TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chinuch Katan · The Fall Between One Level and the Next, and the Close of the Introduction

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we studied the second level of ahavas Hashem, the level every single person is expected to work on. Now we come to a fascinating point that the Alter Rebbe raises at the close of the introduction: «ובין מדרגה למדרגה, טרם שיגיע למדרגה עליונה ממנה, הוא בבחינת נפילה ממדרגה ראשונה» (and between one level and the next, before he arrives at the level higher than it, he is in a state of having fallen from the first level). Let us first open this up with a few illustrations, and afterwards return to the language of the Tanya itself.

The story of Rav Zeira:

The Gemara tells of Rav Zeira, one of the well known Amoraim, who was fluent in the entire Talmud Bavli. It is known that the Talmud Bavli is called «darkness»: on the verse in Eichah «במחשכים הושיבני» (He has seated me in dark places) the Gemara says this refers to the Talmud of Bavel, in contrast to the Talmud Yerushalmi, which is called «light». On the simple level, the method of study in the Bavli is to build a sevarah and then knock it down, an entire structure erected only to collapse, and until the light finally emerges it is a long and wearying process. In the Yerushalmi the approach to learning is entirely different, and the light shines off the page. (We, who learn both of them on a simple level, do not feel this difference.)

When Rav Zeira wished to move over to the Talmud Yerushalmi, the Gemara relates that he fasted, according to one version, one hundred fasts, so that he would forget the Bavli's method of study. Not, heaven forbid, that he should forget the Torah itself, only the approach to learning, since one cannot come to the Yerushalmi carrying the previous mode of study.

Now, once his prayer was answered and he forgot, Rav Zeira found himself in an in-between state: the approach of the Bavli he had already forgotten, and the learning of the Yerushalmi he had not yet reached. That is what is called a fall. Yet it is obvious that this «fall» of Rav Zeira was immeasurably higher than every level of the ordinary people around him. Only relative to his own earlier level is his situation called a fall.

The parable of the two speakers:

The Rebbe brings a parable for this in one of his letters. In a certain community, during the Yamim Noraim, a gifted speaker came to address the congregation, a man who knew how to set a crowd on fire and move them. He delivered a rousing drashah; the people understood, absorbed it, were stirred, and there was not a dry eye in the hall, everyone was shedding tears.

An hour later a second speaker arrived, more gifted than the first, dealing with deeper matters and with a different subject altogether. In order to grasp what the second speaker is saying, one cannot remain immersed in the first drashah; it has to be set aside so that one can be immersed in the second. And indeed, by the end of the second man's drashah they were not merely shedding tears, they broke into open weeping. He succeeded in arousing them even more, on a deeper level.

But absorbing something takes time. In those moments when the first drashah has already been set aside and the tears have been wiped away, while the new drashah has not yet been digested, what state are they in? That is precisely the state called a fall. And of this it is said, «שבע יפול צדיק וקם» (a tzaddik falls seven times and rises): the tzaddik who climbs from level to level falls seven falls, and each time he gets up and ascends.

What holds a person during the fall?

At the moment of the fall, what remains within him, holding him and guarding him, is that first level, the level of «youth» and of chinuch. This is the meaning of «חנוך לנער על פי דרכו, גם כי יזקין לא יסור ממנה» (train a youth according to his way; even when he grows old he will not depart from it): guard the love of Hashem that you arouse with your own powers, for even when you arrive at deeper and loftier levels, you will not depart from it.

The power contained in the beginning:

  • «זכרתי לך חסד נעורייך»: Reb Hillel Paritcher brings an illustration from the verse in which the Holy One recalls the merits of Israel: «זכרתי לך חסד נעורייך, אהבת כלולותייך, לכתך אחריי במדבר בארץ לא זרועה» (I remember for you the kindness of your youth, the love of your bridal days, how you went after Me in the wilderness, in a land not sown). When did that «going after Me in the wilderness» take place? At yetzias Mitzrayim, when they left without provisions for the road and walked into the desert without knowing where they were headed. Afterwards Israel rose to far higher levels, mattan Torah, the Mishkan, the first Beis Hamikdash, and nevertheless it is the beginning, the first chinuch, that supplies the power, and it is that which accompanies us all the way to the end.

  • The dedication of the mizbeach: At the dedication of the Mishkan the nesi'im of Israel brought the very greatest offerings, as detailed at length in the Torah, offerings of a kind that were never brought again in all the generations. Over the generations the mizbeach perhaps acquired greater qualities, and further korbanos were offered on it, since one rises from level to level, but its basic power was given to it at its dedication. So much so that even today, during the first days of the month of Nissan, we do not say Tachanun, because of the dedication of the mizbeach.

  • Learning a new trade: When a person begins a new and complex job, the instructor sits with him, shows him and teaches him, and joins the apprentice's intelligence to the technique and to the new craft, until he grasps the thing. It is entirely possible that over the years this man will invent new and advanced methods that even his teachers never thought of. But all those innovations are in the category of additions, and in them there can be ups and downs; whereas the foundation he received at the start remains forever, and from that there is no fall.

