TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Introduction · The Oneness of the Creator in the Chiddush of the Baal Shem Tov

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we looked at the mitzvah of emunah, believing in Hashem, and the mitzvah of His oneness. In this section we will see just how much this awareness bears on practical daily life, what it means on the level of pshat (the plain sense) and on the level of sod (the mystical sense), and what the Baal Shem Tov adds, his chiddush, in the oneness of the Creator.

This awareness changes everything, because the real question is how a person lives by it. When the awareness is missing, a subtle, small-scale avodah zarah can slip into a person's life. In the first mitzvah, believing in G-dliness, and likewise in the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness, any flaw at all falls under the heading of avodah zarah: whoever brings an additional partner into the “business” has stumbled into idolatry. And in truth there is no vacuum here: He alone, and there is nothing besides Him.

“He believes in the Life of the worlds and sows”:

To sharpen the point, and to see how a Jew who believes in one G-d is expected to live, let us bring an interesting passage from the Gemara. The verse says: “והיה אמונת עתיך חוסן ישועות חכמת ודעת, יראת ה' היא אוצרו” (And the faith of your times shall be a strength of salvations, wisdom and knowledge; the fear of Hashem, that is his treasure). The Gemara, in the name of Reish Lakish, expounds that the six words of the verse hint at the six orders of the Mishnah in their order: “אמונת” (faith) is Seder Zeraim; “עתיך” (your times) is Seder Moed, from the word for time and season, which is exactly what Seder Moed deals with: Shabbos, the festivals and the holidays; and so on down the list.

The question arises: what is the connection between the word “אמונת,” faith, and Seder Zeraim? Seder Zeraim, as its name says, deals with a great many mitzvos and practices connected to the produce of the ground that a person sows: terumos and maasros, leket, shichechah and peah, the gifts to the poor, and everything bound up with seeds. What does faith have to do with any of this?

Tosafos there explains: “מפרש בירושלמי שמאמין בחי העולמים וזורע” (the Yerushalmi explains that he believes in the Life of the worlds and sows). A Jew takes a kernel of wheat and buries it in the earth: why does he do it? A farmer standing in his field sowing would say that this is simply how the world works: you sow, rain falls, the earth brings forth, and the cycle continues. Tosafos says that a Jew does not sow because that is the way of the world; he sows because he believes in the Holy One, blessed be He. He knows the world has a Creator, and he trusts Him to give His blessing. That is why he says in the Shemoneh Esreh: “ברוך אתה ה' מברך השנים” (Blessed are You, Hashem, who blesses the years).

Where exactly does this faith get tested?

At first glance it all sounds simple: a Jew believes, prays and sows. But it is worth going deeper and being precise. Picture a valley with twenty fields belonging to twenty farmers. Nineteen of them are righteous, G-d-fearing Jews, who deserve the blessing stated in Krias Shema: “והיה אם שמוע תשמעו אל מצוותי... ונתתי מטר ארצכם בעתו” (And it will be, if you truly listen to My mitzvos... I will give the rain of your land in its season). One of them, whose field sits in the middle of the valley, is not deserving of having his crop grow.

Now suppose that man says to himself: after all, every field here is going to grow, rain is going to fall, that is how the world works. Is the Holy One really going to perform a special miracle so that all the fields flourish and only my field stays dry? Will the rain fall all around and skip my field? That is a natural way of seeing things, the view of eyes of flesh looking at the physicality of the world without the eyes of faith.

Put differently, this line of thought says that the Holy One set up nature in the world, nature runs itself, and the Creator, as it were, does not necessarily intervene in what happens. If He wants, He can perform a great miracle and leave one field dry, like the miracle of the fleece in Tanach, where Gideon asked Hashem for a sign that dew should fall only on the fleece and not on the ground around it, and so it was. But as long as He does not intervene, nature is in charge.

The mitzvah of Hashem's oneness according to pshat:

Along comes the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness and teaches that there is no other ruler, and that one may not attribute any power of control to nature, as if to say that the Creator is indeed mighty and capable, but in practice nature is what rules. Exclusive control belongs to the Holy One alone: if rain falls, it is because He wants it to fall, and if He does not want it, it will not fall. There is no question here of intervening or not intervening, because He runs everything down to the last detail, and He needs no special miracle in order to change a thing.

This is the meaning of the verse “וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים” (And you shall know this day and take it to your heart that Hashem is G-d) on the level of plain pshat. This is not chassidus, not sod, not Kabbalah; it is the simple meaning. A Jew is obligated at every given moment in fulfilling the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness, “שמע ישראל ה' אלוקינו ה' אחד” (Hear O Israel, Hashem is our G-d, Hashem is one), which he says twice every day: there is no other ruler, and He is the only One in control.

