TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chapter 5 · Concealment and Revelation from One Single Power, and the Attribute of Judgment

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous part we completed chapter 4 and established the foundation: everything is Elokus, and yet the tzimtzum (the Divine contraction that conceals) is itself a Divine truth. The Holy One created a real state of concealment and hiddenness. That is why a piece of parchment or an animal hide lying in front of a person is not holy in and of itself, even though everything originates in the Divine power. It is the Jew's avodah in Torah and mitzvos that changes it, reveals and awakens, until the Jew becomes a partner in creation; the only question is how much a person will actually accomplish.

Now we begin chapter 5. The entire chapter rests on this very same point and this very same foundation, and the Alter Rebbe expands on it and uses it to explain a number of matters. The length of the discussion flows from the importance of the principle, because it gives us the correct understanding of the fundamentals of emunah and the correct way of looking at things: we must not attribute the concealment to some foreign power and the revelation to a Divine power. One single Divine power produces both of them together, at every single moment.

The opening of the chapter:

«והנה על זה אמרו רז״ל: בתחלה עלה במחשבה לברוא את העולם במדת הדין, ראה שאין העולם מתקיים - שיתף בו מדת רחמים» - «Concerning this our Sages said: At first it arose in His thought to create the world with the attribute of judgment; He saw that the world could not endure, so He joined with it the attribute of mercy.» This is a well known Midrash, already cited by Rashi at the very beginning of the Torah.

How is this teaching understood on the level of pshat, the simple reading? The Holy One wished to conduct the world, to judge people and to act within creation with middas hadin, the attribute of strict judgment, in a rigid way: you did such and such, now receive exactly what is coming to you, with no allowances whatsoever. «He saw that the world could not endure», the world cannot hold up under such severity, and therefore «He joined with it the attribute of mercy.»

Two questions on the simple explanation:

  1. A question of substance: The wording «at first it arose in His thought to create the world with the attribute of judgment» paints a picture of a Creator who is harsh, who wants to deal with everyone through reward and punishment alone. Yet the Holy One is described as One who «desires kindness», and we are commanded to cleave to His ways: as He is merciful, so you be merciful; as He is gracious, so you be gracious. Even in matters of chinuch we teach that the first thought and the last thought must be of goodness and compassion. Why, then, is the very first thought specifically middas hadin?

  2. A question on the wording: According to the simple reading it should have said «it arose in His thought to conduct the world with the attribute of judgment», or «to judge the world with the attribute of judgment.» What does it mean to create with middas hadin? To create means to bring into being, an act of newness, of making and giving, whereas judgment and tzimtzum are by definition restraint, covering and concealment. And if the whole concept of din is to conceal what already exists, then there is no creation here at all, only concealment.

But on the basis of the foundation we learned at the end of chapter 4, everything falls into place. What is middas hadin? It is the tzimtzum. And as we learned, the tzimtzum is not a passive act that merely blocks an incoming light; it is an active act that instills within creation the very sense of distance, limitation and concealment. That is «to create with middas hadin» quite literally: the world was indeed created this way, and it appears the way it does by means of covering, hiddenness and concealment.

This is why we see a table and we see a wall, and we do not see Elokus: because the world was created with middas hadin, by means of the tzimtzum. The world was created with ten utterances, and the ten utterances are the letters, and the letters are the division of the Divine power into each and every creation, and that very division is the tzimtzum, the din. Had the world not been created through these letters, it would not look this way at all.

But the Holy One did not want to leave the world in that state alone, with no higher revelation. For if He had, it would have been nearly impossible for a Jew to reveal Elokus within creation and to effect any change through his avodah in Torah and mitzvos. If a finished, sealed world had been created, this is how it looks and that is that, who could possibly change it and who could introduce revelation into it?

Therefore «He joined with it the attribute of mercy.» And what is middas harachamim? A Divine power that is above the letters and above the tzimtzum, a power which, when you look at it, you see actual revealed Elokus. The Holy One placed into the limited, contracted world the very power that transcends the world.

And note the precise wording: «He joined with it the attribute of mercy», with it, within the creation itself. From the six days of Bereishis, middas harachamim is present inside creation as a full partner, except that it is present in potential.

[At first glance, when we look at the world we see nothing but middas hadin. This is not a statement about hanhagah, how G-d conducts the world, where we certainly do see mercy; it is a precision in the words of our Sages, «to create»: what kind of world did we receive? A world of tzimtzum, a world standing under middas hadin. And indeed throughout the account of creation, from the first day until the sixth, the Torah says only «And Elokim said» and «And Elokim created», all of it with the Name associated with middas hadin. Only afterward does the Torah reveal «on the day that Havayah Elokim made earth and heaven», and the intent is not that a new heaven and earth were created, but that the very same heaven and earth spoken of all along were also made with the Name Havayah.]

Where is middas harachamim found within creation?

The Alter Rebbe answers: «דהיינו התגלות אלוקות ע״י צדיקים ואותות ומופתים שבתורה», «namely, the revelation of Elokus through tzaddikim and through the signs and wonders of the Torah.» The Holy One planted tzaddikim in the world, beginning with Moshe Rabbeinu who performed signs and wonders, and likewise all the tzaddikim throughout the generations. When a tzaddik performs a sign or a wonder he effects a change in nature, an overturning of the natural order, and that is a revelation which is not bound by nature.

Yet even when the revelation takes place, one has to know how to look at it. At the splitting of the Sea, the Jewish people, from the infants to the adults, saw and declared «This is my G-d and I will glorify Him», they recognized actual Elokus. The nations of the world, by contrast, melted away in fear. They saw that something terrifying was happening, but they had no way of identifying it as a revelation of Elokus.

