TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chinuch Katan · «Train the Youth According to His Way» and the Two Levels of Love

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous part we learned the first half of the introduction to Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, the section called 'Chinuch Katan' (page 75b, p. 150). In this part we will review the main points we covered and add some emphasis on phrases we read but did not stop to examine.

The verse with which the Alter Rebbe opens:

«חנוך לנער על פי דרכו גם כי יזקין לא יסור ממנה» (Mishlei), «Train the youth according to his way; even when he grows old he will not depart from it.» At first glance there is something here that does not make sense. The emphasis is that a child's training must be «according to his way», that is, something personal, suited to the child's own world and his own situation. If so, this is not the optimal path but the path that fits his present condition while he is still a youth. When he grows up and rises to a higher level, it would stand to reason that one should move him on to a loftier path, and that the path of the youth ought to be left behind. Why, then, does the verse say «even when he grows old he will not depart from it», that even in his old age he will not depart from the path on which he was started as a youth?

Ahavas Hashem and yiras Hashem, the root of all avodas Hashem:

To explain this, the Alter Rebbe first establishes that one of the foundational principles of avodas Hashem is love and fear of G-d, which are a great foundation and root for every aspect of divine service. And precisely because ahavas Hashem is such a great root, it belongs to everyone: to those who are small in understanding or in years and to the mature, to the youth and to the elder alike. Just as the keeping of Torah and mitzvos in the simple sense, the 248 positive commandments and the 365 prohibitions, belongs to every single person, and a father's chinuch of his son covers both the positive and the negative commandments, so too it is incumbent upon him to educate his son in the very roots of avodas Hashem: in love at the level that belongs to a youth, and in love at every level all the way up to «when he grows old».

Two kinds of love:

  1. A love that belongs to tzaddikim alone, the soul's natural yearning to expire toward its Creator (kelos hanefesh), which a person cannot produce.

  2. A love that every person can reach, a love that a person makes and creates with his own powers.

The basis for this division lies in the wording of Scripture. Moshe Rabbeinu says in Devarim, in parashas Eikev, «אשר אנכי מצוה אתכם לעשותה לאהבה את ה'», «which I command you to do, to love Hashem». Love of G-d is something that one «does». And from here comes the famous question of the Maggid of Mezritch (in his formulation, on the verse «ואהבת את ה' אלוקיך», «You shall love Hashem your G-d»): how can there be a commandment to love? Love is an emotion of the heart, and what sense is there in commanding an emotion? The answer is that the command is directed at the things that lead to love, namely at hisbonenus, contemplation. And so it is here: there is a love that one can make, for which a person has means at his disposal to create it, broaden it and expand it; and there is a rare love, the love of tzaddikim, which a person cannot produce at all.

The first level: kelos hanefesh:

This love is «כלות הנפש בטבע אל הבורא», the soul's natural expiring toward the Creator, something inward that exists in the very nature of a Jew. What is kelos hanefesh? It is a love whose intensity simply does not fit into the vessels of the body: the soul is seized by so great a thirst that the body cannot contain it and cannot withstand it. The soul feels that the body is in its way, constricting it and concealing it, and therefore it strains toward kelos hanefesh, because the love bursts forth in it with overwhelming force. The intent here is not kelos hanefesh literally, but a movement of the soul, and not in a way that a person is meant to remain in. This is the inner nature of the tzaddik, and this is the higher level.

What is required of a person in order to merit this level:

  1. Removing the obstacles and hindrances: to subdue and humble the materiality, the coarse part of a person, since coarseness and physicality stand in the way of the revelation.

  2. Positive action: refining the material very, very much, together with much Torah and many good deeds, whose purpose is to make the person into a vessel in which the soul, that higher power, can rest.

Subduing the material by itself does not accomplish the matter; it only clears away the obstacles and hindrances. There must also be a revelation of the soul itself, bursting forth within him.

The levels of the soul: inner powers and encompassing powers:

  • In general terms: the soul is called by five names: nefesh, ruach, neshamah, chayah and yechidah. The first three, nefesh, ruach and neshamah, are called inner powers (kochos penimiyim), because they work, operate and become revealed within a person's inner faculties: in intellect, in emotion and in action. Chayah and yechidah, by contrast, are called encompassing powers (kochos makifim), since their revelation does not come through the ten orderly, familiar faculties of the human soul.

  • In the more detailed treatment of chassidus: even among the first three there is a distinction. Nefesh and ruach, when they are revealed in a person, are inner powers: they are revealed within him in a way that he can contain them and integrate his existing faculties with that intensity. But neshamah is an encompassing power: its intensity is so great that when it is revealed, a love for the Creator bursts forth that is not according to the vessels and not according to a person's limited faculties.

This is why, when the Alter Rebbe speaks here of the great tzaddik in whom that great love is revealed, his wording is that he merits neshamah, that the level of neshamah becomes revealed in him.

