providence as such: in their view the Holy One does not supervise what goes on in the world, and the world runs under its own power. And since they do not believe in providence, they also do not believe in the signs and wonders of the Torah. For a wonder means that someone brought it about for a particular purpose, whereas according to them every event happened naturally: the splitting of the Sea of Reeds was a matter of tides, and it simply happened to work out that way. There is no guiding hand here, they say, G-d forbid.
The Root of the Error
From chapter 1 we learned the foundational point: no single detail of creation exists unless at that very moment the Divine life force is being drawn into it in the form of the letters that contract down from the supernal lights. Therefore it is impossible for anything to sustain itself, because if the Divine life force were to stop contracting into creation for even one instant, then «כל השמים אין ואפס ממש, והיו כלא היו כלל» (all the heavens would be literally naught and nothingness, and would be as though they had never existed at all).
There is a precision in this wording worth highlighting. The Alter Rebbe is not content to say that everything would revert to naught and nothingness; he adds «והיו כלא היו כלל» (and they would be as though they had never been at all), and then adds further «וכמו קודם מאמר יהי רקיע» (just as before the utterance «Let there be a firmament»): a complete return to the state that preceded creation, as if they had never existed. What does this mean? Let us illustrate with three scenarios. Two of them occur among created beings, and from them the novelty of the third will become clear.
The Lego analogy: On Sunday the Lego bricks are lying scattered about. On Monday a fine, impressive house has been built out of them. On Tuesday the house is taken apart and the bricks are scattered again. Factually, the situation on Tuesday is identical to the situation on Sunday: scattered bricks. But conceptually they are not the same. On Sunday there was no building because no one had yet built one; on Tuesday there is no building because someone came and dismantled it. These are not the same kind of absence.
The stone analogy: In the first minute the stone is lying on the floor; in the second minute a person throws it into the air; in the third minute the stone is once again lying on the floor. Here the resemblance is stronger: the stone lies on the floor in the first minute because that is its nature, and for exactly the same reason it lies there in the third minute. If anything, the novelty was precisely in the second minute: how does a stone come to be up in the air? And yet even this is not a perfect return, because in the third minute one can still tell the story that there was a minute in which the stone was in the air. The narrative remains in existence.
In the creation of the world: If the Creator were, G-d forbid, to return the letters to their source, even the concept of time would be nullified, since time too is a creation. And when there is no time, not only would the world not be as it had been, but there would be no state in which one could say «but before this, it existed». Everything is erased. This is «כמו קודם מאמר יהי רקיע» in the most literal sense.
We have no parallel to this among created things. Within creation, even when something returns to its prior state, some residue of it remains: factual, conceptual, or at the very least in the telling of the story. But here, if everything were, G-d forbid, to revert, no residue whatsoever would remain: not factual, not conceptual, not even a story to tell. Everything would return to the precise state that preceded it. It emerges that the world's existence at every single moment is only because at that very moment the Divine act of creation is being drawn down and renewed.
This is the root of the error of those who deny hashgacha pratis: they do not grasp this principle and do not accept it. In their view creation was a one time act that came to an end, whereas the Baal Shem Tov's novel teaching is that creation is renewed at every single moment.
To summarize: In this section we learned the opening of chapter 2: «And from here comes the answer to the minim and the revelation of the root of their error». We clarified the identity of the minim under discussion: those who believe in creation but hold that the world runs on its own, and who consequently deny providence and deny the signs and wonders of the Torah. We saw that the root of their error lies in a failure to grasp the foundation of chapter 1, and through three scenarios (the Lego, the stone, and the creation of the world) the precision of the phrase «והיו כלא היו כלל וכמו קודם מאמר יהי רקיע» became clear: a complete reversion that leaves no residue whatsoever, since time itself is also a created thing.
One question remains open, and it was already raised in the previous lesson: someone encountering this for the first time might think it implies a weakness in the Divine power. When a human being makes something, he makes it, and from then on it exists on its own; yet the Creator has to renew His creation at every moment? In the next section we will address this question and its explanation, with G-d's help.