Before we begin learning Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, we need a few introductory points, so that we will appreciate what exactly the Alter Rebbe is adding in this section of Tanya. After all, the idea of yichud (G-d's oneness) and emunah (faith) is hardly an innovation of the Tanya: it is one of the taryag (613) mitzvos, and every Jew has been obligated in it since Mattan Torah.
More than that: yichud and emunah are a great foundation, especially because they are counted among the six mitzvos known as the «constant mitzvos», mitzvos that are not bound by time, place or gender. Man and woman, weekday and Yom Tov alike, a Jew is obligated in them at every moment. These six, which as a group are mitzvos of chovos halevavos (the duties of the heart), a Jew must know and fulfill constantly and completely.
It follows that this mitzvah has existed since Mattan Torah, and that there were whole and good Jews who fulfilled it for many generations before the great light of the Baal Shem Tov was revealed, and long before the world was given the sefer HaTanya. What, then, is the great chiddush that the Baal Shem Tov came to add in the mitzvah of achdus Hashem, G-d's oneness?
To answer that, let us first see how this mitzvah was understood before the Baal Shem Tov, on two levels: al pi pshat (the plain meaning) and al pi sod (the mystical dimension). The Zohar, after all, was written by Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai many centuries ago, so the inner dimension of the mitzvah has been available for hundreds of years and more. Afterwards we will see what the Baal Shem Tov revealed, and what Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah in Tanya adds beyond everything that was known until then.
What we will learn here is based on what is explained at length and in detail in Derech Mitzvosecha of the Tzemach Tzedek, a sefer that explains mitzvos of the taryag according to pnimiyus (the inner dimension of Torah). There the Tzemach Tzedek explains the mitzvah of achdus Hashem on several levels, and arrives at the chiddush of the Baal Shem Tov in this matter.
The first two of the mitzvos asei (positive commandments):
The mitzvah of emunas haElokus, faith in G-d, based on the verse «Anochi Hashem Elokecha», «I am Hashem your G-d», the opening of the Aseres HaDibros.
The mitzvah of yichud Hashem, G-d's oneness, which is likewise one of the duties of the heart.
Both are constant mitzvos, binding on a Jew at every single moment, unlike mitzvos that depend on a particular time, such as the arba minim, which come once a year for a single week. Let us try to grasp, briefly, what the mitzvah of emunah is, and what the second mitzvah, yichud, adds to it. We will dwell at greater length on the second one, since that is the subject of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, but in order to reach it we will start in order.
The first mitzvah: faith in Hashem
The Rambam opens Sefer HaMada, the first book of the Yad HaChazakah, with this halachah: «יסוד היסודות ועמוד החכמות לידע שיש שם מצוי ראשון, והוא ממציא כל נמצא, וכל הנמצאים מן שמים וארץ ומה שביניהם לא נמצאו אלא מאמיתת הימצאו», «The foundation of all foundations and the pillar of all wisdom is to know that there is a First Being, who brings every existence into being, and all that exists, heaven and earth and what is between them, exists only from the truth of His being». He then writes that «knowing this matter is a positive commandment, as it says, 'I am Hashem your G-d'».
What is this mitzvah on the level of pshat? On the most superficial reading one might say that the mitzvah is simply to know that there is a Creator. But the Tzemach Tzedek rejects that: this is not the mitzvah, and there is no need for such a command.
Why can that not be the mitzvah? Any mitzvah whatsoever, by its very existence, presupposes that there is Someone commanding it. So before a person even hears the mitzvah, he already knows that there is a commandment and a Commander. It is therefore impossible that the content of the mitzvah should be to know that there is a Commander, for who would be the One commanding you to know this? Necessarily, that knowledge precedes the mitzvos and is not one of them.
Furthermore: that the world has a Creator is a simple matter that plain logic yields, since nothing makes itself. Even a non-Jew can arrive at it. There is no need for a commandment about something like that.
What, then, is the first mitzvah? The mitzvah is to know the particulars of the Creator's existence:
That His existence is the true existence.
That He has no body.
That He has no form of a body.
That His oneness is «echad ha'emes», true oneness.
Each of these points deserves a lengthy explanation, and we will not dwell on them now. We will expand a little only on the last one, to give the ear something to grasp.
What does «echad ha'emes» mean? That He is not composite. Take a person standing before us: he looks like one being, one entity. But is he truly one? He is composed of a body and a soul; his body itself is composed of 248 limbs and 365 sinews; his soul is composed of intellect and emotion; the intellect itself is composed of chochmah, binah and daas; and the emotions are composed of chessed and gevurah, love and fear. He is composed of countless details, except that all these details have joined into one entity, and so we call him «one person». That is «echad hamurkav», a composite oneness, like a puzzle assembled from many pieces into a complete picture, which can still be taken apart so that one can point and say: here is half, here is a quarter.
So it is with every existence in the world, physical and even spiritual. Even a malach is composite. Every existence in the world, on whatever level, is composite. To this the first mitzvah speaks and says: the Creator's existence is not composed of parts. This is true oneness, something our imagination has no grasp of, since for us every existence divides into parts, into cells and particles, and anything can be divided further and further.
All these particulars, that He is echad ha'emes, that He has no body, that He has no form of a body, and that He is the true existence, are the details of the first mitzvah, which every Jew must believe and live with at every moment. This is the mitzvah of emunas haElokus.
It is worth emphasizing: this mitzvah and all its details have nothing at all to do with the relationship between the Creator and the world and its creatures. We are speaking about the Creator's existence as it is in itself, that He is the true existence, that He has no body, that He is not composite, with no reference or relation to the world at all. The world is not yet under discussion here.