The explanation of Reb Hillel Paritcher:

At first glance the phrase «refining the material very, very much» seems to be nothing more than a repetition of what was said earlier, to subdue the materiality. But Reb Hillel Paritcher, one of the great chassidim of the Tzemach Tzedek, who wrote a commentary on all of 'Chinuch Katan' and clarifies many points in it, explains that this is not the Alter Rebbe's intent. Subduing the material means removing the obstacles and hindrances: when a person's coarseness and physicality are breaking out, that certainly gets in the way, and first one must subdue it and quiet it. Refining the material is something else entirely: the person succeeds in refining himself to the point that even the pull of the animal side within him is drawn toward G-dly matters, and he becomes pure.

This refinement has a special quality, as explained in the maamar 'Basi LeGani' regarding the nachas ruach that is caused Above and how far the matter reaches, and in the language of the Zohar: «כד אתכפיא סטרא אחרא, אסתלק יקרא דקודשא בריך הוא בכולהו עלמין», «when the sitra achra is subdued, the glory of the Holy One, blessed be He, rises up in all the worlds». In other words, refining the material prepares a person for the very greatest divine revelation. And therefore, since this tzaddik seeks to merit the level of neshamah, he must first act positively through the refinement of his material self.

And even that is not enough; «much Torah and many good deeds» are also required. The greatness of Torah, as we have already learned several times, is that the Holy One, blessed be He, placed and revealed Himself within the Torah, «אנא נפשי כתבית יהבית», «I wrote and gave over My very self», and every word of Torah is a revelation of the Creator Himself. And since the tzaddik seeks to attain something G-dly that is above the vessels, the level of neshamah, abundant Torah study is the means through which this level becomes revealed in him.

After a person does all of these things, which are external actions, it turns out that he never worked on the love directly: he did not contemplate the matters that arouse it. The love bursts forth in him because the neshamah has been revealed within him, and all his actions were only around the edges, either removing obstacles and hindrances, or drawing down the great light by means of his deeds. But once he has done all of these things, the level of neshamah is revealed in him and ahavas Hashem bursts forth in full. This is a level that a person cannot work at and produce by his own powers, and as the Alter Rebbe will say further on, it is a gift from Above.

The second level: a love that a person makes:

This love is created through hisbonenus: the mind acts upon the heart, and out of the contemplation the person arrives at emotion. And since he is the one producing the emotion, the emotion reaches exactly as far as his understanding and grasp reach: the deeper a person's understanding, the loftier his feeling. Still, even the deepest understanding is limited, precisely because the person himself created it. The first level, by contrast, is not limited, because the person does not create it: it is a natural thirst of the soul for G-dliness, present because the soul by its very essence is drawn to G-dliness. That is kelos hanefesh, the soul's natural expiring toward the Creator, the level of neshamah which is above the vessels.

Within hisbonenus itself there are two types, which we learned at length in the previous part and which we will review briefly:

  • Hisbonenus derech klal, general contemplation: a contemplation that is one and the same for every person, that the Holy One, blessed be He, is his very life. Just as a person loves his own life and does everything to avoid losing it, so too, once he recognizes that G-dliness is his life, he will have love for G-dly matters.

  • Hisbonenus derech prat, particular contemplation: a personal contemplation that differs from one person to the next, and this is what was learned at length in the previous section of Tanya, in chapters 46, 47, 48 and 49. On the basis of the verse «כמים הפנים לפנים כן לב האדם לאדם», «as water reflects a face back to a face, so one person's heart to another», a person contemplates the greatness of the Creator and his own smallness, and every single thing the Holy One, blessed be He, does for him: beginning with the general act He did for all of Israel at the Exodus from Egypt, and continuing from there, that in every single day a person is obligated to see himself as if he himself went out of Egypt today, for in every single moment there is an act that the Holy One, blessed be He, does for his sake.

And the more a person grasps the greatness of the Creator, the more he grasps the infinite distance between himself and the Creator, and the more he appreciates what is being given to him. The emotional response to this is love, to return love to the One who gives on his behalf. And since this contemplation depends on how much of the Creator's greatness each person grasps, and on how deeply he is moved by the fact that the greatest of the great descends to give to the smallest of the small, it differs from person to person and is therefore called 'derech prat'. The first contemplation, that the Holy One, blessed be He, is his very life, does not require contemplating the greatness of the Creator and the smallness of man, and is therefore 'derech klal'. This love is one that the person himself creates through his contemplation, and it is about this that Moshe Rabbeinu says «which I command you to do».

To summarize: in this part we reviewed and completed the main points of 'Chinuch Katan'. We looked at the Alter Rebbe's question on the verse «Train the youth according to his way; even when he grows old he will not depart from it», and at his premise that love and fear of G-d are the root of all avodas Hashem, and therefore belong to youth and elder alike. We learned the two kinds of love: the love a person cannot produce, the tzaddikim's kelos hanefesh, the soul's natural expiring toward the Creator, which comes from the revelation of the level of neshamah, an encompassing power, and whose path is subduing the material, refining the material very, very much (as Reb Hillel Paritcher explains) and much Torah and many good deeds, though in the end it is a gift from Above; and the love that a person makes through hisbonenus, both derech klal and derech prat, which is limited according to the measure of his understanding.

In the next part we will continue from where we stopped: page 76a (p. 151), first column, seven lines down, at the word «והנה».