TheWholeTorah.aiBeta

Tamid Chapter 5, Mishnah 2: The Last Two Lotteries of the Morning

Chavrusa Learning

Tamid, Chapter 5, Mishnah 2. Our chapter has been following the kohanim into the Lishkat Hagazit, where the morning tefillah was recited, and it now turns to the final two lotteries of the morning service, which were drawn there once the tefillah was finished.

"Chadashim laketoret"

The kohen appointed to supervise the avodah at that stage rose and called out: "Chadashim laketoret, bo'u vehafisu", that is, any kohen who has not yet done the ketoret should step forward and cast lots. Eligibility was restricted: only a kohen who had never performed this particular avodah could join the drawing.

Why was the field limited in this way? Because the Torah attaches a special blessing to the one who offers the ketoret: he becomes wealthy, he is granted help in parnassah. The pasuk mentions the ketoret, "Yasimu ketorah be'apecha", that they place incense before You, and immediately afterward the Torah says "Barech Hashem cheilo", that Hashem should bless his substance. The juxtaposition tells us that the one who brings the ketoret is blessed with riches. Since that is so, the goal was to spread the opportunity among as many kohanim as possible. A kohen who had already offered the ketoret once did not come back for a second turn, and every kohen who had never had the chance was invited into the drawing.

The mishnah records the outcome: "Hifisu, zachah mi shezachah". Lots were cast, and the kohen upon whom the lot fell merited it. He was the one who would bring the ketoret that morning.

"Chadashim im yeshanim"

A second announcement followed from the same kohen: "Chadashim im yeshanim, bo'u vehafisu", new along with old, come forward for the drawing. For this lottery the veterans, kohanim who had already performed this avodah on earlier occasions, joined the newcomers.

Why did this need to be announced explicitly? Because the experienced kohanim had just been told to stand aside for the ketoret lottery. Having stepped off to the sidelines, they might have assumed they were excluded from what followed as well, so the announcement made clear to them that this next drawing was open to everyone.

What was this lottery for? The mishnah says "Mi ma'aleh evarim", which kohen would bring up the limbs, "min hakevesh lamizbe'ach", from the ramp onto the altar. Look back at how the tamid was described earlier: the kohanim who carried the portions of the animal advanced only to the middle of the ramp, and there the portions were salted and set down. This drawing chose the kohen who would collect them from that halfway spot and bring them the rest of the way, up to the surface of the mizbe'ach.

The View of Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov

Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov takes a different view. In his opinion, "Hama'aleh evarim lakevesh", whichever kohen had carried the portions as far as the ramp, "hu ma'aleh otan", he himself continues with them, "al gabei hamizbe'ach", onto the altar itself. On his understanding, no separate lottery was needed to assign this step.

According to Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov, then, the final lottery of the morning served a different purpose: it determined which kohen would take the coals from the outer mizbe'ach and carry them into the heichal, for the offering of the ketoret on the inner altar.