TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 5 · The Partnership of the Attribute of Mercy, the Miracles, and Moshe's Prophecy

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous section we worked through the words of our Sages about the partnership of the attribute of mercy with the attribute of judgment in the act of creation. The conclusion was that the tzimtzum itself is part of the creation, and with that the whole picture turns over: until now we understood that the essence of creation is the power of chesed, and gevurah is only a junior partner, but it is not so. The world was created with the attribute of gevurah, the attribute of judgment, and it was certainly created with chesed as well, except that the chesed is hidden inside it and reveals itself according to the times.

And so, when a tzaddik tells a person to begin putting on tefillin or to have his mezuzos checked and then the matter works itself out, nothing new has been invented. What has happened is that something already present, already planted inside the creation, has been revealed. Sometimes a person has to do something in order to be worthy that the matter be revealed to him, but the matter itself is planted inside every single thing.

There is tremendous encouragement here for a Jew not to lose his nerve. By nature the situation looks a certain way, and yet the Rebbe wrote time and again: keep Torah and mitzvos and everything will work out. How will it work out, when everything looks sealed shut and dark? Because inside this very world the attribute of mercy is also planted, part of the creation itself, and when the sea needs to split, the sea splits. That is the way to look at it.

Let us add one more foundation that strengthens our view of gevurah and of the attribute of judgment as Divine forces acting actively within creation.

«והנה על זה אמרו בזוהר, דלעילא בסטרא דקדושה עילאה», that is, on high, on the side of the supernal holiness, «אית ימינא ואית שמאלא דהיינו חסד וגבורה»: there is a right and there is a left, which are chesed and gevurah. The power of gevurah on the left comes from that very same supernal source. One cannot say that the right, the power of giving, is the Divine force, while the tzimtzum is some sort of malfunction built into the order of hishtalshelus that hides the Divine truth from the creatures. From the very same place from which the Holy One creates, from there He also gives the capacity to conceal and to hide, and as a result there exists the avodah of Yisrael in Torah and mitzvos, in reward and punishment.

In the Alter Rebbe's words: «דשתיהן הן מידות אלוקות למעלה משכל הנבראים והשגתם», both of them are Divine attributes beyond the intellect and grasp of created beings. Just as a creature cannot comprehend the power that creates, so he cannot comprehend the power that conceals and hides, as we elaborated in earlier lessons. And why is it beyond his intellect? «דאיהו וגרמוהי חד», He and His instruments are one, in the world of Atzilus: the light and the vessel, the Creator and His powers, are one. And just as a creature cannot grasp Him, so he cannot grasp His attributes and His powers, for they are all Elokus. This is the peak of revelation, where it is seen that chesed and gevurah are both true, and that gevurah is not a concealment at all, since it is all part of Him.

The question on the tzaddikim and on Moshe Rabbeinu:

This sharpens the question we raised earlier. What takes place in Atzilus is seen by the tzaddikim, and for those tzaddikim who live with the vision of Atzilus, the yemina and the semala are all Elokus. And if it is all Elokus, there is no covering; and if there is no covering, there would seem to be no point in Torah and mitzvos, since everything is already open before their eyes.

True, about Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov it is stated in the first part of Tanya that they were a merkavah of Atzilus, a chariot to the Divine will. But they lived before Mattan Torah, and therefore they were a merkavah only from the side of the neshamah, while the physical body was not on that level and not in that manner, since at that time there was still a disconnect between the upper worlds and the lower, and before Mattan Torah there was no revealed Elokus in a physical body and in the physical world.

So the question is really asked about Moshe Rabbeinu. He is after Mattan Torah, a neshamah of Atzilus and a merkavah of Atzilus, who sees what takes place in the very highest world, and for him this is not only from the side of the neshamah but from the side of the body as well. If so, he sees the Divine truth in its fullest form, so why would he need to put on tefillin? Before the tefillin and after the tefillin, it is all Elokus.

The Alter Rebbe answers that concealment and hiddenness operate even by Moshe Rabbeinu. Although he sees the world of Atzilus, he does not see it as it is, but as it descends through various screens. And although there is simply no comparison between him and the rest of created beings, still, even for Moshe Rabbeinu this is not Atzilus as it is in itself. Let us read the words, and although we are dealing with concepts we have no real grasp of, from understanding the words themselves we will see that even he is affected by the attribute of judgment and by tzimtzum, and consequently that there is a certain concealment by him too, which his Torah and mitzvos remove:

«ואף השגת משה רבנו עליו השלום בנבואתו לא היתה בעולם האצילות אלא על ידי התלבשותו בעולם הבריאה. ואף גם זאת לא בשתי מידות אלו - חסד וגבורה, אלא על ידי התלבשותן במידות שלמטה מהן במדרגה, שהן מידות נצח הוד ויסוד - כמו שכתוב בשער הנבואה»: even the comprehension of Moshe Rabbeinu, peace be upon him, in his prophecy, was not in the world of Atzilus, but only through its enclothement in the world of Beriah; and even that was not in these two attributes of chesed and gevurah themselves, but through their enclothement in the attributes below them in rank, namely netzach, hod and yesod, as is written in Shaar HaNevuah.