And so it is with all the signs and wonders of every generation: from the splitting of the Sea, through the story in the Gemara of Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa, whose daughter's vinegar burned on Shabbos, all the way to the stories of the Baal Shem Tov and the Rebbes who followed him. All of these are the Divine power that the Holy One joined into creation.

Two questions on the phrase «signs and wonders of the Torah»:

  1. Which Torah is meant? If only the Written Torah, what about all the signs and wonders that came afterward? And even if we say that Torah shebaal peh is included, it is still difficult: what about the tzaddikim from the Baal Shem Tov onward, and before him as well, in whose conduct wonders were plainly seen?

  2. And if the intent is the signs and wonders recorded in the Torah, note that the first sign and wonder we encounter (the burning bush, or the splitting of the Sea) took place thousands of years after the creation of the world. If so, this is not a partnership within creation at all, but an appearance on certain occasions only: when the miracle occurs the partner steps in, and when the miracle ends things revert to middas hadin. Is that a partnership? «He joined with it» implies an active, standing partner, and «with it» means within creation itself.

The answer, as we said, is that middas harachamim is present within creation in potential from the six days of Bereishis. Two sources will clarify this, one from the Gemara and one from the Midrash.

The Gemara in Sanhedrin:

Regarding the wonder Moshe Rabbeinu performed with Korach and his assembly, when the earth swallowed them, the verse says «ואם בריאה יברא ה׳ ופצתה האדמה את פיה», «and if Havayah creates a creation and the earth opens its mouth.» The Gemara says: Moshe said before the Holy One, «if Gehinnom has already been created, well and good; and if not, let Havayah create it.» The Gemara then asks: «What does this mean? If you say literally to create now», did Moshe Rabbeinu really ask that a new creation be brought into being at that moment? But Koheles states «there is nothing new under the sun», meaning that everything that was created was created during the six days of Bereishis and there are no new creations. Rather, the Gemara answers, «to bring the opening close»: Moshe Rabbeinu asked that the very mouth which had already been created during the six days of Bereishis be brought near to that place. And so it is stated explicitly in the Mishnah in Avos: «Ten things were created on the eve of Shabbos at twilight», among them «the mouth of the earth», the very mouth that swallowed Korach and his assembly.

We learn from this that the sign and wonder performed by Moshe Rabbeinu has existed since the creation of the world. The Holy One planted the miracle within creation, and when the day arrived it was revealed in actuality and in a more detailed way.

The Midrash in Bereishis Rabbah:

In the Midrash Rabbah on Bereishis, right at the start of creation, Rabbi Yochanan says: «תנאין התנה הקב״ה עם הים שיהא נקרע לפני ישראל», «The Holy One made a condition with the sea that it should split before Israel.» When the Holy One created the sea during the six days of Bereishis He stipulated with it: waters will flow in you, but when Israel need to pass through, you will open. It emerges that the state of the sea's splitting was built into it at the moment of its creation and is part of it. «הדא הוא דכתיב וישב הים לאיתנו», «as it is written, and the sea returned to its strength.» On the level of pshat «le'eisano» means to its full force and its former state, but the Midrash reads it as «litnao», to its condition (the same letters), to the condition the Holy One stipulated with it: you flow only on condition that you open when the need arises. It opened when it had to, and then returned to flowing as before.

And should you say that this applies to the sea alone, the Midrash continues: «Rabbi Yirmiyah ben Elazar said: not with the sea alone did the Holy One make a condition, but with everything that was created during the six days of Bereishis, as it says, I, My hands stretched out the heavens, and all their hosts I commanded.» And it brings a list of examples:

  • I commanded the sea that it should split before Israel.

  • I commanded the heavens and the earth to be silent before Moshe, as it says «Listen, O heavens.»

  • I commanded the sun and the moon to stand still before Yehoshua, as it says «Sun, stand still over Givon.»

  • I commanded the ravens to sustain Eliyahu, as it says «and the ravens brought him bread.»

  • I commanded the fire not to harm Chananyah, Mishael and Azaryah, who were cast into the fiery furnace.

  • I commanded the lions not to harm Daniel.

  • I commanded the heavens to open at the voice of Yechezkel.

  • I commanded the fish to spit out Yonah.

So we see that middas harachamim, the signs and wonders, which are a Divine revelation above creation, is a partner within creation itself. There is no new power introduced here, since «there is nothing new under the sun»; rather it is a power impressed into creation from its very beginning, which becomes revealed when the time comes.

From here we also understand the phrase «signs and wonders of the Torah.» At the end of chapter 1 the Alter Rebbe emphasized the ten utterances found in the Torah, which contain the power and life force to create yesh me'ayin, something from nothing; in other words, the Torah is the very power of creation. It follows that within those same ten utterances of the Torah, by whose power creation came into being, all the signs and wonders are already contained and hidden away. This is the partnership of middas harachamim within creation.

To summarize: In chapter 5 the Alter Rebbe continues with the same foundation: concealment and revelation alike come from one single Divine power. The teaching «at first it arose in His thought to create the world with middas hadin» is not speaking about hanhagah but about creation itself. Middas hadin is the tzimtzum, and through it the world was created in such a way that it appears as a yesh, an independent existence, rather than as Elokus. «He saw that the world could not endure, so He joined with it middas harachamim»: the Holy One impressed into creation itself a Divine power that transcends the tzimtzum, which is revealed through tzaddikim and through signs and wonders. This power is not a later innovation, but is present in creation in potential from the six days of Bereishis, as explained in the Gemara in Sanhedrin regarding the «mouth of the earth» and in the Midrash regarding the conditions the Holy One made with all of the works of creation; and its source is the ten utterances of the Torah.

In the next part we will continue with the words of the Alter Rebbe in chapter 5 and with the further development of this foundation.