In the previous section we learned about two kinds of love of G-d: the first love, which is a gift from Above, a flame that rises of its own accord, and the second love, which a person generates himself through hisbonenus (deep, settled contemplation). Now we will see how the Alter Rebbe explains that it is specifically the second love about which the language of a command applies, and from there we will return to the verse «Chanoch lanaar al pi darko, gam ki yazkin lo yasur mimenu», «Educate the youth according to his way, even when he grows old he will not depart from it».
The Alter Rebbe continues: והנה ענין אהבה זו רצה משה רבינו עליו השלום ליטע בלב כל ישראל (« This is the love that Moshe Rabbeinu, peace be upon him, wished to implant in the heart of every Jew »). He means the second love, the one every person can reach with his own powers through hisbonenus. This is what Moshe Rabbeinu sought to plant in the heart of all Israel: that every Jew contemplate the greatness of the Creator and his own smallness, and out of that come to an inner feeling of love for the Creator.
The Alter Rebbe is not pointing to the second love merely in a general way, as opposed to the love of the tzaddikim. He is being more precise than that. Within the second love itself we distinguished between contemplating «in a general way» and contemplating «in a detailed way», and Moshe Rabbeinu was speaking of the detailed way: contemplating just how great He, blessed be He, is, and just how small a person is.
Where do we see that this is his intent? In Parshas Eikev, in the passage «Ve'atah Yisrael», the Alter Rebbe cites a brief sequence of verses, and from the verses themselves you can see the line of thought that Moshe Rabbeinu is setting before the Jewish people: how great the Creator is, and how far He came down to us, the small ones.
הן לה' אלוקיך השמים וגו' (« Behold, to Hashem your G-d belong the heavens »): the greatness of the Creator, that all the heavens are His.
רק באבותיך חשק ה' וגו' (« Only in your fathers did Hashem desire »): and nevertheless He chose the Jewish people.
ומלתם את ערלת לבבכם וגו' (« And you shall circumcise the foreskin of your heart »): the practical demand that follows from this.
בשבעים נפש וגו' (« With seventy souls »): a further contemplation, that our forefathers went down to Egypt as seventy souls, and how vast the nation was that came out from there.
And out of all of this: ואהבת וגו' (« And you shall love »).
This is precisely the style of hisbonenus «in a detailed way». ולכן סיים [Moshe Rabbeinu] דבריו על אהבה זו: אשר אנכי מצווה אתכם לעשותה (« And therefore he concluded his words about this love: which I command you to do »), שהיא אהבה עשויה בלב על ידי הבינה והדעת בדברים המעוררים את האהבה (« for it is a love made in the heart by means of binah and daas, through things that arouse love »). A person really can make and produce this love.
With this, the question we opened with is resolved, the question of the Maggid of Mezritch: how can one be commanded about a feeling? The answer is that the command is not on the feeling itself, but on the path that leads to it, on the hisbonenus. And when a person contemplates not in a sweeping, surface way but deeply, internalizing the matter and becoming one with it until he actually feels the point he is contemplating, then the heart begins to translate it into emotion.
The source of this principle in the Sifri:
About this Moshe Rabbeinu commanded already earlier: והיו הדברים האלה אשר אנכי מצווך היום על לבבך (« And these words which I command you today shall be upon your heart »), כדי שעל ידי זה תבוא לאהבת ה', כדאיתא בספרי על פסוק זה (« so that through this you will come to the love of Hashem, as stated in the Sifri on this verse »).
And this is the language of the Sifri: « 'And you shall love Hashem your G-d with all your heart' - I do not know in what manner one loves the Omnipresent; therefore the verse says, 'And these words which I command you today shall be upon your heart' - for through this you come to recognize the Holy One, blessed be He, and to cleave to His ways. » In other words, when the Holy One, blessed be He, commands a Jew to love Him, the command in practice is to contemplate those things that will lead him to the breaking through of the love of G-d, and out of that hisbonenus he walks in the paths that lead to his Father in Heaven.
Why a command applies specifically to the second love:
Now the Alter Rebbe completes his answer to the question he opened with. At first he focused only on the word «לעשותה», «to do it»: how can love be made? And now that it is clear how one makes it, the word «מצווה», «I command», is understood as well: והנה על אהבה זו השנית שייך לשון מצווה וציווי (« Now with regard to this second love, the language of mitzvah and command applies »), and the command refers to this: לשום לבו ודעתו בדברים המעוררים את האהבה (« to set his heart and his mind on the things that arouse love »).
But the first love, שהיא שלהבת העולה מאליה, לא שייך בה ציווי ומצווה כלל (« which is a flame that rises of its own accord, no command or mitzvah applies to it at all »), for two reasons:
A person does not produce it; it rises and bursts forth on its own from the neshamah, and you cannot send a person to a place that is not within his power to reach.
ולא עוד, אלא שהיא מתן שכרן של צדיקים (« And moreover, it is the reward given to tzaddikim »). A command applies to avodah, to work, whereas this is already the reward for the work.