First, note the precision of the word «בנבואתו», in his prophecy. Moshe Rabbeinu himself had levels, and at the moment of prophecy he is at the very peak of peaks, as it is said, «there never arose in Yisrael a prophet like Moshe». The other prophets, when receiving prophecy, would fall and tremble and their strength would give way, as the Rambam details; Moshe Rabbeinu stood in his prophecy on his own feet. His physical body was a direct vessel for the highest level, and no change came over him as a result of the enormous revelation, because he was a vessel for it. And if he was such a vessel, and attained the highest comprehension even in his physical body, why should Torah and mitzvos be relevant to him at all?

We will not enter here into every detail of the explanations, but the general direction is this: Moshe Rabbeinu's comprehension of chesed and gevurah was not as they are in Atzilus, where everything is Elokus in revelation, but as chesed and gevurah descend into the world of Beriah; and even within Beriah itself, not chesed and gevurah themselves, but as they are revealed in the attributes that branch out from them, as is known that netzach branches out from chesed and hod from gevurah, that is, netzach, hod and yesod of Beriah. And since even Moshe Rabbeinu did not have the highest revelation, Torah and mitzvos are relevant to him too, for through them he pierces the screen in order to reach the higher mode.

It emerges that in Atzilus itself there is no concept of Torah and mitzvos at all, and even in Beriah it is not in revelation except by way of a great tzimtzum.

The comprehension of the souls in Gan Eden:

From here we come to the question with which the chapter concludes. If even in the worlds of Beriah, Yetzirah and Asiyah there is no state of revelation, then where is Gan Eden? We already learned in the first part of Tanya that Gan Eden, whether the higher or the lower, is in the world of Beriah, and that is where the souls are, and there they attain a comprehension of Elokus. How can they comprehend Elokus if comprehension is not relevant there?

On this the Alter Rebbe explains, «רק שמתן שכרן של צדיקים בגן עדן הוא השגת התפשטות החיות והאור הנמשך משתי מידות אלו חסד וגבורה», that the reward given to the tzaddikim in Gan Eden is the comprehension of the spreading forth of the life force and light drawn from these two attributes, chesed and gevurah. The souls in Gan Eden do indeed receive the revelation of chesed and gevurah in Beriah, and not by way of their descent into netzach, hod and yesod, but from chesed and gevurah themselves. «והוא מזון נשמות הצדיקים שעסקו בתורה לשמה בעולם הזה», and this is the food of the souls of the tzaddikim who occupied themselves with Torah lishmah in this world. «Food» here is not literal, for there is no physical food there; it is a metaphor for something that penetrates inwardly. The soul becomes inwardly fused with this lofty level, the way food becomes part of a person.

And how is this possible, when even Beriah is subject to the concealment of tzimtzum? The Alter Rebbe continues: «כי מהתפשטות שתי מידות אלו נמתח רקיע על הנשמות שבגן עדן, ורקיע זה נקרא רזא דאורייתא, ובו סוד כ"ב אותיות התורה הנתונה משתי מידות אלו, כדכתיב 'מימינו אש דת למו'»: from the spreading forth of these two attributes a firmament is stretched over the souls in Gan Eden, and this firmament is called raza d'Oraisa, the secret of Torah, and in it is the mystery of the twenty two letters of the Torah which was given from these two attributes, as it is written, «from His right hand a fiery law was given to them». «Right» is chesed and «fire» is gevurah. The Torah itself includes both opposites, and therefore it gives both of them the power to coexist.

And this is a wonder of wonders. Had there been revelation without any covering, Gan Eden would have been nullified entirely, as we learned at the end of chapter three, that revelation without concealment brings about the complete nullification of the creature. The souls cannot ascend to Atzilus; they remain in Beriah. So if the revelation there were as it is in itself, there would be no Gan Eden. But the power of the Torah, which includes right and left as one, enables the soul to feel the greatest revelation and nevertheless to remain a metzius, an existing something: a union of opposites.