The mitzvah of Hashem's oneness according to sod:

Then comes the Zohar, the teachings of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, and adds a far deeper dimension to this mitzvah. It is not only that one must not attribute control to some foreign power, G-d forbid; that much is already clear from the pshat. There is something more. As is known, the creation of the world has an order of hishtalshelus, the chainlike unfolding of worlds, as we have learned many times in Tanya: four worlds, Atzilus, Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah; memaleh kol almin and sovev kol almin, the light that fills all worlds and the light that encompasses all worlds; the name Havayah and the name Elokim; the power of limitation and the power of the limitless; the ten sefiros. So there is a multiplicity of Divine powers, and a great difference between the way the Creator reveals Himself through one power and the way He reveals Himself through another.

An analogy: a human being has different faculties. He has a higher faculty of intellect, to think deeply and to explain, and a lower faculty of action, to pick up a hammer and nails and build a sukkah. There is a great difference between how he is invested when he is engaged with the lower faculties and how he is invested in the higher ones: outwardly he wears work clothes here and different clothes there, and inwardly he is focused differently, speaks differently and comes across differently. A person expressing himself emotionally is not the same as a person expressing himself intellectually or technically, because each faculty is a different level and a different expression of his personality.

Shall we say the same of the Creator of the world, who emanated from Himself different powers: powers of limitation and powers of the limitless, the name Havayah, which means He was, He is and He will be as one, an infinite power, and the name Elokim, which is the power of limitation? Is there, as it were, a multiplicity in G-dliness, so that at one moment He is this way and at another moment that way? For even on the level of pshat we find “ה' איש מלחמה” (Hashem is a man of war), that sometimes He reveals Himself as a mighty warrior, and sometimes wrapped in a tallis, as He revealed Himself to Moshe Rabbeinu in the thirteen attributes of mercy, as brought in the words of our Sages and in Rashi.

To this the Zohar says: “אני ה' לא שניתי” (I, Hashem, have not changed), which means that “הוי' ואלוקים כולא חד” (Havayah and Elokim are entirely one), with no difference between them. It is not like a human being, where when he reveals himself through one faculty he is different from when he reveals himself through another, because a person is composite, and his “oneness” is a composite oneness. With the Creator, although here there is an expression of limitation and there an expression of the limitless, He Himself is one, without the slightest difference. This is the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness according to the Zohar: to contemplate, to go deep, and to believe that He is one in His revelation through this power, and He is the same one in His revelation through the other.

The mistake of the spies:

Where does this become visible? With the meraglim, the spies. The spies were righteous men whom Moshe Rabbeinu chose to scout out the Land of Israel, and of them it is said: “כולם אנשים ראשי בני ישראל המה” (they were all men, heads of the children of Israel). They had seen the exodus from Egypt, the ten plagues and the splitting of the sea; they had witnessed with their own eyes supernatural miracles that the Creator performed. And still they came back and said that they would not manage to enter the land of Canaan, in the words of the verse: “כי חזק הוא ממנו” (for he is stronger than us). Rashi explains: do not read “ממנו” as “than us,” but rather, as it were, upward, stronger than the Holy One, and they even used a parable: “אפילו בעל הבית אינו יכול להוציא כליו משם” (even the Master of the house cannot get His vessels out of there). Every child who learns this wonders: what happened to them? Where did their faith go?

The answer is that this was their perspective: the Creator has different modes of revelation. There is revelation by way of miracle and there is revelation by way of nature. When He chooses to reveal Himself miraculously, that is one form of expression, and when He chooses to reveal Himself through nature, that is a different form of expression. In Egypt He chose to reveal Himself by way of miracle, whereas in the land of Canaan they knew the revelation would be by way of nature. And by the rules of nature, the thirty-one kings ruling the land of Canaan were stronger than the six hundred thousand. For when the Creator reveals Himself through nature, the rules of nature operate differently from the rules of miracles.

And indeed they knew that in the land the conduct would be natural: not as in Egypt facing Pharaoh, where no weapons and no military draft were needed and everything ran by way of miracle, but rather enlisting soldiers and waging war, as Moshe Rabbeinu said to the tribes of Gad and Reuven, “חלוצים תעברו לפני אחיכם” (you shall cross over armed before your brothers). There are weapons, there are soldiers, there is war and there are rules, and by the rules of nature there is such a thing as a balance of power.

The root of their error was a lack of the explanation of Hashem's oneness according to sod, for “כולא חד,” it is all one: there is no difference between the modes, and the Creator does not have to stop, change garments and switch over to another approach in order to bring about a change in nature. Within the natural process itself He can change the rules of nature at that very moment, as He wishes. And that is exactly what happened in practice: at Jericho things ran according to the rules of nature, and within nature itself miracles above nature were woven in. The recognition that by the Creator everything blends together and there is no dividing into two separate domains, that is the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness according to sod: He is one with His powers, and His powers are one.