True, this love is embedded in the neshamah and reveals itself on its own, but not every person merits this revelation. A person can make all the preparations: Torah and good deeds, refining his material self and subduing his soul, and still not necessarily merit it. All that is in his hands is to prepare the ground, as we learned in Tanya in one of the explanations of the words «תהי צדיק», «be a tzaddik»: do what is incumbent upon you, and perhaps the Holy One, blessed be He, will illuminate you and you will merit to be a tzaddik. Perhaps, and perhaps not. And if he merited and the Holy One, blessed be He, brought it about that the inner truth should be revealed in him and burst forth in all its force, that is a gift he received.
This also explains the wording of Chazal, «היום לעשותם ולמחר לקבל שכרם», « today to do them, and tomorrow to receive their reward ». «Today» is this world, the time of doing; «tomorrow» is the receiving of reward in the World to Come, which is the place of souls without bodies. How, then, does the tzaddik receive reward while still in this world? About this the Alter Rebbe uses the expression לטעום מעין עולם הבא בעולם הזה (« to taste something of the World to Come in this world »): the Holy One, blessed be He, gave him a taste of the infinite drawing that exists in the World to Come, as was said of the holy Avos, Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, that He let them taste something of the World to Come in this world. And of this it is said, עבודת מתנה אתן את כהונתכם (« a service of gift I give you, your priesthood »): a gift, as explained in its place (in the previous section, and also in the final part of Tanya).
[Some interpret «olam haba», the World to Come, from the word «ne'elam haba», the hidden that comes, but that is not the Alter Rebbe's intent here. It is worth noting in this context that the World to Come itself is built out of our avodah in this world: we do not merely reveal worlds, we create them.]
«Chanoch lanaar al pi darko, gam ki yazkin lo yasur mimenu»:
With this, the lengthy introduction the Alter Rebbe laid down in order to explain the verse comes to an end: the love of G-d is a great foundation and a great root, and it is demanded of every single person; and in general there are two kinds of love of G-d, the first level, the level of tzaddikim, and the second level, which every person can reach.
First we must be precise in the wording of the verse, which speaks of a «naar», a youth, on the one hand, and «yazkin», growing old, on the other. «Zakein» is one who has acquired wisdom, the level of the tzaddik; «naar» is the basic level that every person can reach. The direction in which the Alter Rebbe explains it is this: a person who begins his avodah of love at the level of the «naar», the first, basic level, must not abandon it even when he reaches the level of a tzaddik. On the face of it, what does he still need the lower level for? To this the verse says: «gam ki yazkin lo yasur mimenu», even when he grows old he will not depart from it. One always needs the foundation.
«Ki sheva yipol tzaddik vakam»:
In the Alter Rebbe's words: אך הנה ידוע ליודעים, טעמא דקרא מאי דכתיב: כי שבע יפול צדיק וקם (« But it is known to those who know the reason of the verse that is written: for seven times the tzaddik falls and rises »). This is not a prophecy of doom; it is a description of the orderly and proper process of the tzaddik. Nor does it mean falling into sins, G-d forbid, for then he would not be called a tzaddik at all, whereas here, throughout all seven of those falls, he is called a tzaddik the entire time.
ובפרט שאדם נקרא מהלך ולא עומד (« And especially since man is called a goer and not a stander »). This is the difference between angels and souls: angels are called «omdim», standers, and souls are called «mehalchim», goers. An angel is created at a particular level, and that is his level; he remains at that same rung and in that same manner for as long as he exists. Of a Jew, by contrast, it is demanded that he be a mehalech, that he advance: the next moment must be higher than the moment before, and next year he must arrive at a level he did not have last year.
And a true «mehalech» is not merely someone who advances gradually, from one rung to the next rung that is proportionate to the one before it. Such progress is good, but it still falls under the category of «omed», standing. A true mehalech is one who cannot be recognized in comparison to what he was before, whose advance bears no proportion whatsoever to his previous state. This is what is always demanded of a Jew: וצריך לילך ממדרגה למדרגה ולא לעמוד במדרגה אחת לעולם (« and he must go from level to level and never stand still at one level »), never to be satisfied with the rung he has reached.
In summary: in this section we learned that «this love which I command you to do» refers to the second love and to hisbonenus «in a detailed way», as emerges from the sequence of verses in the passage «Ve'atah Yisrael». The command is not on the feeling itself but on the hisbonenus that leads to it, as explained in the Sifri on «And these words». Therefore a command applies only to the second love, whereas the first love, the flame that rises of its own accord, is the reward given to tzaddikim: a taste of the World to Come in this world, in the category of «a service of gift». From here we returned to the verse «Chanoch lanaar al pi darko»: «zakein» is the tzaddik who has acquired wisdom, and «naar» is the basic level that must never be abandoned. And we began to look at «for seven times the tzaddik falls and rises», and at man being «a goer and not a stander».
In the next section we will go deeper into the explanation of «for seven times the tzaddik falls and rises», into the meaning of going from level to level, and into how all of this connects to the theme of «chinuch katan», the education of the small one.