And the words continue: «ומרקיע זה נוטף טל למזון הנשמות, דהיינו ידיעת סוד כ"ב אותיות התורה, כי הרקיע הזה הוא סוד הדעת, והתורה היא מזון הנשמות בגן עדן», from this firmament dew drips down as food for the souls, namely the knowledge of the secret of the twenty two letters of the Torah, for this firmament is the mystery of daas, and Torah is the food of the souls in Gan Eden. Since the Torah contains the opposites within itself, the soul is able to grasp Elokus in both its opposites: to grasp the greatest revelation, in whose light its own existence is as nothing, and at the same time to remain a soul with an existence in Gan Eden. That is the power of Torah.

In Torah, in every single subject one studies, one can find opposite sides. The Gemara speaks of one who would give, on every matter, reasons for purity and reasons for impurity; and so too the disputes of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel on one and the same topic, where there is a line of reasoning on the side of chesed and a line of reasoning on the side of gevurah. Torah contains everything, including opposites, and therefore the reward drawn from studying it is the ability to live with those opposites in a state of revelation.

With mitzvos, however, it is different. There are mitzvos whose theme is chesed and mitzvos whose theme is gevurah, but there is no mitzvah that contains both at once: a mitzvah of chesed is chesed, and a mitzvah of gevurah is gevurah. If so, when a soul receives reward for a mitzvah of chesed and comes to grasp and feel the infinite power of chesed within it, it would seem that it must be utterly nullified, and here we cannot answer as we answered regarding Torah, which always contains two opposites.

To this he answers, «והמצוות הן לבושים», the mitzvos are garments. They are not in the category of food that penetrates inwardly, concerning which we had to explain how the soul fuses with it and is not nullified; they are only garments, an encompassing, external connection, and therefore the question of how the soul is not nullified never arises at all. All of this is explained in the Zohar, parshas Vayakhel, and in Eitz Chaim there.

From here it is also understood that in Gan Eden mitzvos are not performed: Torah is studied there, mitzvos are not done. Why? Because if the mitzvah were revealed in Gan Eden as it truly is, Gan Eden would vanish and be nullified, for the power of a mitzvah is beyond all measure. The very fact that we can perform a mitzvah and not be nullified is the wonder of wonders that the Holy One accomplished through the attribute of judgment. In this world we draw down an infinite revelation through a mitzvah and we actually accomplish it, yet we do not feel it or internalize it. A person knows the matter is there, but he does not sense it. [And along these lines is the saying «the reward of a mitzvah is the mitzvah», that the reward is right here in this world, in the very performance of it.]

A parable: a man needs to send an envelope containing a million dollars urgently from one city to another. If he hands it to a trustworthy messenger and tells him what is inside, the messenger will not be able to handle it. He will be checking his pockets every moment lest it have fallen out, taking it out and putting it back, and out of sheer agitation he may even lose it and never arrive with it; not because he wants to steal it, but because he knows what it is worth. Whereas someone who does not know what is inside will slip it into his pocket, walk along calmly, even put it in an outer pocket, and deliver it without any trouble at all, because he does not grasp and does not feel what he is carrying. So it is in this world. The concealment and hiddenness are precisely what give us the ability to perform mitzvos and go on existing; were we to grasp what takes place in the moment of a mitzvah, we would not be here.

In Gan Eden, by contrast, where chesed and gevurah are in revelation, the soul is incapable of performing a mitzvah and cannot even come to it, since it grasps the matter and fuses with it. Therefore in Gan Eden there are no mitzvos, only Torah, and the reward the soul receives for mitzvos is in the category of garments, not food. This principle, that Torah is food for the souls and mitzvos are garments, is explained in other places as well.

[It is worth adding that in Atzilus itself one finds the root of the matter, but not its actual performance. There is no reality of one who performs, since there Elokus is revealed and there is nothing to conceal. We will return to this further on.]

To summarize: in this section we learned that tzimtzum and the attribute of judgment are part of creation and part of its Divine powers, as the Zohar says, that on the side of the supernal holiness «אית ימינא ואית שמאלא», there is a right and there is a left. Both attributes come from one source and both are beyond the grasp of created beings, since in Atzilus «איהו וגרמוהי חד», He and His instruments are one. From this arose the question about the tzaddikim and especially about Moshe Rabbeinu, and we learned that even his comprehension in prophecy was not in Atzilus but through enclothement in Beriah, and there too in netzach, hod and yesod; and therefore Torah and mitzvos are relevant even to him. We also learned that the reward of the tzaddikim in Gan Eden is the comprehension of the life force drawn from these two attributes, in the manner of food, and this is possible through the power of Torah, which includes «right» and «fire», chesed and gevurah, and enables the soul to grasp the revelation and yet remain an existing being; whereas the mitzvos, which do not contain a union of opposites, are in the category of garments only, and they are not performed in Gan Eden.

With this, the parenthetical passage that ran from the end of chapter four through the end of chapter five is complete. In the next section we will return to the subject we were dealing with earlier, and add a few more points to round it out.