One must not make a separation here the way a human being does. When a man stands in his office in dignified clothing and addresses his employees, he is not at that same moment holding a hammer and arranging the table; he calls a tradesman who comes in work clothes to do the building. They are two people, each with his own domain. With the Creator it is not so, and there is no difference between one Divine power and another.

[There is another well-known explanation of the spies, that they did not want to enter the land but to remain in the spiritual realm alone and not mix the domains. That is a long subject in its own right and this is not the place for it; the matter of the spies was brought here only as an illustration.]

The chiddush of the Baal Shem Tov:

So far we have gone briefly through the matter according to pshat and according to sod, though each of them could easily fill an entire series of classes. But our main aim is to arrive at Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah according to pnimiyus haTorah, the inner dimension of Torah, as taught by the Baal Shem Tov, and from there to understand what is about to be explained here.

Before the Baal Shem Tov there were fine Jews who knew the pshat, knew the sod, and simply believed in the oneness of Hashem. It was all clear: an explicit verse, “ה' אלוקינו ה' אחד,” and they directed all the proper kavanos while saying the word “echad.” Then comes the foundation and depth of the Baal Shem Tov's approach and adds something new. Until now the discussion has been that the Creator's oneness is a oneness of His powers: this power and that power are entirely one, Havayah and Elokim are entirely one, and no other power called nature has any control.

The Baal Shem Tov adds: not only are the name Havayah and the name Elokim one with the Creator, but the world itself, the physical reality that was created, heaven and earth with their myriads upon myriads of details, is one with the Creator. For seemingly, even someone who believes that all His powers are one still feels that the world is a reality unto itself. He does not mean that the world has control or power, certainly not, but still it seems as though there is a reality of a world here. Comes the Baal Shem Tov and makes it clear, and this is what will be explained at length here in Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, that the world too, with all its details, is one with the Creator: not only are His powers one with Him, but so is the reality that was created and formed, physical reality itself, down to the simplest inanimate object.

This is extremely hard to grasp, for two reasons. First, because we live inside the reality of the world and feel it as a genuine reality, and the whole world shouts “כוחי ועוצם ידי” (my strength and the might of my hand). And second, because the difficulty is hinted at in the verse itself, as the Alter Rebbe will point out precisely at the beginning of the chapter: the verse that commands this knowledge uses language that shows just how hard it is to absorb. It is not enough to say “וידעת היום” (and you shall know this day); it adds “והשבות אל לבבך” (and you shall take it to your heart), meaning that it has to be driven into the heart with force.

Had we remained with pshat alone or with sod alone, it would have been enough to tell a Jew that this is how it is, and he believes it. But to absorb that the world too is utterly nullified to the Creator, in complete bittul, and one with Him, that does not go in by itself. Even when a person knows it, he finds it hard to live with it and to accept it, because he experiences a world that contradicts it. That is why the verse uses several expressions: “וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת” (and you shall know this day and take it to your heart that Hashem is G-d in the heavens above and on the earth below). A person has to look for means, approaches and explanations, in order to find pathways into his own heart and recognize that the created reality too is one with Him.

A clarification is in order: certainly reality was created by the Creator, and He forms it, creates it and brings it into being at every moment. The question is whether the reality that was created is a reality separate from Him. The goal is to reach the recognition that although a physical reality was created and it exists, and as we will see in the next section it clearly does exist, nevertheless it is absolutely one with the Creator.

In summary: in this section we looked at the practical implication of the mitzvah of Hashem's oneness, and how its absence leads to a refined form of avodah zarah. We learned from the Gemara and Tosafos that a Jew “believes in the Life of the worlds and sows,” and we illustrated the test of that faith with the valley of twenty fields. According to pshat: there is no ruler besides Him, nature has no control whatsoever, and He runs everything down to the last detail. According to sod: “Havayah and Elokim are entirely one,” there is no difference between His modes of revelation, and the spies' mistake came from splitting miraculous conduct off from natural conduct. The Baal Shem Tov adds that the created physical reality itself is also one with the Creator, and this is the recognition that demands “and you shall take it to your heart.”

In the next section we will open with the first lines of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah and learn how to connect reality back to the Holy One. Once reality is connected to the Holy One, living according to Torah becomes self-evident and unavoidable, because there is no other reality besides Him, even though the world shouts the opposite. This work is not simple: first to understand it, and then to connect to it. So far we have only set out the headline, and that itself has to be internalized; the rest will follow, with G-d's help.