  • The first melamed: It is told that when the melamed who had taught the Rebbe in the first grade of cheder came in to him, the Rebbe showed him enormous honor, and said that in a certain sense he deserves more honor than the one who taught him Gemara, because he is the one who taught him to read. Reading is the foundation, and upon it the entire structure later stands: one person learns more and another less, but from the foundation he received he never departs.

The Alter Rebbe's words:

«ובין מדרגה למדרגה, טרם שיגיע למדרגה עליונה ממנה, הוא בבחינת נפילה ממדרגה ראשונה, אך 'כי יפול - לא יוטל' כתיב» (and between one level and the next, before he arrives at the higher level, he is in a state of having fallen from the first level; yet it is written, «though he fall, he shall not be cast down»). He is not lying flat on the ground having lost everything, for his fall is from one lofty level toward a level even loftier. «ואינה נקראת נפילה, אלא לגבי מדרגתו הראשונה, ולא לגבי שאר כל אדם חס ושלום, שאף-על-פי-כן, הוא למעלה מכל האדם בעבודתו» (and it is called a fall only relative to his own first level, and not, heaven forbid, relative to everyone else, for even so he is above all other people in his avodah). For someone who never even began to arouse a feeling of love for Hashem in his heart is certainly lower than the one who is mid-fall from a lofty level.

«כי נשאר בה בחינת רשימו ממדרגתו הראשונה» (for there remains in him a reshimu, an imprint, of his first level). An imprint remains. Like a page from which the writing has been erased in order to write on it anew: you can see that it is not a blank page that was never written on, but one in which a trace of the earlier writing remains. So too, the higher level from which he fell leaves an imprint on him even during the fall, just as with Rav Zeira the Bavli's method of study remained in him as a reshimu.

«אך עיקרה, מאהבה שנתחנך והורגל בה מנעוריו, בטרם שהגיע למדרגת צדיק» (but the main part of it comes from the love in which he was trained and accustomed from his youth, before he reached the level of a tzaddik). That first and most basic level, the love he generated himself through hisbonenus even before he reached the level of a tzaddik, does not remain with him as a mere imprint, but in its full strength and force, unchanged. «וזהו שכתוב: גם כי יזקין וגו' [לא יסור ממנה]» (and this is what is written: «even when he grows old» [he will not depart from it]).

The conclusion that emerges from all this: where should a person invest his attention and his time? Precisely in arousing that first level, the foundation, to be trained like a youth and to awaken that basic love of Hashem that belongs to every person through simple hisbonenus. That is the thing that never departs.

It is worth adding that the fall itself is a precondition for the ascent: it is impossible to rise to a higher level without first falling from the previous one. And this is the very same idea found in the Nahar Dinur that separates one Gan Eden from the second Gan Eden, and likewise in the passage from one «yesh» to another «yesh», which must pass through the state of «ayin» in between.

Closing the introduction: the transition to Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah:

Everything we have learned at such length until now is considered an introduction to Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, in which we will study, at great length, twelve chapters of the fundamentals of emunah and of the oneness of Hashem, the most basic matters of all. The whole subject of «chanoch lana'ar al pi darko» and the levels within ahavas Hashem is bound up with this.

Before we look at the final lines, let us go back to a single line in the second column of the previous page. When the Alter Rebbe opened his discussion of the second level of love, the level everyone must occupy himself with, he wrote «שיתבונן היטב בעומקא דליבא» (that he should contemplate well, in the depth of his heart), and contemplate what? «בדברים המעוררים את האהבה לה'» (the things that arouse the love of Hashem). That was the headline sentence, and about it we spoke of the derech klal, the general approach, and the derech prat, the detailed approach.

And now, at the close of the chapter, the Alter Rebbe writes: «והנה ראשית הדברים המעוררים אהבה ויראה ויסודן, היא האמונה הטהורה ונאמנה בייחודו ואחדותו יתברך ויתעלה» (now, the first of the things that arouse love and fear, and their foundation, is the pure and faithful emunah in His Oneness and His unity, blessed and exalted be He). There is a list of things upon which one must meditate, and once they are internalized a person will succeed in arousing the love of Hashem; but with what must he begin? Even before the derech klal and before the derech prat: first one must contemplate the existence of the Creator and the fact that He is One, and what «echad» means and what «yachid» means, as we will see at length further on. Only afterwards does he contemplate how the Holy One is his very life, how great He is, and how far He descends to him.

To summarize: in this section we learned that between one level and the next there exists a state of falling, as we saw in the story of Rav Zeira and in the parable of the two speakers, and as in the saying «a tzaddik falls seven times and rises». This fall is only relative to his own previous level; relative to everyone else he stands above them, since a reshimu of his first level remains within him. And the main thing, which stands in full strength without change, is the love in which he was trained from his youth: «even when he grows old he will not depart from it». We dwelt on the power of the beginning from «chesed ne'urayich», from the dedication of the mizbeach, from learning a trade, and from the first melamed. Finally we saw that the first of the things that arouse love and fear, and their foundation, is the pure emunah in His Oneness and unity, and for this reason everything studied until now is no more than an introduction.

In the next section we will begin, with Hashem's help, to taste Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, and to understand properly what the Oneness of Hashem is and what emunah in Him is, for only afterwards can one begin with «Chinuch Katan».