[There is the well known story of the Jew who was asked whether he believes in G-d, and answered: «I don't believe, I know». And indeed that is so: that the Creator exists is a simple piece of knowledge, just as a person who sees a cup in front of him does not «believe» in its existence. The emunah demanded of a Jew is not in the fact that He exists, but in the nature of His existence: that it is echad ha'emes, unlimited and uncomposite.]
And how does one bring into one's awareness matters that the imagination cannot hold? First, because the Torah says that this is how it is, and here emunah is what rests upon a person. But that is not enough: there are many maamarim of Chassidus that bring these matters closer to comprehension, and one must learn them. Whoever has not learned will not even know what the term «He has no body» means. Even the Rambam himself, at the beginning of his sefer and in a straightforward way, brings a number of proofs that He has no body, teaching us that the matter can be proven and understood, and that it is a mitzvah to learn and understand as far as one can.
And finally, one must know that the intellect is limited, and whatever we know, there is more beyond it. Up to the boundary the intellect can reach, it is our duty to understand; beyond that, to believe. And the more details a person understands, the higher his emunah rises: what has been understood becomes knowledge for him, and the emunah moves on to a deeper level, and so on without end.
The second mitzvah: yichud Hashem
Let us now move on to the second mitzvah, on which we will dwell at greater length, since it is the subject of this section of Tanya. The Rambam writes: «אלוקה זה אחד הוא, אינו לא שניים ולא יתר על שניים אלא אחד», «This G-d is one; He is not two, nor more than two, but one», and after adding several further expressions on the matter, he writes: «and knowing this matter is a positive commandment, as it says, 'Hashem our G-d, Hashem is one'».
Let us try to understand what this mitzvah means: what achdus Hashem is al pi pshat, then al pi sod, and from there we will come, with G-d's help, to the teaching of the Baal Shem Tov. For to appreciate his chiddush, one must first stand firmly on the foundations.
On the level of pshat, the intent is not the simplest reading of the line, the way a child would understand it, that He is one and not two, meaning that we should not think, G-d forbid, that there are two gods or many gods. As we will see in the first chapter of Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, the Alter Rebbe addresses such a thought and rejects it outright: would it even enter your mind that there is another god, such that a warning would be needed? That is obvious, and it is not what is being spoken about. The Rambam too dismisses it as self evident.
What, then, is the mitzvah of achdus Hashem, which is a great foundation of emunah? What does «He is one and there is no second» mean?
A note before we begin: with each explanation we will try not only to understand it in the abstract, but also to see how it translates into avodas Hashem, how a believing Jew who truly lives with these ideas is meant to live by it.
The pshat, based on the Rambam's words, is this: you must know and believe that the Holy One, blessed be He, is the sole ruler. In the first mitzvah, as we said, there was no discussion at all of the relationship between the Creator and the world, only of His existence in itself. The second mitzvah, however, already relates to the world: a world was created, and its very existence raises a question. How does the existence of the world fit together with the existence of the Creator, and who is running matters here? Does He conduct everything, or does He perhaps have servants who conduct things under Him?
For by a human king, and likewise by any factory manager or manufacturer, the one in charge is not invested in every last detail. He is not capable of it. So he appoints deputies and representatives beneath him who manage affairs, while he himself deals with the large matters and does not get involved in the small details; and if he were asked about some small detail, he would know nothing about it.
Should we say, G-d forbid, the same about the world? It is obvious to us that the world is coarse, lower and lowly relative to the existence of the Creator, who, as we already know from the first mitzvah, is the true existence and perfect oneness. Who, then, conducts this world and who rules it? Are there additional powers ruling here, not, G-d forbid, powers that arose on their own, but powers the Creator set up, and they are the ones conducting and ruling here?
To this the second mitzvah speaks and says: «ה' אלוקינו ה' אחד», «Hashem our G-d, Hashem is one». He is the sole ruler. There is no other ruler, and there is no power separate from Him, G-d forbid, running anything here. Every single detail, down to the smallest and last detail that occurs, He is the one conducting it.
And as it says: «וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ה' הוא האלוקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת, אין עוד», «Know this day and take it to your heart, that Hashem is the G-d in the heavens above and on the earth below, there is nothing else». The plain meaning of the word «Elokim», as Rashi brings in Chumash and as the Gemara has it, is an expression of power and rulership, as in «eilei ha'aretz», the mighty of the land. Accordingly, «that Hashem is the Elokim» means that Hashem is the ruler, and He is the only ruler: there is no other ruler and no separate agency running matters here, but He runs it all.
This is the meaning of the second mitzvah al pi pshat, and this is what a Jew must contemplate at every moment, experience, and live by.
In summary: in this section we introduced that the mitzvos of yichud and emunah are among the taryag mitzvos and among the six constant mitzvos, and are not an innovation of the Tanya. We examined the first mitzvah, emunas haElokus («Anochi Hashem Elokecha»), whose content is not to know that there is a Creator (a simple matter that logic yields and that precedes any commandment), but to know the particulars of His existence: that He is the true existence, that He has no body and no form of a body, and that He is echad ha'emes, not composite, unlike any creature, even a malach. We then opened the second mitzvah, yichud Hashem («Hashem Elokeinu Hashem Echad»), whose meaning al pi pshat concerns the relationship between the Creator and the world: that the Holy One, blessed be He, is the sole ruler, and there is no separate power running even a single detail of creation.
In the next section we will go deeper into the mitzvah of yichud Hashem al pi sod, and from there we will arrive at the chiddush of the Baal Shem Tov and at the Alter Rebbe's unique addition in Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah.