TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Chinuch Katan · Train a Youth According to His Way · Two Levels of Love

Chavrusa LearningBuy the book
Listen0:00 / 0:00

In the previous part we began learning Kuntres Chinuch Katan, the essay that opens Shaar HaYichud VehaEmunah, and we studied the verse in Mishlei with which the Alter Rebbe opens: “חנוך לנער על פי דרכו גם כי יזקין לא יסור ממנה” (Train a youth according to his way; even when he grows old he will not depart from it). In this part we will go deeper into the two levels of ahavas Hashem, the love of the «youth» and the love of the «elder», and into the way a person can awaken love in his own heart.

Let us restate the question. When you educate a youth, you give him only what suits him where he is holding now; the whole hope is that when he matures and grows old he will rise to levels far higher than anything he was accustomed to as a youth. What, then, does Shlomo HaMelech mean when he says «even when he grows old he will not depart from it»?

The precision of the question comes from the wording of the verse itself. Had it said «train a youth according to the way», or «according to the way of Hashem», it would be self understood that he should never depart from it, not in his youth and not in his maturity, since that is always the correct path. But Shlomo HaMelech says specifically «according to his way», the way of the youth, a path pitched at the level of a youth. On the face of it, that is precisely the path he ought to leave behind, since we want him to rise to the way of an elder, to a finer path altogether.

To resolve this, the Alter Rebbe first lays down that the service of Hashem has foundations and roots, and they are ahavah and yirah, love and awe. These foundations are needed by every single person, at every stage of life, whether he stands at the level of an «elder» or at the level of a «youth». Service that is merely technical, with no feeling in it, is liable to weaken, to stop, and eventually to collapse. It is the emotion that gives the avodah vitality, strength, and lasting endurance.

Now we will learn that within ahavas Hashem itself there are two general levels: the level of the tzaddik, called «elder», as in «an elder is one who has acquired wisdom»; and the level of every ordinary person, called «youth». The vast majority of people remain until a hundred and twenty with the love that belongs to the level of «youth», and only exceptionally lofty souls arrive at the love of the «elder». Along comes Shlomo HaMelech and says that even for tzaddikim and great people the rule is «train a youth according to his way»: whoever belongs to the level of a youth must be taught the love of a youth, according to the way of a youth.

Certainly the words are also true in their plain sense: youngsters must be educated in ahavas Hashem, and so must adults. But now we will peel the idea away from its literal sense and transpose it to a deeper plane: «youth» does not mean young in years but a beginning stage of love, and «elder» does not mean old in years but love in its spiritual maturity. And even one who has reached the higher level does not cut himself off from the lower one, because it is not lower at all. It is a sincere, genuine love, with its own distinction and great importance, and it must always be remembered.

Let us look at the Alter Rebbe's own words: “והנה באהבה כתיב בסוף פרשת עקב: אשר אנכי מצוה אתכם לעשותה, לאהבה את ה' וגו'” (Regarding love it is written at the end of Parshas Eikev: which I command you to do, to love Hashem). At the end of Parshas Eikev, Moshe Rabbeinu says about ahavas Hashem that the Holy One commands us to «do» the love.

“וצריך להבין איך שייך לשון עשייה גבי אהבה שבלב” (And one must understand how the term «doing» applies to a love in the heart). The language of doing fits something technical, performed with hands and feet, not an emotion. Can a person be commanded to love? Both expressions, «I command» and «to do it», sit badly with a feeling of the heart. Why, then, does the Torah use the language of doing with regard to love, which is an emotion of the heart?

[One might have suggested that the command refers only to the deed, and that since «the heart is drawn after the actions», the love will then come on its own, as a kind of natural consequence. After all, we see in material matters that a person becomes attached to the work of his own hands and develops feeling toward it. But the plain meaning of the verse is «I command you to do it, to love», that is, the making of the love itself. From here we see that there is indeed a way in which a person creates the love, and we must learn how that is done.]

“אך הענין כי יש שני מיני אהבת ה'” (But the matter is that there are two kinds of love of Hashem). There are two levels: a love a person is able to create with his own powers, which is the love of the «youth»; and a love a person does not create but receives from the Holy One, which is the love of the «elder». The Alter Rebbe actually opens with the higher level, but let us first explain how a person goes about creating love.

The love a person creates: the love of the «youth»

In the inner system the Holy One gave each of us there is intellect and there is emotion. Emotion sits in the heart, intellect in the brain. The Holy One created man with the brain above and the heart beneath it, and this is not merely a technical layout but an instruction in how to use the faculties we were given: if you want to awaken feeling in the heart, begin from the head. There is something situated above the emotions, and when you press from above, something stirs below. That means to contemplate, to think deeply. This is hisbonenus.

An analogy. A person passes someone he does not know, and feels nothing toward him. Then people begin telling him how kindhearted that man is, how he helped him behind the scenes when he was in a tight spot and pulled him out of the situation he was in, and how constantly he looks out for him. Immediately love toward him begins to develop in his heart. And who opened the heart? The brain, which contemplated the man's deeds and his goodness.

In exactly the same way a Jew can contemplate with regard to the Holy One. If a person has no ahavas Hashem, the reason is simple: he has never thought about what the Holy One does for him, and has never reflected that his whole life, his breath, his food, and every arrangement in his affairs come from Him. The hisbonenus can be on the macro level, what the Holy One does for the Jewish people, for his forefathers and their forefathers throughout all of history; and it can be on the micro level, the hashgacha pratis in his own personal life, how things work out and unfold, including things that did not seem good at the time, and only later did it emerge that precisely they were for his benefit, or that the person comes to understand their purpose and accept them.

When a person contemplates truly and gives it real time and thought, it works on him, and the heart begins to stir. He loves the Holy One and wants to keep His mitzvos out of love, because he feels how much the Holy One does for him and how dependent he is on Him. The more he engages in hisbonenus, the more material he has to contemplate, and the deeper his concentration, each according to his own capacities, the more active and powerful his heart will be.

This is the kind of love a person creates himself, and about it the verse says “לעשותה” (to do it). This is the love of the «youth», and this is the level where all of us stand, and all of us are asked to awaken ahavas Hashem in our hearts through hisbonenus.

The natural love: the love of the «elder»

There are Jews who were born from the outset with an unusually lofty soul, whether because the parents prepared it or because the Holy One designated them for a particular purpose and mission in the world, and in them the heart beats with love for Elokus in a way that is constant and cannot be accounted for. They did not create this love; it is a gift from Above. For it is the nature of every Jewish soul to be bound up with the Holy One, except that in them it is revealed, and they are drawn to Him naturally.

Of this level the Alter Rebbe says that it is a love which “היא כלות הנפש בטבעה אל בוראה” (is the soul's natural yearning and expiring toward its Creator), like a candle whose flame strains upward at every moment, because that is its nature. And he adds: “כאשר תתגבר נפש השכלית על החומר ותשפילהו ותכניעהו תחתיה, אזי תתלהב ותתלהט בשלהבת העולה מאליה” (when the nefesh hasichlis, the intellective soul, overpowers the material and lowers it and subdues it beneath itself, then it will blaze and flame with a flame that rises of itself).

Here is the explanation. The neshamah as it is before its descent into a body has its feeling for the Creator fully revealed. The Holy One brought it down into a body, and a body, even the body of a complete tzaddik, is still a body, physical and material. The soul of the tzaddik wants to remain in the very feeling it had beforehand, and therefore it has no need to arouse the love and no need to create it. It needs only to remove the obstruction: to subdue the materiality of the body so that it should not screen off the revelation of the soul. That is «the nefesh hasichlis overpowers the material and lowers it and subdues it beneath itself», and then the flame rises on its own.

Now, a person in whom ahavas Hashem is implanted naturally, does he too need the kind of contemplation that we engage in? He might well say: since the love exists in me anyway, I have no need for the love a person manufactures.

And in truth, one does not reinforce something that exists by its own nature. Think of a glass of water held in a person's hand: by its nature it falls the moment he lets go, and there is no need to tie a string to it and pull it downward so that it will fall with greater certainty. Something that is essential needs no reinforcement.

But sometimes something happens to that glass of water and it is not drawn downward. So too with the tzaddik: «a tzaddik falls seven times and rises». There is such a thing as a tzaddik falling, not in a coarse and crude sense, but a fall nonetheless; and at that moment a screen and a barrier are spread over his natural love. Then he needs to draw on the love of the «youth». This is “חנוך לנער על פי דרכו גם כי יזקין לא יסור ממנה” (Train a youth according to his way; even when he grows old he will not depart from it). Even one who has reached the level of «elder» does not forget the path in which he was trained as a «youth», because there will be times in his life when he will need it, as we will learn at length further on.

Understanding the term «nefesh hasichlis»

Within the soul of every person there are different levels, three in a general sense: the intellect of Elokus, which is the intellect of the neshamah; the nefesh hasichlis, the intellect that grasps the affairs of the world; and the nature of the body.

What is the intellect of the neshamah? We have no real contact with or grasp of that level, but we can get a sense of it from the difference between a human being and an animal. An animal understands only what pertains to its stall, its food, and its young; there is no point explaining an abstract idea to it, it is like talking to a wall. A human being, on the other hand, if you were to speak to him on the level an animal understands, would feel degraded, because he does not belong to that level at all. Now take it a step higher: the neshamah as it is in itself speaks the language of Elokus, and the subjects it absorbs, understands and wants to be occupied with are G-dly matters. Even the most magnificent wisdoms of the world, the ones people invest years of study in and receive degrees for, stand in relation to the intellect of the neshamah like the distance between a human being and an animal, and even more than that.

To summarize: In this part we examined the precision of the verse «train a youth according to his way», and we saw that the foundations of avodas Hashem are love and awe. From the wording «which I command you to do, to love Hashem» we learned that there is a love to which the language of «doing» applies, and from there that «there are two kinds of love of Hashem»: the love of the «youth», a love a person creates himself through the brain's contemplation of the Holy One's goodness and His hashgacha, until the heart is stirred; and the love of the «elder», a natural love that is a gift from Above, in which there is nothing to create but only the materiality of the body to subdue, and then it «will blaze and flame with a flame that rises of itself». We saw that even one who possesses the natural love needs the way of the youth at a moment when a screen is drawn over his love, and this is «even when he grows old he will not depart from it». Finally we began to explain the three levels within the soul: the intellect of the neshamah, the nefesh hasichlis, and the nature of the body.

In the next part we will continue and go deeper into the difference between the intellect of the neshamah, the nefesh hasichlis and the nature of the body, and into the way the nefesh hasichlis subdues the material until the natural love comes into revelation.